Nature | News

Prestigious Karolinska Institute dismisses controversial trachea surgeon

Paolo Macchiarini says that he does not accept disciplinary-board findings.

Article tools

Rights & Permissions

Stefan Zimmerman/TT / TT News Agency/Press Association Images.

Pioneering trachea surgeon Paolo Macchiarini in 2011.

The prestigious Karolinska Institute (KI) in Stockholm has ended its contract with the controversial surgeon Paolo Macchiarini after a series of allegations about his clinical and research practices.

Macchiarini, formerly a visiting professor at the medical institute, had been internationally fêted for his pioneering operations to implant artificial windpipes — until allegations of scientific and ethical misconduct began to emerge almost two years ago. The KI, which selects winners of the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine, has subsequently come under criticism for its handling of the affair.

In February, the KI announced that it had “lost confidence” in Macchiarini; that his lab there should phase out its research; and that his contract would not be renewed in November.

Now, the Staff Disciplinary Board at the institute says that he has been dismissed. Macchiarini “engaged in conduct and research that is incompatible with a position of employment”, alleged the board in a statement released on 23 March. “It’s impossible for KI to have any kind of collaboration with Paolo Macchiarini any longer,” said KI human-resources manager Mats Engelbrektson in the same statement.

Following the announcement, Macchiarini told Nature: “I do not accept any of the findings of the Disciplinary Board. I have instructed lawyers and will be taking immediate steps to restore my reputation.”

Russian procedures

Macchiarini carried out three artificial trachea operations, in which the synthetic tracheas were seeded with the patients' own stem cells, at the Karolinska University Hospital between 2011 and 2012. Two of those patients have since died, and one remains in hospital. In 2013, the KI said that it would not extend his contract as a surgeon, but kept him on as a basic researcher in regenerative medicine and approved his 'extra-mural occupation' as a surgeon at the Kuban State Medical University in Krasnodar, Russia.

Allegations of misconduct against Macchiarini began to emerge in June 2014, including that he had exaggerated the success of his artificial-trachea implants in several scientific papers describing experiments in rats and in people. In August 2015, the KI cleared him of scientific misconduct, but said that his research failed to meet its required standards of quality

A television documentary about Macchiarini’s work, aired in January, brought fresh, public attention to his work. The programme suggested that in an operation in Russia, Macchiarini implanted one of his plastic tracheas into a woman who was not in a life-threatening condition. Previously, the surgeon had said he attempted the risky procedures only on people who were life-threateningly ill.

External investigation

After the documentary, leading Karolinska figures resigned, including the vice-chancellor, the dean of research and the secretary-general of the Nobel Assembly. The KI has also commissioned an ongoing, external investigation into its hiring of Macchiarini and the handling of its previous investigations into his work.

In its latest statement, the Karolinska Staff Disciplinary Board says that it found that Macchiarini’s activities in Krasnodar “are in breach of the KI’s fundamental values and have damaged KI’s reputation” and that he had failed to “truthfully and fully” report his activities there. It also says that Macchiarini “supplied false or misleading information in the CV he submitted to KI”, and had “demonstrated scientific negligence”.

Engelbrektson added: “He has acted in a way that has had very tragic consequences for the people affected and their families. His conduct has seriously damaged confidence in Karolinska Institute and for research in general.”

Journal name:
Nature
DOI:
doi:10.1038/nature.2016.19629

For the best commenting experience, please login or register as a user and agree to our Community Guidelines. You will be re-directed back to this page where you will see comments updating in real-time and have the ability to recommend comments to other users.

Comments for this thread are now closed.

Comments

1 comment Subscribe to comments

  1. Avatar for Leonid Schneider
    Leonid Schneider
    Macchiarini's Russian colleagues in the Kuban State University in Krasnodar declared that all operations were approved through a videoconference, where specialists from Karolinska, Careggi and MD Anderson participated. This statement has been taken offline quickly, but I saved a cached copy, while a reader of my site found out the names of all participants. https://forbetterscience.wordpress.com/2016/03/15/macchiarinis-german-ex-friends-jungebluth-and-bader/ https://forbetterscience.wordpress.com/2016/03/15/macchiarinis-german-ex-friends-jungebluth-and-bader/#comment-590
sign up to Nature briefing

What matters in science — and why — free in your inbox every weekday.

Sign up

Listen

new-pod-red

Nature Podcast

Our award-winning show features highlights from the week's edition of Nature, interviews with the people behind the science, and in-depth commentary and analysis from journalists around the world.