Skip to main content

Thank you for visiting nature.com. You are using a browser version with limited support for CSS. To obtain the best experience, we recommend you use a more up to date browser (or turn off compatibility mode in Internet Explorer). In the meantime, to ensure continued support, we are displaying the site without styles and JavaScript.

Slow shipping hobbles Chinese science

A lack of laboratory reagents is taking its toll on researchers.

Shanghai

Chemical reagents can take months to arrive in China. Credit: CHINA PHOTOS/GETTY IMAGES

Earlier this year, a researcher in Shanghai requested antibodies from a collaborator at Harvard University. Working with customs and shippers to arrange the transfer, including extra dry ice to keep the materials cool, cost US$1,500 and took well over a month. "It was very tedious and very expensive," says the scientist, who did not want to be identified.

Yet this experience is speedy for China, where reagents, biological materials and other laboratory materials can take weeks or months longer to obtain than in Europe or the United States. With few local suppliers, researchers in China rely on deliveries from overseas. But the shipments regularly get hung up in customs and in a network of distributors, and product quality is sometimes compromised by the tortuous route.

The reagents problem could crimp China's ambitious plans to become one of the top five biotechnology powers by 2020. The Chinese can build a five-star hotel, a highway or a research institute before they can get a mouse from Boston to Beijing. "If a researcher from the United States and I have the same idea at the same time, I won't even try," says Duanqing Pei, director of the Guangzhou Institute of Biomedicine and Health. "I'd never be able to keep up."

Chinese scientists like to say that a 10-million renminbi (US$1.5-million) grant in China will go as far as a $10-million grant in the United States, because labour and overheads are cheaper. But reagents remain some of the biggest expenses — and hassles.

This year's Beijing Olympics made a tough situation even worse. Because of tightened security restrictions, the China branches of Sigma Aldrich, one of the world's biggest suppliers of laboratory reagents, stopped importing from US plants between early August and mid-September. As a result, its China sector was the only one that failed to meet target goals for the company for the third quarter of 2008. Employees at Stealth Peptides International had to drive for two days to bring peptides from its Shanghai headquarters to a contract laboratory in Shenzen, says chief executive Dajun Yang. In Beijing, neuroscientist Minmin Luo of the National Institute of Biological Sciences couldn't get oxygen in compressed tanks, or the radioactive probes to do Southern blots. "It was very bizarre," he says.

Now things are mostly back to normal — that is, normal for China. Researchers share stories of waiting a year for a shipment of basic materials. Yuqiang Ding of the Institute of Neuroscience in Shanghai says that part of the problem is that distributors pile up orders and send them all together to reduce shipment fees. Animals, cell lines or reagents with bovine serum are particularly slow to arrive because of strict regulations and confusion at customs. Knockout mice take six months to arrive from most places, says Luo. Shipping from the United States is often a little faster — about five months — because the greater number of orders has made the paperwork more routine.

The delays mean that interesting leads turned up during experiments frequently have to wait. "Sometimes you just can't plan ahead," says Luo. He often ends up saving the exciting parts of the experiment for later and doing controls — experiments that might not even be needed if the more critical parts don't turn out — until he can get what he needs.

Some researchers have to make substitutions using less-than-ideal alternatives. Luo has applied several times for the right to obtain ketamine from Beijing manufacturers, to no avail. The drug, which can be used recreationally, is tightly controlled in China. Instead he uses phenobarbiturate, which is more difficult to dose than ketamine. "We end up killing some mice," he says. "The experiments go much slower."

Multinational pharmaceutical companies and contract research organizations, which have poured hundreds of millions of dollars into research units in China over the past few years (see _Nature_ 455, 1168–1170; 2008), are not immune to the shortages. Sometimes they innovate around the problem. In one instance, Shanghai-based researchers at GlaxoSmithKline took just a week to express and purify more than 10 milligrams of a protein for assay. It would have cost more than $200,000 and taken at least a month if ordered from a US vendor, says Jingwu Zang, head of the research centre.

But that only works for some reagents. GlaxoSmithKline wants to use its influence and size to sort out the rest. The company intends to increase its staff in China from 200 to 1,000 over the next decade and is pushing local vendors to stock reagents nearby, and others to expedite shipping. It has paid off: some shipments are down to seven days from the United States and one day within China. Zang says he also plans to collaborate with other pharmaceutical companies, many of which are now represented in Shanghai, to establish a centralized local stock facility for all users.

In Guangzhou, Anlong Xu, the vice-president for research at Sun Yat-Sen University, is working to build expertise at the custom houses and exchange agencies that must test and approve imported reagents. "They often don't know how to test the materials, and so they leave them overnight", by which time the dry ice has gone, Xu says. "We can help them." But pulling together the regulatory authorities is a headache; Xu has dedicated one assistant entirely to the task. Luo suggests a quicker alternative: a fast-track system that would accelerate shipments for accredited research institutions.

None of these innovations can arrive too soon for researchers. "Sometimes I feel so frustrated I wonder if I can still do research here," says Luo, who spent nine years in the United States. "It just goes so much faster there."

Authors

Related links

Related links

Related links in Nature Research

Biotechnology@nature.com

Rights and permissions

Reprints and Permissions

About this article

Cite this article

Cyranoski, D. Slow shipping hobbles Chinese science. Nature 456, 550–551 (2008). https://doi.org/10.1038/456550a

Download citation

Further reading

Comments

By submitting a comment you agree to abide by our Terms and Community Guidelines. If you find something abusive or that does not comply with our terms or guidelines please flag it as inappropriate.

Search

Quick links

Nature Briefing

Sign up for the Nature Briefing newsletter — what matters in science, free to your inbox daily.

Get the most important science stories of the day, free in your inbox. Sign up for Nature Briefing