A comparison of CD34⁺ cell selected and unselected autologous peripheral blood stem cell transplantation for multiple myeloma: a case controlled analysis

Abstract

Following ASCT for multiple myeloma, it is unclear whether relapse is due solely to the presence of residual myeloma cells after myeloablation, or whether it is in part attributable to contamination of the stem cell harvest with viable malignant cells. Positive selection of CD34⁺ cells markedly reduces plasma cell contamination. We performed a case controlled analysis in which 15 patients with myeloma who underwent autologous PBSCT with CD34⁺cell selection using the Ceprate System (index group), were compared with 15 matched controls. All subjects received an identical preparative regimen. The median times to neutrophils ⩾0.5 × 10⁹/l and unsupported platelets ⩾50 × 10⁹/l were 14 and 23 days for the CD34⁺cell selected group and 11 (P = 0.03) and 14 (P = 0.029) for the case controls. Median follow-up of purged patients from autologous PBSCT was 32 months (range 18–43). At 36 months, the probability of PFS was 47 ± 14% and 46 ± 14% in the index and control groups (P = 0.44). The 3 year probability of OS was 69 ± 13% for the CD34⁺ cell selected arm and 66 ± 12.4% in unpurged patients (P = 0.91). Median PFS for the cell selected group is 24 months (CI 19.1–36.0), and 29 months for controls (CI 7.1–50.9). Eleven patients undergoing cell selection remain alive, seven of whom are progression free. At the same time-point after unpurged autologous PBSCT, the corresponding figures are 12 patients alive, with seven remaining progression free. Autologous PBSCT with CD34⁺ cell selection is both feasible and safe, but results in delayed engraftment as compared to case controls. The 3 year probability of PFS and OS in the cell selected arm was similar to that of the unpurged controls. Our findings indicate that autologous PBSCT with CD34⁺ cell selection appears not to have any favourable effect on disease progression. However, the results of this case controlled analysis should be cautiously interpreted, and the role of CD34⁺ selection in autologous PBSCT should be further investigated by large randomised trials.