Published online 21 October 2009 | Nature 461, 1035 (2009) | doi:10.1038/4611035a


Hwang verdict imminent

Disgraced stem-cell researcher may face time in jail.

Hwang is charged with fraud.Hwang is charged with fraud.CHUNG SUNG-JUN/GETTY

Despite his research being exposed as fraudulent and unethical almost four years ago, the career of South Korean cloner Woo Suk Hwang has thrived. He has established a research institute, laid claim to a set of human-cloning patents, received a scientific excellence award, published a handful of papers and entered into a collaboration with a powerful provincial government.

Now Hwang faces his biggest hurdle yet: the possibility of jail time. As Nature went to press, a verdict was expected on charges that he knowingly used faked research results to apply for grants, embezzled as much as 2.8 billion Korean won (US$2.4 million), and purchased human eggs in violation of the country's bioethics law.

The charges relate to two papers in which Hwang claimed to have created stem-cell lines from cloned human embryos, and to have used the technology to develop patient-specific stem cells (W. S. Hwang et al. Science 303, 1669–1674; 2004 and W. S. Hwang et al. Science 308, 1777–1783; 2005). Both were found to have been fabricated.

In August, at the last of 43 judicial hearings on the affair, prosecutors sought four years in prison for Hwang. It was the end of an epic 40-month trial that saw the chief judge change three times, heard testimonies from more than 60 witnesses and included some bizarre moments — such as when Hwang claimed he could not account for some of his funding because he had used it to pay Russian mafia for access to the DNA of a frozen mammoth that he hoped to clone.

Hwang still has powerful supporters. In June, he received an award from the Jang Yeong-sil Memorial Foundation for scientific excellence. In August, the South Korean province of Gyeonggi announced that it planned a collaboration with Hwang to develop transgenic animals able to grow organs for transplantation to humans. And on 12 October, 33 parliamentarians submitted a petition to the Seoul Central District Court Criminal Division pleading for leniency in sentencing Hwang so that he can continue his research without further ado.

Meanwhile, stem-cell science in South Korea has also bounced back from the scandal. In July, the government promised to triple its funding for the field to 120 billion won by 2015. The government is also putting together a plan to give about 20 top stem-cell projects up to 1 billion won each over two years, with the possibility of twice that amount in a subsequent funding round. In April, the government approved an application by Seoul's Pochon CHA University to carry out human therapeutic cloning experiments.

"The future of stem-cell research is very promising," says Dong-Youn Hwang of the Pochon CHA University. "Many Korean people now realize that stem-cell-based therapy is not magic, but only results from hard work, huge investment and continuous support," he adds.

Developmental biologist Kunsoo Rhee of Seoul National University, where Woo Suk Hwang worked until he was dismissed in 2006, says that the increased attention on scientific conduct has had some positive outcomes, including an undergraduate course on misconduct, which began at the university two years ago. "If we have something like [the Hwang case] all the time it would be bad, but once every 10 years — or hopefully only once in our lifetime — it can be a learning experience."


"After Hwang's scandal, Korean biotech is getting more transparent," adds Kyung-Sun Kang of Seoul National University's Adult Stem Cell Research Center. Kang says that although research on embryonic stem cells was difficult for a while, there has been an upsurge in the commercialization of adult stem cells, with several stem-cell therapies now in clinical trials.

If Woo Suk Hwang avoids a prison sentence, he says that he plans to continue his efforts to benefit South Korea by continuing his research on mammalian cloning, and still hopes to vindicate his human-cloning technique. 


If you find something abusive or inappropriate or which does not otherwise comply with our Terms or Community Guidelines, please select the relevant 'Report this comment' link.

Comments on this thread are vetted after posting.

  • #60442

    I think the article reports on the verdict of cloner Woo Suk Hwang on charges that he used fake research results in his application for grants, misappropriated as much as 2.8 billion Korean won, and purchased human eggs in violation of the bioethics law in South Korea.

Commenting is now closed.