The evolutionary theory of sex ratios should apply to all creatures, both great and small. Experimental studies of the proportions of male to female sex cells of malaria parasites deliver cheering results.
Charles Darwin, the man of 'enlarged curiosity', was particularly curious about sex. He wondered, for example, why males and females are equally abundant in so many species in which males can mate with multiple females. Aren't males in surplus and a waste for such species? Darwin provided an answer, but was concerned primarily with human sex ratios. The question extends to even the single-celled protists, and on page 609 of this issue1 Reece et al. revisit this venerable problem with a study of sex ratios in a protist that is both complex and lethal — the Plasmodium parasite that causes malaria.
Plasmodium prospers by replicating asexually within its vertebrate host, but also produces male and female gametocyte cells for transmission to a blood-feeding insect vector. Sex occurs within the vector, after each female gametocyte develops into a single female gamete, and each male yields several male gametes2. Intuition suggests that a Plasmodium infection's transmission success into the vector would be greatest when just enough male gametocytes are present to mate with all the females. Female-biased sex ratios are indeed common, but an apparent surplus of male gametocytes is routinely seen in some Plasmodium species, and gametocyte sex ratio varies among and even within infections over time2,3,4,5,6. Sex-ratio theory, a mainstay of modern evolutionary biology, offers explanations for these observations, but experimental verification has long been lacking.
Reece et al.1 report that rodent malaria parasites follow sex-ratio theory quite well. Their elegant experiments show that each parasite clone shifts its ratio of male and female gametocytes according to the density of gametocytes in the blood, the fecundity of each male gametocyte and the likelihood of selfing (that is, union of male and female cells from the same clone). But Plasmodium also surprises with an additional talent — the parasite seems to detect kin and non-kin in the infection, and even the proportions of each.
Darwin provided a verbal explanation for the occurrence of equal proportions of males and females (Carl Düsing supplied the algebraic treatment a decade later)7. When sex ratio is biased, the less-common gender will have, on average, higher fitness, strictly because it will claim more offspring in the next generation. Mothers that produce offspring of the less-common gender would thus expect more 'grand offspring'. The equilibrium sex ratio would be 1:1. Almost a century later, W. D. Hamilton recognized that this model holds only for outbred populations8. In a species that reproduces in patches in which sisters mate only with brothers, a mother's fitness depends on reducing competition among her sons for mates. Thus, just enough sons should be produced to mate with all the daughters. As the degree of mating between siblings declines within patches, the sex ratio should shift towards more equal representation of males and females. Humans show a 1:1 sex ratio because we are so well outbred.
Hamilton's model fits the life history of malaria parasites9. All mating of Plasmodium gametes occurs in a single blood meal within the vector. If an infection consists of a single genotype, or clone, of parasites, the optimal sex ratio for that clone would be one male gametocyte to f female gametocytes, where f is the fecundity of the male, or the number of gametes it produces. In mixed-clone infections, the optimal sex ratio for each genotype depends on the likelihood of selfing, and will shift appropriately towards more males. Hamilton's simple equations allow predictions of expected sex ratios (Fig. 1).
Two additions must be mentioned to account for wrinkles in the Plasmodium life cycle. First, the sex ratio of several Plasmodium species is female-biased early in the infection, but shifts towards more males as the infection ages5,6. When the host mounts an immune attack against the parasite, carry-over of antibodies in the blood meal will kill many male gametes. Male fecundity will decline and more male gametocytes should be produced. Second, low-density infections may result in few gametocytes being transmitted, so male gametes cannot find a female. 'Fertility insurance' would then drive the production of more males10.
The Reece group1 used well-characterized clones of Plasmodium chabaudi originally isolated from the natural host, African thicket rats (Thamnomys), and then inoculated into laboratory mice to initiate experimental infections. Real-time application of the polymerase chain reaction allowed quantification of specific genetic strains and precise measurement of sex ratio.
The authors found that single-clone infections were female-biased early on, but that over time the sex ratio shifted towards males. Single-clone infections should yield 11% male gametocytes early in an infection if f = 8 as per malariology lore. Four of the clones behaved according to theory. The two others produced more males, so we can predict the fecundity of these as 1 (the clone designated DK) and 4 (CR) (Fig. 1). Mixing all six clones should give 42% males, and this is just what was observed for the first six days of the infections. This outcome could be spurious if the DK clone dominates in infections (with its high male production), but this clone is known to be a poor competitor and to have low density in mixed infections. Mixing clones two-by-two, the expected result is 25% males, if both clones are equally abundant. But only one clone behaved as expected, with the others producing too few males.
However, Reece et al. determined the relative abundance of each clone, finding a negative correlation between the proportion of each parasite clone and its proportion of male gametocytes; when a clone predominated, it was more likely to self, and so produced fewer male cells. Finally, infections with a low density of gametocytes produced more males, even when only a single clone was present, which matches the expectations of fertility insurance.
These results should give cheer to fans of sex-ratio theory because the theory applies even for protist parasites dwelling within blood cells. Hamilton's equations are so simple, yet work so well. This is the real wonder of Reece and colleagues' study; it is as though this 'simple' parasite knows a little algebra.
Further questions have arisen, of course. There seems to be genetic variation for male fecundity (among isolates); why should this be? How does the parasite recognize its own density in the host, and — even more vexing — how does it monitor the presence of kin versus non-kin in other blood cells? Finally, Reece and colleagues' experiments are a study in evolutionary ecology, but in this case the parasite and host have not coevolved, and the ecology is foreign. When a parasite of thicket rats enters a lab mouse, it meets a strange environment. Yet the protist follows the rules laid down in sex-ratio theory. Getting the gametocyte sex ratio right seems to be crucial for Plasmodium, no matter what host it visits. Once again, when dealing with sex, it seems that getting it right is all-important.
Reece, S. E., Drew, D. R. & Gardner, A. Nature 453, 609–614 (2008).
Read, A. F. et al. in Sex Ratios: Concepts and Research Methods (ed. Hardy, I. C. W.) 314–332 (Cambridge Univ. Press, 2002).
Schall, J. J. Adv. Parasitol. 37, 255–333 (1996).
Osgood, S. M. & Schall, J. J. Parasitology 128, 23–29 (2004).
Paul, R. E. L., Coulson, T. N., Raibaud, A. & Brey, P. T. Science 287, 128–131 (2000).
Paul, R. E. L., Brey, P. T. & Robert, V. Trends Parasitol. 18, 32–38 (2002).
Edwards, A. W. F. Am. Nat. 151, 564–569 (1998).
Hamilton, W. D. Science 156, 477–488 (1967).
Read, A. F., Narara, A., Nee, S., Keymer, A. E. & Day, K. P. Parasitology 104, 387–395 (1992).
West, S. A., Smith, T. G., Nee, S. & Read, A. F. J. Parasitol. 88, 258–263 (2002).
About this article
The Dynamics of Sex Ratio Evolution: The Impact of Males as Passive Gene Carriers on Multilevel Selection
Dynamic Games and Applications (2018)
Journal of Eukaryotic Microbiology (2016)
Evolutionary implications for the determination of gametocyte sex ratios under fecundity variation for the malaria parasite
Journal of Theoretical Biology (2016)
Evidence of taxa-, clone-, and kin-discrimination in protists: ecological and evolutionary implications
Evolutionary Ecology (2014)
Malaria's Missing Number: Calculating the Human Component of R0 by a Within-Host Mechanistic Model of Plasmodium falciparum Infection and Transmission
PLoS Computational Biology (2013)