Strength in unity

    Adapting to reunification has been a painful process for much of the scientific community in the former East Germany. But the city of Magdeburg has shown how a successful outcome can be achieved.

    It is a truism that upbringing influences character. Nowhere is this more clearly demonstrated than in the research institutes in the former German Democratic Republic, where, in the period since reunification, west and east German scientists have been thrown together, often uncomfortably. During the restructuring of research organizations along western lines, for example, many senior east German academics lost their jobs to west Germans when most academic posts were opened to competition. Some were deemed unemployable because of their political past. Others were simply not felt to be at the cutting edge of research.

    Five years after completion of this unique exercise in social engineering, however, some of the rewards are now emerging. Magdeburg is a shining example (see page 725). The quality of research now being undertaken, particularly in the neurosciences, is as high as anywhere in west Germany. East German scientists who kept their posts say their work in more interesting and fulfilling than before; west Germans appreciate the opportunity to build something new and significant, particularly at a time when support for research has contracted in the west. So good is the current situation that one senior researcher last year turned down a prestigious chair in Bonn to continue his research in Magdeburg.

    But the undercurrents created by a strong and continuing east-west culture clash tell a different story. West German scientists are frustrated by the tendency towards a bureaucratic and cautious approach to problems of east Germans, brought up in a society where it was unwise to have strong opinions, or to make decisions without the support of one's superiors. Appeals to eastern researchers from western colleagues to use their initiative are still sometimes seen by the former as potential traps.

    East German scientists continue to resent what they feel to be colonization by westerners who tend to dismiss their entire pre-reunification lives as having little value, and western values that have ruined the careers of many former colleagues. They often view their new west German bosses as arrogant and aggressive in their demand for constant progress, and see an enforced continual competition for jobs and research money as unnecessarily stressful.

    In practice, the two sides usually manage to work well together, largely because, whatever the underlying tensions, it is easier, more fun and more satisfying for a researcher from the east to work in a well-equipped modern laboratory, with much greater personal freedom than before. But, understandably, experienced researchers seldom choose to mix socially.

    It is therefore reassuring to see how, only eight years after reunification, young scientists already appear free of the same tensions. Those who were still undergraduates in 1990 have been brought up under a single system of research training, and, moreover, appear able to enjoy one another's company both during and after working hours unburdened by recent history. This, together with the high calibre of the research staff appointed from the west — by no means the case in all parts of east Germany — has been an essential element in the success of Magdeburg in establishing itself as a centre of research excellence. It is also a hopeful sign for the future of German science.

    Rights and permissions

    Reprints and Permissions

    About this article

    Cite this article

    Strength in unity. Nature 393, 717 (1998).

    Download citation

    Further reading


    By submitting a comment you agree to abide by our Terms and Community Guidelines. If you find something abusive or that does not comply with our terms or guidelines please flag it as inappropriate.