Journal home
Advance online publication
Current issue
Archive
Press releases
Supplements
Focuses
Guide to authors
Online submissionOnline submission
For referees
Free online issue
Contact the journal
Subscribe
Advertising
work@npg
Reprints and permissions
About this site
For librarians
 
NPG Resources
Nature
Nature Reviews
Nature Immunology
Nature Cell Biology
Nature Genetics
news@nature.com
Nature Conferences
Dissect Medicine
NPG Subject areas
Biotechnology
Cancer
Chemistry
Clinical Medicine
Dentistry
Development
Drug Discovery
Earth Sciences
Evolution & Ecology
Genetics
Immunology
Materials Science
Medical Research
Microbiology
Molecular Cell Biology
Neuroscience
Pharmacology
Physics
Browse all publications
Book Review
Nature Medicine  8, 923 (2002)
doi:10.1038/nm0902-923a

The Future of Life

Reviewed by: Russell F. Doolittle

Center for Molecular Genetics University of California, San Diego, La Jolla, California, USA



by E.O. Wilson

Alfred A. Knopf, 229 pp, $22.00
,2002
E.O. Wilson is among America's most eminent biologists. Winner of two Pulitzer prizes and the recipient of countless scientific honors, his influence extends far beyond the scientific community. In this well documented if somewhat mistitled book, he chronicles the sad destruction of the planet Earth by the human species. Hammering home the theme he makes so well in his public lectures, he reminds the reader that for the rest of the current world's population to be raised to the U.S. level of consumption would require four more planet Earths.

The Future of Life has only seven chapters, the first six of which are beautifully written essays; each could easily stand alone and be read profitably by any literate citizen. In a charming prologue, Wilson pens a letter to Henry David Thoreau—a pioneer of the conservation movement—telling him not only about the present condition of Walden Pond but also about the state of the world: that there are now more than six billion people, the great majority of whom are poor, and a billion on the edge of starvation—equivalent to the world's entire population in 1800.

The first six chapters state the facts: the extent of biodiversity, how human beings evolved to be plunderers, how environmental incursions occur, the worldwide demise of large animals, the rapidly accelerating loss of species. Wilson, a gifted and forceful writer, spares no society, from the Aboriginals of Australia to the Maoris of New Zealand to the European settlers of the New World. But the major aggravation, he notes, is that in the twentieth century the pattern of human population growth "was more bacterial than primate," heading for a likely world population of more than 10 billion by the middle of this century. Adding to the woe is the growing disparity between the haves and have-nots of the world.

China in particular receives a good deal of deserved scrutiny. Today, the 1.2 billion Chinese account for one in every five persons on Earth. (Wilson missed a chance to point out that were it not for China's much maligned "one-child policy," one in every four persons on Earth today could have been Chinese.) China's problems seem overwhelming, whether it be the availability of water or the limits of world grain production and what Chinese demand will do to prices in less developed countries. That Chinese folk medicine is coupled to the demise of exotic rhinoceri (because of the alleged medicinal powers of horn extracts) only seems to rub salt in an already mortal wound.

Given this hopelessly depressing state of affairs, I desperately looked forward to the last chapter, titled 'The Solutions'. Alas, I was greatly disappointed. It's as though the author had forgotten everything he had written in the first six chapters. In an effort to be statesman-like, this eminent spokesperson for science, who has the ear of government and religious leaders, begins by constructing a dialogue between two extremist views: the People-First Critic versus the Environmentalist. This is a false dichotomy. Most environmentalists are also people-first in the sense they recognize that if something is not done about their numbers now, there will not be any humans at all in the future.

Wilson's message is one of compromise. Science, he says, must join with religion in pursuing a future course. This implies an undeserved equity. In my view, such a coalition will never be effective until the leaders of the world's major religions acknowledge the arithmetic of human reproduction and the need for a population decline. Similarly, Wilson proposes an equilateral triangle of cooperation among the Private Sector, Government, and Science and Technology to address biodiversity problems. Once again, the implied parity is unrealistic. The "juggernaut of technology-based capitalism will not be stopped," he concedes. So where does he glean his "cautious optimism"? So long as we have an economic system that depends absolutely on growth, there are no grounds for even cautious optimism.

Wilson offers a specific 12-point plan for saving a slice of the world's ecosystems, mainly through concentrating on high-yield targets. 25 hotspots around the world account for only 1.4 percent of the Earth's land mass, he reasons, but are the last remaining habitat for 40% of vascular plants and non-fish vertebrates. He estimates that saving these targets could be financed by as little as a one-cent-per-cup tax on coffee.

Much of Wilson's strategy for turning matters around depends on wilderness buy-backs and zoo breeding programs. He touts a proposal to turn the Demilitarized Zone between North and South Korea into a habitat for biodiversity. Certainly no biologist would oppose these worthy if modest goals. But can they save the world? We will be saved, Wilson says, because we now understand the problem.

A more accurate title for this book would have been "The Threatened Future of Biodiversity". A cynic might even have argued for the longer title: "If We Can't Save the Planet, Let Us Please Keep a Little Slice of It Naturally Diverse for the Little While We Have Left".

 Top
FULL TEXT
Previous | Next
Table of contents
Download PDFDownload PDF
Send to a friendSend to a friend
Save this linkSave this link

natureevents

Export citation
natureproducts

Search buyers guide:

 
ADVERTISEMENT
 
Nature Medicine
ISSN: 1078-8956
EISSN: 1546-170X
Journal home | Advance online publication | Current issue | Archive | Press releases | Supplements | Focuses | For authors | Online submission | For referees | Free online issue | About the journal | Contact the journal | Subscribe | Advertising | work@npg | Reprints and permissions | About this site | For librarians
Nature Publishing Group, publisher of Nature, and other science journals and reference works©2002 Nature Publishing Group | Privacy policy