Rights for all

Journal name:
Date published:
Published online

Scientists should push for fair treatment of Turkish academics arrested on little evidence.

Earlier this month, a Turkish court acquitted the sociologist Pinar Selek on terrorism charges — the third time she has been cleared of causing a 1998 explosion at an Istanbul spice market that killed seven people. Selek's real crime, in the eyes of the Turkish government, seems to have been contact with Kurdish separatist groups as part of her academic research. Prosecutors have again appealed the not-guilty verdict, to howls of outrage from human-rights groups in Europe, which is watching Turkey's conduct in the case with interest as the nation seeks membership of the European Union (EU).

A less-scrutinized and less-supported cause are the dozen or so Turkish academics arrested — among hundreds of others — as part of a government crackdown on 'deep-state networks'. In the past, these are said to have violently targeted those whom they consider to be Turkey's enemies, including Kurdish separatists. Turkish police say that they have uncovered a tightly controlled, hierarchical organization — called Ergenekon — that conspires to destabilize the government through political violence and pave the way for a military coup.

The government frames its Ergenekon investigation as a step towards democratic reform, but detractors say it has also been used as an excuse to round up and silence government critics, particularly vociferous defenders of secularism in politics and education.

An independent analysis of the investigation by the Istanbul-based analyst Gareth Jenkins says that many of those arrested seem to be linked to one another by little more than their opposition to Islamic conservatism and the ruling Justice and Development Party (AKP). That certainly describes the arrested academics — most of whom hailed from the conservative secular elite — including several university rectors who had decried attempts to lift the headscarf ban in Turkish universities, and criticized, for example, the appointment of AKP supporters to key academic positions, such as in the government's science-funding agency TÜBİTAK.

Most of the arrested academics have been released on bail, but two are still being held: Mehmet Haberal, the US-trained rector of Baskent University in Ankara, who pioneered transplant surgery in Turkey, and physician Fatih Hilmioğlu, former rector of İnönü University in Malatya.

The two have now been detained for almost two years, and there is no sign that they will be released, or have their trials heard, any time soon. Turkish law allows indicted individuals to be kept in long-term detention only if there is a danger that they might either destroy evidence or flee. Supporters say that both scientists are being treated for poor health and neither danger applies.

Questions have been asked on their behalf. In December 2009, Carol Corillon, executive director of the US National Academies' committee on human rights, expressed concern about the arrest of the academics in University Values, an electronic bulletin. And last year, the Turkish Academy of Sciences raised the detentions with Turkish President Abdullah Gül, who said he could not interfere with the independent courts.

Mostly, however, silence rules. The huge Ergenekon trial is moving very slowly, and those out on bail have been warned not to prejudice its outcome by discussing their cases publicly. The investigation has engendered an atmosphere of fear in universities. Academics are keeping their heads down and trying to enjoy the genuine attempts that Turkey is making to raise its science base towards EU norms. TÜBİTAK is also keeping quiet, afraid of further charges of political interference in scientific matters, such as it attracted in 2009, when it pulled the Darwin-celebratory cover of its popular-science magazine Bilim ve Teknik and demoted its editor (see Nature 458, 259; 2009).

Meanwhile, most human-rights groups have proved less keen to jump to the defence of those on the political right than those on the left, including Selek. Jenkins' report did stress that the Ergenekon investigation successfully identified some deep-state operatives, probably involved in political violence. And phone-tap transcripts have exposed unpleasant and antidemocratic right-wing sentiment among some of the indicted individuals.

But according to the European Convention on Human Rights, everyone has the right to a fair trial in a reasonable time. The Turkish government needs to feel the world's eyes on the actions of its judiciary. And the international scientific community should spread the word on the indicted and detained academics, and monitor how fairly their cases are handled. The last thing Turkish scientists need right now — as research investment is growing but the legal and administrative framework is not always keeping up — is to be afraid to criticize how their promising scientific landscape is developing.


  1. Report this comment #18331

    Dr. Levent Doganci said:

    I read the recent article in Nature with a great interest and deeply impressed that my decade long concerns have been getting an international expressions, finally! As an academician, I have to write down my comment as clearly as open for your readers. There are two great lessons, which should be taken into consideration utmost properly; First for my citizens: Whenever Turkey tries her best to integrate to West through out the history, she always becomes a great looser because of very narrow minded politicians. Turks must learn what the real idea of those politicians and where their final target pointing out clearly. Look carefully close around now a days in North Africa and Middle East and see where the final terminal is. It is clear and obvious. Second lesson is for the our western friends. Look carefully to the German history from 1935 to 1945. What you see there is exactly re-happening now. “History is recurrence”, a Turkish apothegm. “ First they collected the socialist, than Jews and communists. No body reacted. Finally when they came for me, there was no body to react!”. Unfortunately, last 8 years was not so happy times for free secular scientists, free media and modern universities in Turkey. Please remember, how percentage of votes were enough to gain the power for Adolph Hitler in Germany. Do we call that regime “democracy”? Who paid the final bill? Just Germans? Now a day another example for our western friends: Who are the best friend of Libya’s dictator Quaddaphi in Europe and Middle East? Why everybody wants him to leave the power now immediately? Is it because he is a bloody dictator, or is it just because oil price are rocket high? So far, the West should learn that the Globe is a very small place in XXI. Century. Small enough to irritate every people on Earth for frictions and lack of tranquillity or peace; and so small place to everyone to live a better life. One side will be very rich and other side will suffer with poverty to let the others become richer and richer. When the land is not worth to live for an average citizen, the fire of unrest will burn everybody. So far, please do your best for a true democracy and freedom for every people, for every nation always. Acting instead of reality spoils.

Subscribe to comments

Additional data