Published online 24 September 2008 | Nature 455, 438-439 (2008) | doi:10.1038/455438a


Gulf states plan for nuclear future

Oil-rich nations concern proliferation experts with atomic projects.

The speed of development in Dubai makes many think its nuclear power project will also be rapid.The speed of development in Dubai makes many think its nuclear power project will also be rapid.G. HELLIER/GETTY IMAGES

While Iran grabs international headlines for its controversial nuclear programme, ambitious plans for an atomic roll-out on the other side of the Gulf are quietly under way. Non-proliferation experts are already voicing concern.

Major oil-producing states, including Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates (UAE) and Bahrain, are taking steps to develop civilian nuclear power. Concurrently, the Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC), a trade bloc of the six Arab states in the region, is working with the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) to erect a research reactor on the peninsula. Nearly everyone in the Gulf has declared some interest in nuclear power over the past two years, says Mustafa Alani, a senior consultant with the Gulf Research Centre, an independent think tank in Dubai, UAE. "There is a fever in the region."

Interest in nuclear power is on the rise worldwide, but the Gulf may be better situated than most to actually build reactors. Whereas Western utilities struggle to raise the billions needed for a power plant, the cash-flush Gulf states have more than enough money, says Seth Grae, chief executive of Thorium Power, a consultancy on nuclear power based in McLean, Virginia. "Right now, the Gulf region represents one of the most exciting and promising nuclear markets in the world."

Grae says that the nuclear fever is driven by the region's rapidly expanding economies and the need for fresh water, for which energy-intensive desalination is the best option. But some non-proliferation experts say that fear of Iran, which may be close to developing a nuclear weapon, is the real reason behind the growing interest. "States are not driven to build reactors solely based on economic concerns," says Jill Parillo, deputy director for security programmes at Physicians for Social Responsibility, an advocacy group based in Washington DC. "It's a perceived security assurance."

It may seem strange that a region flush with oil and natural gas — not to mention the solar-energy potential — would even consider building nuclear power stations. Nuclear power plants are enormously expensive to build — recent estimates run at US$7 billion per plant. And there are time-consuming, political complications. A nation with nuclear power must introduce legislation to address liability and safety concerns, for example, and an independent regulatory body to oversee plant operations.

Yet nuclear power makes sense for the Gulf states, says Hans-Holger Rogner, the head of planning and economic studies at the IAEA, which is responsible for both overseeing nuclear safeguards and promoting the development of nuclear power. The region faces unprecedented growth over the coming decade. The UAE alone expects its electricity needs to almost quadruple, rising from around 15 gigawatts (thousand megawatts) in 2006 to nearly 40 gigawatts in 2020. Part of that demand is driven by the UAE's rapid economic development, but demand for fresh water, which will be desalinated using energy-intensive reverse osmosis, is also a major factor. The need for electricity could be met in part by burning fossil fuels, but their anticipated future price abroad makes that option uneconomical, Rogner says. "The oil and gas the Gulf states produce are worth far more on the international market than if they burn them at home."

The UAE has progressed furthest in its plans to develop nuclear power. Earlier this year, the small, oil-rich nation penned a cooperative agreement with France to begin nuclear development, and it is looking at a bid from French companies Areva, Suez and Total to build and operate two 1,600-megawatt reactors on islands off its coast. At the same time, it is enacting legislation on nuclear issues and setting up an independent regulatory body to license and oversee its plants. "They're taking it very seriously," says Grae, whose firm consults with the UAE government on its nuclear plans.

Some are concerned about the UAE programme's rapid development. The tiny state is famous for importing foreign talent to build its roads and bridges, and it looks as though nuclear will be no exception. "They're apparently talking about just buying in regulators from other countries," says Charles Ferguson of the Council on Foreign Relations, a think tank based in Washington DC. Ferguson says that these foreign regulators would face "enormous pressure" from the government if they tried to shut down a reactor for safety reasons.

Grae counters that the UAE already has a proven record of importing international talent to operate independent institutions. Dubai's International Financial Centre, for example, is administered according to international 'common law' and has its own courts staffed by foreign judges. "The UAE has some real examples of regulatory independence," Grae says.

Like many states in the region, the UAE has signed up to the international Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty, a document that promises aid for civilian programmes if countries give up their right to nuclear arms. In addition, it and many other GCC states have announced that they will not develop the nuclear technologies of most concern: uranium enrichment and spent-fuel reprocessing. Both technologies can be used to manufacture reactor fuel, but they can also be used to refine weapons-grade nuclear material. Rogner says he is satisfied that the Gulf states are not a danger. "A nuclear power plant per se is not a proliferation risk," he says.

Grae says that he believes economics is the sole driver behind the Gulf's push for nuclear power. "What I am seeing in the UAE is that this has zero to do with security," he says.


But Parillo has her doubts. Creating the technological basis for a civilian programme will also be of some use should the states ever need to develop nuclear weapons, she says. Building and operating plants will help nations develop expertise in areas such as reactor physics and the handling of nuclear materials. "This is the first step on the way to developing a dual-use capability."

Alani adds that it is no coincidence that the Gulf's nuclear renaissance began in earnest two years ago. In the spring of 2006, the IAEA announced that Iran was enriching uranium without the agency's approval. The Gulf states view Iran as an expansionist and interventionist regime, he says, and the international community's failure to control its programme set off alarm bells. The message to many states was clear, he says: "One has to start a civilian programme to start narrowing the gap." 

Commenting is now closed.