2013 Editors' choice

    Adapted extracts from selected News & Views articles published this year.

    Fisheries: Climate change at the dinner table

    Mark R. Payne (Nature 497, 320–321; 2013)

    Nature special: The year in review

    Marine species tend to occupy the full range of temperatures that they can tolerate physiologically, and therefore, on a broad scale, their distributions closely track temperature boundaries in the ocean. Thus, over the multi-decadal to centennial scale, warming, acidification and deoxygenation of the oceans are expected to change the species composition of fish communities in a given region. However, Cheung et al. present startling evidence that global fisheries catches have already changed in a manner associated with the warming trend. Furthermore, they suggest that catch composition in tropical regions has stabilized, implying that these regions have already become too hot for all but the warmest-water species. The fact that the catch composition seems to have reached the terminal hot-water state in these regions means that further warming may reduce fishery yields, if it has not already done so.

    Nature 497, 365–368 (2013).

    Neuroscience: The units of a song

    Todd W. Troyer (Nature 495, 56–57; 2013)


    What is the basic unit of speech? This question has vexed speech and language researchers for decades, and similar questions have challenged those who study songbirds. Whereas behavioural evidence supports the grouping of songs into 100–250-millisecond vocalizations called syllables, neurophysiological data suggest that the premotor areas at high levels in the hierarchy of motor neurons in the brain act more like a clock, providing a continuous stream of activity on a 10-millisecond timescale. Amador et al. reconcile these data, providing evidence that the song code generated by HCV motor neurons in zebra finches (Taeniopygia guttata) is indeed broken into discrete 'gestures', which are significantly shorter than song syllables. Although the clock and gesture hypotheses lead to different views of the motor code for song, it is possible that, whereas bursting activity in HVC neurons tends to align with gesture transitions, enough HVC neurons are active throughout each gesture to sustain clock-like functionality.

    Nature 495, 59–64 (2013).

    Optical devices: Seeing the world through an insect's eyes

    Alexander Borst & Johannes Plett (Nature 497, 47–48; 2013)

    Credit: UNIV. ILLINOIS

    Flies are usually treated with disdain. Most commonly associated with spreading disease, they are at best considered simply annoying. Conversely, flies have also inspired mankind for centuries. An early report along these lines dates back to the seventeenth century, when the young René Descartes, while lying sick in bed, observed a fly walking along the ceiling of his room. Thinking about how he could describe the path of the fly in quantitative terms, he came up with what have become known as Cartesian coordinates. The most recent example of such insect-inspired research is described by Song et al. — the authors have transferred the design of an insect's compound eye to a digital camera. The result is a small, artificial faceted eye with a near-hemispheric field of view, but without off-axis aberration and with an almost infinite depth of field. It could prove a stepping stone towards autonomous navigation of micro aerial vehicles, in their manifold possible uses.

    Nature 497, 95–99 (2013).

    Global health: Persuasive evidence on HIV policy

    Grace John-Stewart (Nature 495, 452–453; 2013)

    As emergency investment to fight HIV/AIDS evolves into a long-term response, it remains crucial to measure the direct and indirect benefits of HIV treatment to sustain investment. Two studies published in Science (Tanser et al. and Bor et al.) show a large increase in the overall population life expectancy and a decrease in new cases of HIV infection after expanded use of antiretroviral therapy in South Africa. Population studies such as these, which involve individuals who may have much lower drug adherence than those participating in carefully controlled clinical trials, are a powerful complement to clinical trials. They give us a sense of impact in the 'real world'. The new studies focus on a fairly specific real world — one in which HIV prevalence was staggeringly high, allowing detection of the impact of therapy on overall adult life expectancy. Nonetheless, the studies are persuasive in the larger landscape of global HIV. These data should persuade policy-makers to sustain or increase investment in this form of therapy.

