Access
This article is part of Nature's premium content.
Published online 16 April 2008 | Nature | doi:10.1038/452806a
Archaeology: Bones, isles and videotape
Old human remains found on the Pacific islands of Palau are caught in the crossfire between entertainment and science. Rex Dalton reports.
To read this story in full you will need to login or make a payment (see right).
Comments
Reader comments are usually moderated after posting. If you find something offensive or inappropriate, you can speed this process by clicking 'Report this comment' (or, if that doesn't work for you, email webadmin@nature.com). For more controversial topics, we reserve the right to moderate before comments are published.
If bones of mixed-species australopithecine/Homo erectus/Homo sapiens populations are not actually present in Mr. Berger's cave, they are likely to be found nearby. Indonesian, Melanesian, and Polynesian oral history is full of realistic, non-mythologized reports of encountering (and often cannibalizing) small hairy people regarded as sub-human. And we know from the Kennewick Man proceedings that native oral history can be used even as scientific court evidence (at least, if it supports what you want it to). Mr. Berger's crime is that he brings up the subject of these populations at all. He's obviously trying to promote the Out of Africa party line and argue against Homo floriensis -- but he does so so awkwardly and unbelievably, with his instant-million-year island regression -- that the entire subject has to be immediately and vigorously tamped down. Just as a hill in Bosnia, in the shape of a pyramid, with human-made rock surfacing, does not exist, could not exist, and Shall Not Be Investigated Further.
It is most unlikely that the bones on Palau belong to any hominid species other than Homo sapiens -- in fact, Berger does not claim them to be other than H. sapiens. He only claims that there are certain similarities between them and those on Flores, which may illuminate the process of island dwarfism. But as for the so-called ebu gogo or orang pendek, the hairy sub-human folk spoken of by Flores folk and Indonesians, if these have a basis in reality, they are probably orang-utans!