Most popular cell lines close to approval for US federal funding.
Two of the most widely used embryonic stem (ES) cell lines could be just weeks away from being eligible for US federal funding. The lines, which were approved under the administration of former president George W. Bush, have spent months in limbo pending the go-ahead from the current administration of President Barack Obama. Researchers' frustrations are boiling over at the amount of time lost because of the delays. "The stem-cell community has really been jerked around," says Julie Baker, an associate professor of genetics at Stanford University, California.
The two key cell lines — known as H9 and H7 — that Baker and others are desperate to see approved were derived more than a decade ago and are owned by the WiCell Research Institute in Madison, Wisconsin. According to a stem-cell registry maintained by the University of Massachusetts Medical School in Worcester, H9 has led to 551 publications, and H7 has been used in 133 reports — an order of magnitude more than any of the other 19 Bush-era lines, with the exception of another heavily used WiCell line called H1, which was approved for federal funding in January.
Under guidelines announced in July 2009 by the US National Institutes of Health (NIH) in Bethesda, Maryland, ES cell lines must meet extensive informed-consent conditions before research using the cells can be funded. Whereas the NIH has approved 51 ES cell lines for federal funding since December 2009, H1 is the only Bush-era line to win the agency's approval so far.
"The H7 [and] H9 submission is still in draft and has not been submitted to the NIH," says NIH spokesman John Burklow, adding that the agency has contacted all of the Bush-era line holders and offered technical assistance in preparing their submissions. "The NIH does recognize that these lines are important to many NIH-funded researchers now and in the future."
Erik Forsberg, executive director of WiCell, says that he expects approval "in the next month or so" for four outstanding WiCell lines, including H7 and H9. "We are extraordinarily close to getting all the documents that we anticipate are needed for approval," he says. But scientists are still concerned that there could be further hitches. "With the Obama administration, we thought things were going to get better, and this is almost worse," says Baker. "If they don't approve these lines, we have to go backwards."
It's crucial that the lines held by WiCell are approved, adds Joseph Itskovitz-Eldor, a stem-cell expert at the Technion-Israel Institute of Technology in Haifa, who helped to derive the four H-lines held by WiCell using donated Israeli embryos. "They are being used so widely. To switch to other cell lines is going to be time-consuming and costly."
Gathering the paperwork needed for the NIH application has been slowed by translation requirements (the original documents are in Hebrew) and other problems. One donating couple had not been informed that the lines could be used commercially and that they would not benefit financially — requirements that are spelled out in the NIH guidelines. Itskovitz-Eldor e-mailed patient re-consent forms, and institutional review board approvals for them, to WiCell on 8 April. "At this point, we have completed our part. But I am sure that more documents will be needed. The whole process may take some weeks or maybe more," he says.
The hoped-for approval can't come soon enough for Baker, who almost exclusively uses H9 in her lab. "The one that's really easy to produce in the lab, which grows well, is H9. That's why all the publications use it," she says. In early March, Baker submitted an NIH grant application to use H9 to examine how ES cells use cell signalling to form endoderm, which gives rise to many internal tissues. If H9 is not approved soon, she plans to write to reviewers and suggest that she switch to using H1. But that would require extra work to extrapolate data she has already generated in "extremely expensive" H9 experiments to H1.
Even if the four outstanding WiCell lines are approved, that still leaves 16 Bush-era lines unapproved. "Obama made his announcement over a year ago and right now there is only one of the [formerly approved] lines on the federal registry," says Tim Kamp, the director of the Stem Cell and Regenerative Medicine Center at the University of Wisconsin–Madison. "Is it going to take another two months? Another year? We just don't know."
Update: On 13 April, WiCell completed its application for the four H lines and submitted it to the NIH.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Wadman, M. Stem-cell funding in sight. Nature 464, 967 (2010). https://doi.org/10.1038/464967a
This article is cited by
Ethical Issues for Clinical Studies That use Human Embryonic Stem Cells: The 2014 Revisions to the Japanese Guidelines
Stem Cell Reviews and Reports (2015)