Nature | Editorial

Translations

عربي

Hope from the Pope

The Vatican has produced a timely and valuable warning on the threat of climate change that will reach a wide audience.

Article tools

Relations between the Catholic Church and science have long been ambivalent. Famously, it took the Vatican 359 years to formally concede that Earth moves around the Sun: only in 1992 was Galileo Galilei, who proclaimed that fact in 1633, officially ‘rehabilitated’ by Pope John Paul II.

It is gratifying that Catholic officials have moved on. Pope Francis’s much-anticipated encyclical letter on climate and the environment, released last week with great fanfare, is of course pastoral in tone and intent. And yet, the papal letter testifies to the respect and honest understanding that the Argentinian Pope and his cardinals have for science.

“Science is the best tool by which we can listen to the cry of the Earth,” Cardinal Peter Turkson, president of the Pontifical Council for Justice and Peace, said on releasing the 192-page letter, drafted in consultation with leading climate experts. While calling on leaders to step up efforts to reduce global greenhouse emissions (which the encyclical acknowledges to be the main cause of warming), the Pope warns in strong language that unabated climate change will cause severe disruptions to ecosystems and human societies. His letter to the world’s more than one billion Catholics repeatedly stresses the moral imperative for action on global warming, poverty and overexploitation of natural resources.

With international climate negotiations entering a decisive phase, the Vatican has chosen the right time to weigh in. Combined with a pledge earlier this month from the G7 leading industrialized nations to phase out fossil fuels, hopes are increasing that the next round of global climate negotiations, in Paris in December, might reach a meaningful deal.

Scientists and political leaders in favour of climate action have rightly expressed gratitude and admiration for Pope Francis’s brave move. In doing so, President Barack Obama said that the United States must be a leader in efforts to cut carbon pollution and protect the environment. Other nations must follow suit. It will take more than spiritual aid to set the course for a clean-energy future, but the political weight of the Pope’s appeal to the moral conscience and reason of millions of people must not be underestimated.

The fact that the Vatican has sided with those who criticize the excesses of capitalism and consumerism — systems that the Pope labels in the encyclical as culprits in the world’s ecological crisis — could fuel suspicion in some quarters. But his plea for moderation and sustainability should not be dismissed as naive or utopian. The long-held view that continuous economic growth produces perpetual happiness and wellbeing is increasingly being questioned, including by forward-looking economists and social psychologists. And the financial crisis of recent years has produced ample evidence of the risks of runaway capitalism.

Wisely, Pope Francis has framed the issue of global change along the lines of hope and opportunity, rather than of doom and gloom. Why, he asks, should humankind take the risk of dangerously altering the planet’s climate and biosphere when there are viable alternatives?

The papal calls to end poverty and share the world’s ecological space in a fair way are objectives that mirror the United Nations’ Sustainable Development Goals, to be released in September. The Pope’s letter adds an important facet to the discussion: it is not merely conceivable to secure a sound future for human civilization without relying on coal, oil and gas — it is a prerequisite.

Given the Pope’s moral authority and sky-rocketing popularity — not just among Catholics — his words might travel farther than sober scientific reports by bodies such as the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC). Those tomes tend to brim with jargon and are read by relatively few people. And unlike the IPCC, which sometimes struggles with public outreach, the Catholic Church has a superb means of spreading the word every Sunday. A global campaign that the church plans to run in coming months could step up the urgency for the December climate talks. To build useful momentum, climate policies must be top of the agenda when Pope Francis visits the White House and addresses the UN General Assembly in September.

Meanwhile, within the encyclical are other issues that are important for science. Remarkably, the Pope concedes that intervening with plants and animals is “permissible when it pertains to the necessities of human life”. The clause signals a rethink of the Catholic Church’s attitude to genetic engineering and animal research. Alas, he remained silent on issues of contraception. With a world population heading towards a possible 10 billion, the importance of family planning is clear. The Vatican has been brave on climate change. If it is serious about the fate of the planet and the welfare of its inhabitants, then it must be braver still on the issue of contraception.

Journal name:
Nature
Volume:
522,
Pages:
391
Date published:
()
DOI:
doi:10.1038/522391a

For the best commenting experience, please login or register as a user and agree to our Community Guidelines. You will be re-directed back to this page where you will see comments updating in real-time and have the ability to recommend comments to other users.

