This page has been archived and is no longer updated

 
January 05, 2011 | By:  Nick Morris
Aa Aa Aa

Facebook and Teaching - is Facebook evil?

Last night I was watching Newsnight (a late night news programme on the BBC in the UK) and they were talking about the recent valuation of Facebook. The TV news story was followed up today with a blog post on the BBC - Behind Facebook's megavaluation: the generational divide lurks by Paul Mason (Newsnight's economics editor). (The post also has some great comments that are worth a read.)

Interestingly is the post, which I thought would be mainly about the 'megavaluation' of Facebook, also contained material on the 'generational divide' (as the title suggested) on Facebook, that is, who is and who is not on Facebook, and who can be-friend who.

The article makes the claim that on Facebook teenagers (read students) only have teenager (read student) friends, and that they don't expect 'post-teenagers' to be-friend them on the site. In addition, the article makes the point that teenagers are not really in to email, Twitter, or online chat. I must admit that these claims are confirmed by my own observations in my teaching, and that I can fully understand why students want a place online that is private and their area away from the prying eyes of 'post-teenagers'.

From a teaching perspective this raises some interesting problems. If students are only in to Facebook and are not into email, Twitter, or online chat, then how are the educators supposed to reach them? Will Facebook launch a Virtual Learning Environment (VLE) section? And what does all this mean for the openness of the web?*

Hopefully, this lack of online interaction between students and educators will fade..... But in the meantime we need to find a solution! Any ideas?


* Tim Berners-Lee (the inventor of the world wide web) wrote an interesting piece in the Guardian (a British newspaper) back in November (Tim Berners-Lee: Facebook could fragment web) in which he argued that there is a real danger that the web could fragment with large sections being closed off (and not easily searchable) behind passwords and/or paywall. This could have a huge impact on students being able to access material online, and educators being able to reach the students.

6 Comments
Comments
January 07, 2011 | 04:42 PM
Posted By:  Nick Morris
Khalil A. Cassimally - yes, I agree. However, you do have to be careful as there may be a time when a 'disciplinary issue' arise, and then there can be problems....
January 07, 2011 | 04:15 PM
Posted By:  Khalil A. Cassimally
@Nick But if teachers and students become more like friends, communication between them is bound to go more smoothly and in (possibly) a more entertaining manner. Which equals to better education.

Right?
January 07, 2011 | 02:33 PM
Posted By:  Nick Morris
Yes, excellent link Ilona.

The key point in the link you gave is summed up with:

"Kids (and teachers) today need boundaries between professional and casual conversation."

This echos a conversation I had at Science OnLine London 2010 (SOLO10) with Aleks Krotoski (@aleksk - http://alekskrotoski.com/) in which she argued that 'staff' and students should have 'professional' and 'personal' areas online.
January 05, 2011 | 10:34 PM
Posted By:  Khalil A. Cassimally
Aha, nice link there Ilona!
January 05, 2011 | 05:49 PM
Posted By:  Ilona Miko
Students are savvy Facebook users and they know how to create sublists, so I don't see a problem persisting here as faculty try to create new venues at student watering holes, so to speak. VLE sections may emerge out of existing subnetworks people already make within their accounts. For instance, one can make use of sublists of "friends" to separate social from educational networks or others. Many faculty are already closing this generational divide, and use fan pages for their classes or institutions. Though Facebook is definitely the most popular, but educators don't necessarily have to go there. As Sean Nash points out in his edublog, google profile pages and nings are also working well to connect students to educational endeavors and form interactive online networks. http://nashworld.edublogs.org/2010/08/29/how-close-is-too-close/
January 05, 2011 | 02:56 PM
Posted By:  Robin Heyden
Hi Nick - Thanks for this blog you've started. I enjoyed reading your thoughts on Facebook and using social media with students. I have worked with teachers in the U.S. who've had success communicating with their students on Facebook through the clever manipulation of privacy settings and forming groups. While I think that our students are made uncomfortable by adult-intrusion into their world (and that's not just with Facebook!), it does make sense for educators to figure out a way to meet them where they "live". One-stop-shopping for communication makes sense and, while they're in there, manipulating the privacy settings and establishing groups, educators can also model appropriate and sensible use of the tool for their students.
Blogger Profiles
Recent Posts

« Prev Next »

Connect
Connect Send a message

Scitable by Nature Education Nature Education Home Learn More About Faculty Page Students Page Feedback



Blogs