Analytical technique promises to match fertilizers to soil in bid to boost yields in Africa.
Efforts to bring chemical fertilizers to sub-Saharan Africa are often met with concerns over harmful environmental and economic side effects. The products improve soil quality — useful in Africa, where soils often lack crucial nutrients — and help to increase yields. But fertilizers are costly for subsistence farmers and can leach into water supplies, leading to health problems. Soil scientists have long wanted to assist poor farmers with their selection and use of fertilizers so that they can better match them with soil types and use less of them.
At the Global Soil Week event in Berlin this week, researchers are presenting analytical tools that could enable them to do just that. Rapid soil-fertility assessment, a new spectroscopy technique used to analyse samples and produce site-specific soil maps for farmers, might help to halve the amount of fertilizer needed to bring food self-sufficiency to sub-Saharan Africa, according to proponents. Critics, however, argue that the technique is impractical and costly, and that organic fertilizers such as manure are cheaper and greener.
Malnourishment affects roughly 223 million people in sub-Saharan Africa — about one-quarter of the region’s total population — according to estimates by the Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) of the United Nations. Most of the region missed out on the ‘green revolution’ that occurred in the late 1940s to the 1960s, which boosted crop yields in other parts of the world. Farmers in some areas of Africa have begun to adopt fertilizers only in the past decade. And, on average, they use just 9 kilograms per hectare each year, compared with more than 200 kilograms used in high-intensity agriculture, such as in Germany. Yields are typically 30–80% lower as a result.
Widespread use of chemical fertilizer has greatly increased food sufficiency in many countries, for example in China and India, but the ecological and health effects of fertilizer chemicals raise serious concerns. China, in particular, is facing a major pollution problem from overuse of nitrogen fertilizer, which can harm air quality and contaminate groundwater, suffocating aquatic life.
To avoid similar problems on African farms, scientists working with local farmers are exploring crop modelling and nutrient management. Field trials to assess the ecological efficiency of organic and chemical fertilizers in different geographic and climatic settings are under way in Ethiopia, Kenya, Malawi, Uganda and Tanzania.
The goal, says Rolf Sommer, an agricultural scientist at the International Center for Tropical Agriculture (CIAT) in Nairobi, is to provide smallholders with easy-to-understand information that will help them to decide what works best, economically and ecologically. To help, researchers at CIAT developed the spectroscopy technique, which uses mid-infrared light, to precisely determine the mineral properties, nutrient content and organic chemistry of sub-Saharan soils. Although still in its infancy, the technology could one day be used to evaluate and map the yield potential of soils across the region — information that would then be relayed to farmers. “If farmers know what fertilizer to use and when to use it, they’ll need less and it will work better,” says Sommer.
Agronomists, he adds, would also be able to make informed recommendations on the right mix and most economical use of fertilizers — a practice that would help to avoid the ecological and monetary costs of fertilizer overuse.
“We do need to increase food productivity in a sustainable way,” says Ronald Vargas, a soils and land management officer at the FAO in Rome. “Understanding the health and condition of tropical soils is a prerequisite for any wise use of fertilizers.” Advances in soil spectroscopy are “very promising”, he adds, and spectral analysis is on the agenda of a special FAO workshop on soil monitoring in Rome this December.
Others are unconvinced. Although soil analysis is “very important”, says Johannes Kotschi, a soil scientist at the Association for Agriculture and Ecology in Marburg, Germany, “the notion that intricate and expensive lab technology will influence farming practices in sub-Saharan Africa is far-fetched”. Soil nutrients and soil acidity can be easily determined with readily available, cheap test strips, he adds.
Kotschi also thinks that organic fertilizers such as manure, compost and plant residues should play a greater part in efforts to increase productivity. “Nitrogen fertilizer isn’t a quick fix to soil problems,” he says. “Its use produces greenhouse gases and it ruins soil fertility rather than improving it.” He points out that many smallholders in sub-Saharan Africa can scarcely afford to buy mineral fertilizers anyway.
Most agricultural scientists acknowledge that applying only chemical fertilizers is not the solution to Africa’s yield problem. But an organic-only solution, favoured by environmental groups such as Greenpeace, will also fall short, says Sommer.
“Conservation agriculture is excessively time-consuming, and organic fertilizer produced on-farm does not replenish soils with nutrients,” he says. “We will need to find solutions that fit local farmers. The times when African farmers blindly applied what Western scientists thought was good for them are definitely over.”
Related links in Nature Research
African agriculture: Dirt poor 2012-Mar-28
Climate-smart agriculture is needed 2011-Mar-02
Phosphate fertilizer warning for China 2010-Sep-29
Nitrogen fertilizer warning for China 2009-Feb-16
Related external links
Alliance for a Green Revolution in Africa
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Schiermeier, Q. Farmers dig into soil quality. Nature 502, 607 (2013). https://doi.org/10.1038/502607a
This article is cited by
Do biochar and polyacrylamide have synergistic effect on net denitrification and ammonia volatilization in saline soils?
Environmental Science and Pollution Research (2021)
Elevation of biochar application as regulator on denitrification/NH3 volatilization in saline soils
Environmental Science and Pollution Research (2021)