Comments

4 comments Subscribe to comments

  1. Avatar for septian handioko
    septian handioko
    It matters that Prof. Hunt was a good mentor. But even if he was trying to "joke" ( I believe he did), it shows poor judgement and lack of awareness of his own power. I've read that he and his wife were so upset that they were in tears - it's difficult to have sympathy for his tears, after his joke about women crying in the lab. I suspect that the strong reaction towards Prof. Hunt at the UCL, and at various science organizations and societies, indicates lack of having built good will. I.e., I suspect that there were many people unhappy with him, and once he did something stupid, they jumped at the opportunity. thanks http://jokowi.biz/service/
  2. Avatar for Giovanna Serenelli
    Giovanna Serenelli
    It seems too simplistic to stop the speech at the energy. When the Pope wrote the Enciclica has used broad and pregnant (rich in significance or implication) concepts. . ‘The urgent challenge of protecting our common home understands the concern to unite the whole human family in the search for sustainable integral development, because we know that things can change After a time of irrational faith in progress and in human capabilities, a part of the society is entering a phase of greater awareness. There is an increasing sensitivity about the environment and care of nature, and he developed a sincere and painful concern for what is happening to our planet This sister (Earth) protest against the damage that we cause, due to irresponsible use and abuse of the goods that God has placed in her. We grew up thinking we were its owners and rulers, allowed to plunder it. The violence that exists in the human heart wounded by sin is also manifested in the symptoms of the disease that we experience in soil, water, air and in living things. For this, among the most abandoned poor and abused, there is our oppressed and devastated land… Our body is made up of the same elements of the planet, its air is the one that gives us the breath and its water gives us life and restores.’ Some chapters of the encyclical: I.POLLUTION AND CLIMATE CHANGE Pollution, waste and scrap culture The climate as a common good II. THE QUESTION OF WATER III. LOSS OF BIODIVERSITY IV. DETERIORATION IN THE QUALITY OF LIFE AND SOCIAL DEGRADATION V. PLANETARY INEQUITIES VI. THE WEAKNESS OF REACTIONS (weak reaction of international policy; The alliance between economics and technology ends up leaving out anything that is not part of their immediate interests). And more… We can remove all references to religion. No problem. The meaning does not change. The essential theme is the RESPECT or if you want the ETHICS. Applied!, not proclaimed with useless 'empty' words Applied, not proclaimed with empty words
  3. Avatar for Timothy Roberts
    Timothy Roberts
    As the Pope says, the poor must come first. Developing countries need to grow richer - and educate women. That would slow population growth. More expensive energy will slow development.
  4. Avatar for Atanacio Luna
    Atanacio Luna
    Not necessarily. If we can produce energy at the cost of fossil fuels, with pollution costs accounted for, the opposite will be the case; a booming economy throughout the world. This will lift poor and rich nations into a new era of clean energy, but more importantly of clean conscience and broad awareness. We could accommodate 11 billion as current trends indicate will be peak population, if our cities factor in the cost of pollution. This means that silly city design such as sprawling suburbs will be replaced with much more functional, interesting, and enjoyable cities. Can we produce energy at the such a low cost? Yes, PV is rapidly approaching that point if it has not already surpassed it. Wind is slowly getting there too, but the game changing technologies are just around the corner; that is what I do. Even if my offering is not correct, you can get an idea of what that new era might look like by looking at Pluvinergy. It is just one idea of many that can revolutionize energy and our relationship to the planet.

Busy, busy, busy

timelab

The lab that knows where your time really goes

Armed with 850,000 diaries, an Oxford centre is trying to find out why modern life seems so hectic.

Hiding in plain sight

Galapagos

Genetics probe identifies new Galapagos tortoise species

Known group of 250 animals found to be genetically distinct from their island neighbours.

Google alert

Google

Why biomedical superstars are signing on with Google

Tech firms’ ambitious goals and abundant resources attract life scientists.

Nature Podcast

podcast

On this week's show...

A dying solar system just like ours, the effect of temperature on the economy, and electricity-eating bacteria.

FSB oversight

Putin

Russian secret service to vet research papers

Moscow biology department among the first to require that all manuscripts comply with law on state secrets.

Unruly ocean

El_nino

Hunting the Godzilla El Niño

As a massive El Niño warming builds in the equatorial Pacific Ocean, researchers hope to make the most of their chance to study this havoc-wreaking phenomenon.

Science jobs from naturejobs