Rules of Nomenclature

Article metrics


In your review of Mr. Massee's monograph of the Myxogastres (NATURE, p. 365) I notice the sentence, “Under the generally accepted rules of nomenclature, this leads to Massee standing as the authority for many species, transferred by him, in reality, to another genus.” I take this to mean that, for example, a species of which the trivial name is, say, abii, and which was originally described by an author Xyz, and referred (erroneously) by him to the genus Cdia, has been transferred now to another (the correct, according to present knowledge) genus Efia, and the name is now printed in this work not as Efia abii, Xyz, but as Efia abii, Massee. I am aware that this course is frequently adopted, but surely not “under the generally accepted rules of nomenclature.” There is no copy of the British Association “Rules” within reach here, but my recollection is that they prescribe a different course, viz., to retain as authority for a species the name of the original describer, and that is the course adopted in, I think, most of the Challenger reports, and by very many zoologists. I may state briefly as an example the first case that occurs to me—I have no systematic books here to refer to. (1) About 1870 Cunningham described a new Ascidian as Cynthia gigantea. (2) About 1880 Herdman transferred that species to the genus Molgula. (3) In the Challenger report this species figures as Molgula gigantea, Cunningham; and I would submit that that, rather than the course indicated in the review, is “under the generally accepted rules of nomenclature.”

Access options

Rent or Buy article

Get time limited or full article access on ReadCube.


All prices are NET prices.

Author information

Rights and permissions

Reprints and Permissions

About this article

Cite this article

HERDMAN, W. Rules of Nomenclature. Nature 46, 417–418 (1892) doi:10.1038/046417c0

Download citation


By submitting a comment you agree to abide by our Terms and Community Guidelines. If you find something abusive or that does not comply with our terms or guidelines please flag it as inappropriate.