Revelation could have implications for how scientists approach quantum problems.
With particles that can exist in two places at once, the quantum world is often considered to be inherently counterintuitive. Now, a group of scientists has created a video game that follows the laws of quantum mechanics, but at which non-physicist human players excel (J. J. W. H. Sørensen et al. Nature 532, 210–213; 2016).
One implication of the team’s results is that efforts to use computer games to crowdsource solutions to science problems can now be extended to quantum physics. In the past, such gamification projects have been limited to challenging but less mind-bending problems, such as protein folding.
But the work also suggests that the human mind might be more capable of grasping the rules of the bizarre quantum world than previously thought — a revelation that could have implications for how scientists approach quantum physics, says Jacob Sherson, a quantum physicist at Aarhus University, Denmark, who led the study. “Maybe we should allow some of that normal intuition to enter our problem solving,” he says. Scientists studying quantum foundations have also long said that finding a more intuitive approach to quantum physics could help to crack outstanding puzzles, although many doubted that this would ever be possible without new theories.
The game, called Quantum Moves , is based on a real problem in quantum computing: how fast a laser can move an atom between wells in an egg-box-like structure without changing the energy of the atom, which is in a delicate quantum state. In the quantum world, speed and energy are a trade-off limited by Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle, so the trick is to find the sweet spot where the transition from one place to another is as fast as possible without disturbing the quantum state. Endless possible combinations of movement and timing exist, and scientists have designed computer algorithms to try to solve the problem.
We should try to be more spontaneous and intuitive about problem solving.
In the game, an atom is represented by what looks like a liquid sloshing around in a well, which reflects the wave-like nature of a quantum particle. In one level, players move a cursor to control a second well, which they use to collect the sloshing liquid and take it back to a base. The liquid behaves according to the laws of quantum mechanics rather than like an actual bucket of water — for example, to pick up the liquid, players can get it to ‘quantum tunnel’ from one well to another, something that players must learn to adapt to. Once they find ways to transfer the liquid, a computer can then convert their mouse movements to solutions to the real-world quantum egg box.
Sherson’s team got around 300 people to play this level a total of 12,000 times on a volunteer-research platform called ScienceAtHome. The researchers then fed the human solutions into a computer for further refinement. Not only were more than half of the human-inspired solutions more efficient than those produced by just computer algorithms, but the two best hybrid strategies were faster than what the quickest computers had been able to achieve working alone. “I was completely amazed when we saw the results,” says Sherson.
What abilities humans bring to the mix is unclear. Although an interest in physics seems to correlate with ability in the game, success did not correlate with years spent studying quantum physics. Sherson suggests that the superior human strategies stem from the mind’s ability to capture the essence of a problem. Quantum concepts may seem less bizarre to people in a game than they do in other contexts, because it is an environment in which they expect rules to be broken, adds Sabrina Maniscalco of the Turku Centre for Quantum Physics in Finland, who runs an event aimed at making games that might benefit quantum physics.
Adam Levy tries the video game that helps use human intuition to solve quantum problems.
To Sherson, the results also suggest that physicists could use their own intuition more. “We should try to be more spontaneous and intuitive about problem solving,” he says. To that end, his team is building a version of the game in which physicists can tweak the scenario to represent different set-ups, potentially offering them new insights into their work.
Other quantum physicists agree that the finding that people can develop an intuition for quantum processes is surprising, but think that scientists already use intuition to solve quantum problems, at least at the mathematical level. By playing the game, people perhaps gain a form of that intuition, says Seth Lloyd, a physicist at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology in Cambridge. He notes that before babies learn to expect an object to stay where it is, they have a form of quantum intuition, which they lose. “Before three months, if it disappears, they guess that’s just how things are in the world. After three months, they think, ‘Where’d the toy go’?”
Lloyd also says that much of the success of Quantum Moves is due to its clever design, which successfully translates a quantum problem to a visual one, but which could fail with more-complex quantum problems.
Physicists who are trying to develop quantum-computing algorithms already play around with graphical interfaces to help them to improve on existing solutions, says Charles Tahan, a theoretical physicist at the University of Maryland in College Park.
But Tahan does think that teaching quantum intuition through games has benefits. He has developed another game, Meqanic, that gets players to perform basic quantum computations and intuit the rules as they play. He hopes that it could boost student’s abilities and help to find individuals who have an untapped natural flair for the field.
Related links in Nature Research
Physics: Quantum problems solved through games 2016-Apr-13
Rise of the citizen scientist 2015-Aug-18
Quantum physics: What is really real? 2015-May-20
Physics: Quantum computer quest 2014-Dec-03
Physics: Quantum quest 2013-Sep-11
Experts still split about what quantum theory means 2013-Jan-11
Victory for crowdsourced biomolecule design 2012-Jan-22
Related external links
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Gibney, E. Human mind excels at quantum-physics computer game. Nature 532, 160–161 (2016). https://doi.org/10.1038/532160a