Net losses pose extinction risk for porpoise

San Diego

In peril: at least six vaquita have died this year after being accidentally caught in fishing nets. Credit: A. ROBLES

One of the world's most endangered marine mammals is dying in fishing nets at an alarming rate in the Gulf of California off Mexico, prompting fears that the species could soon be extinct.

Mexican scientists have confirmed that at least six of the porpoises, called vaquita (Phocoena sinus), have died in nets in the past six months. This level of reported deaths by fishermen is unprecedented, scientists say — and many more may actually be dying.

“At this rate, the species will not survive very long,” says marine mammalogist Lorenzo Rojas Bracho, coordinator of Mexico's National Marine Mammal Programme in Ensenada.

The vaquita is now only found in the Gulf of California. Its population has dwindled to less than 600 animals after years of being accidentally snagged in the nets of large trawlers and small boats called pangas as they fish for shrimp and fish. The porpoises have been considered critically endangered by Mexican and international agencies for a decade.

In 1993 the Mexican government established a reserve area, including a no-fishing zone, in the upper Gulf, where fresh water trickling into the Gulf from the Colorado River is thought to provide ideal conditions for fish that the vaquita feeds on. But Mexican officials and scientists say that commercial shrimp trawlers and pangas are continuing to fish the reserve illegally.

Fishing-industry officials and some members of the Mexican government blame the disappearance of the vaquita on US-owned dams in the Colorado River, which limits the amount of fresh water flowing into the estuary and may cut down the vaquita's food supply. But marine scientists who monitor the vaquita are unanimous that fishing nets are the main culprit. “Fishing clearly is the greatest threat,” says Jay Barlow, a marine mammalogist at the Southwest Fisheries Science Center in La Jolla and a member of the recovery team.

Environmental groups including The Nature Conservancy, the WWF and Conservation International have devised a viable plan to save the porpoises, says Exequiel Ezcurra, president of Mexico's National Institute of Ecology in Mexico City. They propose that the Mexican government divert US$50 million, currently used to subsidize fuel prices for the shrimp trawling industry, to instead purchase trawlers and decommission them. This would leave more fish for the panga fishermen, who would be encouraged to use fish traps and other methods that do not endanger the vaquita as gill nets do.

Ezcurra says the plan has not been implemented because the trawling industry won't give up its ships or make long-term commitments to halt fishing in the area. Industry groups did not respond to interview requests from Nature.

“I personally feel that the plan is the only ray of hope for the vaquita,” says Ezcurra. “I am pushing for it very strongly.”


Rights and permissions

Reprints and Permissions

About this article

Cite this article

Dalton, R. Net losses pose extinction risk for porpoise. Nature 429, 590 (2004).

Download citation

Further reading


By submitting a comment you agree to abide by our Terms and Community Guidelines. If you find something abusive or that does not comply with our terms or guidelines please flag it as inappropriate.


Nature Briefing

Sign up for the Nature Briefing newsletter — what matters in science, free to your inbox daily.

Get the most important science stories of the day, free in your inbox. Sign up for Nature Briefing