    Science 339, 966–971 (2013). Science 339, 961–965 (2013)

    Quantum physics: The right ambience for a single spin

    Michael E. Flatté (Nature 503, 205–206; 2013)

    Anyone whose dinner at a favourite restaurant has been ruined by noisy neighbours understands the disruption caused by too much interaction with one's environment. Most electronic spins in a solid are also buffeted by naturally occurring 'noises'. The resilience of single-spin dynamics to these noises is quantified by the spin coherence time or the closely related zero-field spin lifetime. Just as one might make modifications that soundproof a restaurant and thus improve the ambience for diners, so using methods to reduce the noises influencing a single spin leads to long spin coherence times. Unfortunately, these methods also limit the materials in which long spin coherence times can be observed. Miyamachi et al. demonstrate an approach to making a single spin deaf to the dominant noises around it. With a single holmium atom adsorbed on the surface of platinum, they measured a spin lifetime that exceeded 6 minutes — a remarkably high value for any solid-state spin system.

    Nature 503, 242–246 (2013).

    Earth science: Mainly in the plain

    James W. Kirchner & Ken L. Ferrier (Nature 495, 318–319; 2013)


    On million-year timescales, landscapes disappear, gradually consumed by physical erosion and chemical dissolution. How quickly these processes transform Earth's surface has been a question of great interest to geologists and geochemists. But they may have mostly been looking for the answer in the wrong places, Willenbring et al. report in Geology. Geologists have focused their attention on steep terrain, where rapid erosion is thought to drive rapid chemical weathering. However, Willenbring and colleagues say that there is just not enough mountainous terrain to account for much of the global flux of sediment (from erosion) or solutes (from chemical weathering) reaching the oceans. This argument is likely to arouse interest, and some measure of controversy. There are details in the paper that one can argue over. Nonetheless, the authors' analysis suggests that more geologists should climb down from their beloved mountains, to explore the erosion and weathering of the surrounding lowlands.

    Geology 41, 343–346 (2013).

    Social science: The mathematics of murder

    Adeline Lo & James H. Fowler (Nature 501, 170–171; 2013)

    The mass killing on 14 December 2012 at Sandy Hook Elementary School in Newtown, Connecticut, has revived an enduring controversy about gun control in the United States. Gun-control advocates believe that widespread gun ownership increases the rate of gun-related crime and homicide, whereas critics argue that gun availability decreases gun violence because potential assailants are less likely to commit such crimes if they believe citizens are armed. But who is right? Writing in PLoS ONE, Wodarz and Komarova describe a mathematical model designed to answer exactly this question. In an extremely cautious way, they suggest that more guns make things worse. This is social science at its very best. Rather than crafting yet another highly abstract formal model, the authors create a model that is directly relevant to this issue. And rather than overly emphasizing their model's results, they conduct an exercise in caution, highlighting the importance of grounding models in sound and accurate assumptions.

    PLoS ONE 8, e71606 (2013).

    Forum Genetics: A social rearrangement

    (Nature 493, 612–613; 2013)


    Some worker fire ants (Solenopsis invicta) will tolerate multiple queens in their colony, but others only one. It turns out that this behaviour is governed by a gene cluster on an unusual pair of chromosomes. Two scientists describe what these findings mean to the fields of social evolution, genetics and beyond.

    Genes and queens

    Andrew F. G. Bourke

    Social evolution — the evolution of behaviours that have effects beyond the individual — requires genetic variation to influence social behaviour. The fire ant's social polymorphism is associated with inheritance of variants of the gene Gp-9, but Wang et al. show that Gp-9 sits within a supergene containing other genes that are differentially expressed between the two colony forms. The system shows that a multifaceted social trait can be under genetic influence.

    Chromosome mysteries

    Judith E. Mank

    At first glance, it might be difficult to see what, if anything, fire-ant behaviour can tell us about the evolution of sex chromosomes. However, Wang and colleagues show that the fire-ant 'social chromosomes' are, in many ways, similar to X and Y chromosomes. At least one massive inversion on the chromosome that encompasses Gp-9 prevents recombination between the two chromosome forms, in much the same way as we think inversions might prevent recombination between the X and Y chromosomes.

    Nature 493, 664–668 (2013).

    Rights and permissions

    Reprints and Permissions

    About this article

    Cite this article

    2013 Editors' choice. Nature 504, 386–387 (2013). https://doi.org/10.1038/504386a

    Download citation

    Further reading


    By submitting a comment you agree to abide by our Terms and Community Guidelines. If you find something abusive or that does not comply with our terms or guidelines please flag it as inappropriate.


    Nature Briefing

    Sign up for the Nature Briefing newsletter — what matters in science, free to your inbox daily.

    Get the most important science stories of the day, free in your inbox. Sign up for Nature Briefing