The technological potential of masers — the microwave equivalents of lasers — has been thwarted by their impractical operating conditions. A solid-state maser that works at room temperature may change that. See Letter p.353
Noise is an integral part of any electronic system, and it comes in many forms. We are all familiar with the noise that emerges from our radio when we try to listen to a distant station, or the 'snow-like' noise that appears on a detuned television screen. Scientists and engineers have been battling with noise for years, trying to make radio, television and mobile-phone communication better and clearer. In terms of noise reduction, however, the best performance is achieved only when electronic systems are operated at cryogenic temperatures. On page 353 of this issue, Oxborrow et al.1 describe a solid-state microwave source and amplifier that has an exceptionally low noise level and that operates at room temperature. The device may find applications in space communication, radio astronomy and microwave spectroscopy.
Sources of noise can be roughly divided into those that are an intrinsic part of the signal of interest, about which not much can be done, and those that are added to the signal by external components, such as systems of electronic detection, reception or amplification. These extrinsic sources can be minimized, but the proper handling of signals and noise depends greatly on their characteristic frequency. One of the most crucial but challenging frequency bands for signal detection and amplification is the micro- and millimetre-wave range — frequencies of 1–100gigahertz (1gigahertz is 109Hz). This part of the electromagnetic spectrum is commonly used for: surveillance radars; communication for mobile phones; space communication; radio astronomy (including the search for signals coming from extraterrestrial intelligence); and a variety of microwave-spectroscopy techniques.
In the first two of these applications, the noise levels that come with the signal are quite high. This means that low-cost amplifiers and detectors can be used at room temperature without significantly increasing the high intrinsic noise levels, and thus with almost no deterioration in the quality of the measured signals. However, in the other applications mentioned, the intrinsic noise can be very low. This means that considerable sensitivity to weak signals would be gained if the electronic detection and amplification of these signals were almost noiseless.
One of the earliest methods for amplifying faint signals in the microwave range, and still the best one, is based on the use of a maser — a device that performs 'microwave amplification by stimulated emission of radiation'. Masers are the predecessors and radio equivalents of lasers. They were at the centre of at least two Nobel prizes, one awarded to Charles Townes in 1964 for inventing the device, and the other to Arno Penzias and Robert Wilson in 1978 for the discovery of cosmic microwave background radiation — relic radiation from the Big Bang. The latter achievement was made possible only by the use of a maser amplifier whose noise contribution to the signal the researchers were detecting was so small that they had no choice but to 'blame' the background radiation for the noise in their system2.
Masers of the type used in these experiments are based on crystals 'doped' with a paramagnetic substance — one that contains unpaired electron spins. In these systems, most of the unpaired electrons are found at the lowest energy level of the medium. But if the crystal is 'pumped' with microwave radiation, it is possible to reach a situation in which there are more of these electrons in an excited state than in a lower-energy state (a mechanism known as population inversion) and to 'stimulate' them to decay into this lower state and emit radiation of the same frequency and phase as the incident radiation (Fig. 1a). In this way, the microwave radiation passing through the crystal is amplified. This emission and amplification is analogous to that of lasers, but occurs at much lower frequencies.
In such masers, the intrinsic noise, which is mainly caused by spontaneous photon emission, is very low — close to its physical limit. So similar designs are still used today in fundamental science, as well as in advanced space communications and radio-astronomy applications. However, for population inversion to be attained, the masers need to be cooled to liquid-helium temperatures (4.2 kelvin). This, together with their limited output power and the fact that their operation requires a rather large static magnetic field, has led to masers becoming a rare, almost extinct, species. Furthermore, in recent years, microwave technology has advanced so much that the noise levels achieved by cryogenically cooled, conventional semiconductor-based or superconducting amplifiers is comparable to that of masers, but with a much better power and bandwidth performance and far less physical complexity3,4.
Now Oxborrow and colleagues have solved one of the most troubling aspects of solid-state maser operation. They demonstrate a device working at room temperature — a feat not previously achieved even though it has been five decades since the invention of the solid-state maser. They did this by using a special system: a crystal of the organic compound p-terphenyl doped with pentacene molecules. The energy levels of a pentacene molecule can be pumped optically to achieve large population inversion even at room temperature (Fig. 1b). A large population inversion, which leaves few electrons at the lower energy level, is required for the amplification process, and reduces the intrinsic noise of the maser.
In addition, Oxborrow et al. operated the maser using a microwave resonator that has low energy loss. Such low-loss resonators ensure that the device functions as an amplifier rather than as a sophisticated, but expensive, attenuator. In principle, their maser can be used to amplify weak microwave signals that have small intrinsic noise and without the need for any cooling. On the downside, like the 'old-fashioned' solid-state masers, its frequency of operation can be tuned only by an external magnetic field. However, this operational aspect is far less complicated than cryogenic cooling. Several other microwave devices, such as YIG oscillators, which also use external magnetic fields for frequency tuning, are in wide commercial use.
Finally, the authors' optically pumped maser delivers pulses of microwave radiation, rather than continuous signals. Ideally, amplifiers and sources of radiation should be able to operate in a continuous mode, which is more useful than 'part-time' operation. Nevertheless, with additional improvements — such as size reduction, a more efficient light-excitation protocol and the use of several resonators in parallel — the device may be useful for the applications mentioned previously. For example, the new maser can be seen as a first step towards a space-communication capability with which we could talk to extraterrestrials using 'phones' at room temperature.
Oxborrow, M., Breeze, J. D. & Alford, N. M. Nature 488, 353–356 (2012).
Penzias, A. A. & Wilson, R. W. Astrophys. J. 142, 419–421 (1965).
Schleeh, J. IEEE Electron. Device Lett. 33, 664–666 (2012).
Eom, B. H., Day, P. K., LeDuc, H. G. & Zmuidzinas, J. Nature Phys. 8, 623–627 (2012).