Books and Arts

Nature 459, 1058-1059 (25 June 2009) | doi:10.1038/4591058a; Published online 24 June 2009

From rubber ducks to ocean gyres

Simon Boxall1


The tale of Curtis Ebbesmeyer's use of beachcombing to reveal patterns of ocean circulation conveys the romance of early marine science, but his lessons for today are serious, finds Simon Boxall.

BOOK REVIEWEDFlotsametrics and the Floating World: How One Man's Obsession with Runaway Sneakers and Rubber Ducks Revolutionized Ocean Science

by Curtis Ebbesmeyer & Eric Scigliano

HarperCollins: 2009. 304 pp. $26.99, £16.99

From rubber ducks to ocean gyres


Curtis Ebbesmeyer has raised concerns that our seas are being choked by rubbish and plastic debris spilt from ships' containers.

As I gaze down from the aeroplane window at the Arabian Sea, the irony that I'm flying around the world to talk about the impact of climate change and how to reduce carbon emissions is not lost on me. To get to my meeting without emitting any carbon, I could, like the ancient Norsemen, have ridden the ocean gyres to far-off lands. Although the excuse "Sorry I'm 3.4 years late but that's the Majid Gyre for you" would be original, it might not satisfy my audience. Yet it comes out of a new book on ocean currents by oceanographer Curtis Ebbesmeyer and journalist Eric Scigliano.

I say the Majid Gyre as this is what the authors unilaterally call the Indian Subtropical Gyre. And I say a precise 3.4 years because that is the period of a harmonic in the ocean's large-scale flow. Flotsametrics and the Floating World highlights that the 11 major gyres that determine the surface circulation of the oceans rotate with a fundamental tone of 13.4 years, with half, quarter (hence 3.4), eighth and sixteenth tones. The authors elegantly call this the 'music of the gyres'.

From rubber ducks to ocean gyres


As I read on, however, my attention turns to my immediate surroundings. Plastic is everywhere: in the cabin lining, the chairs, the food trays and, let's face it, most of the airline food too. Virtually everything we use today is plastic, but our disposal of it is haphazard. As plastic objects break down into smaller and smaller particles, they disappear from view and from our minds but not from our environment. Most of this plastic will one day end up in the ocean.

Ebbesmeyer and Scigliano show — from journal papers, reports and their own observations — that the level of plastics building up in the sea, and particularly in the ocean gyres, is alarming. The North Pacific Subtropical Gyre has recently been dubbed the "Garbage Patch" by the media and by scientists; in places, plastic dust particles exceed phytoplankton in number.

Plastic bags are one source that has recently received a lot of attention. Some states in India have banned them, and even carrying one in the street incurs a penalty. This may be warranted. Although initial investigations of the environmental impact of ubiquitous microscopic plastic particles showed them to be benign roughage, recent research, covered in the book, flags up health issues. Chemicals from plastics can be carcinogens and 'endocrine disrupters' that mimic hormones such as oestrogen.

It is not only plastics that find their way into the ocean through landfill and dumping at sea. Flotsam and jetsam also get caught in its endless gyres. Ships are not always obliged to report the loss of containers at sea, nor their contents, and many do not because it looks bad on their records. In international waters the law against such pollution is inefficient or unenforceable. Yet Ebbesmeyer has built much of his ocean-circulation research on the serendipitous finds of beachcombers and mariners — from container loads of plastic bath toys and trainers spilled from ships, to bodies and ghost vessels lost at sea.

Flotsametrics and the Floating World is a tale of climate change and its effect on ocean gyres, and of seas so choked with plastic that climate change may be the least of our problems. The book also touches on darker, intriguing issues, such as the fate of bodies in the marine environment. But there is good news here too, from the discovery of new drugs in marine organisms to how oceans have enabled the dispersal of human civilizations across Earth. Best of all, the book reads like a good story because of the autobiographical way in which Ebbesmeyer and Scigliano lead the reader through.

My own path through oceanography has been similar to Ebbesmeyer's. We both worked on similar problems; from slabs of water and their mixing to tracking spills, dead bodies and plastic ducks. In the 1970s and 1980s, oceanography involved more exploration and pure experimentation than is typical today — it was romantic and fun. We get more out of marine science now, using technological tools such as satellites, supercomputers, robotic drifters and acoustic probes. But we have also inherited a bureaucracy of targets, cost allocations and concerns over health and safety, and this change in culture comes through in Ebbesmeyer's story. Concern for safety is no bad thing. But picture the scene if we were to start oceanography from scratch today — "Yes, we're going out in very deep water with 10-metre waves, in a small metal container while operating high-voltage equipment and explosives." We would be banned.

Whether you want to learn more about how the oceans tick or how we are affecting our environment, or to reminisce about science not being what it used to be, this is a very enjoyable, if at times dark, book. And I never did have to resort to the in-flight movie.

  1. Simon Boxall is a lecturer in oceanography at the National Oceanography Centre, University of Southampton, Southampton SO14 3ZH, UK.

Readers' Comments

If you find something abusive or inappropriate or which does not otherwise comply with our Terms and Conditions or Community Guidelines, please select the relevant 'Report this comment' link.

There are currently no comments.

Add your own comment

This is a public forum. Please keep to our Community Guidelines. You can be controversial, but please don't get personal or offensive and do keep it brief. Remember our threads are for feedback and discussion - not for publishing papers, press releases or advertisements.

You need to be registered with Nature and agree to our Community Guidelines to leave a comment. Please log in or register as a new user. You will be re-directed back to this page.