Abstract
The vasculature of solid tumours is morphologically aberrant and characterized by dilated and fragile vessels, intensive vessel sprouting and loss of hierarchical architecture1. Constant vessel remodelling leads to spontaneous haemorrhages2 and increased interstitial fluid pressure in the tumour environment3, 4. Tumour-related angiogenesis supports tumour growth and is also a major obstacle for successful immune therapy as it prevents migration of immune effector cells into established tumour parenchyma2, 5, 6. The molecular mechanisms for these angiogenic alterations are largely unknown. Here we identify regulator of G-protein signalling 5 (Rgs5) as a master gene responsible for the abnormal tumour vascular morphology in mice. Loss of Rgs5 results in pericyte maturation, vascular normalization and consequent marked reductions in tumour hypoxia and vessel leakiness. These vascular and intratumoral changes enhance influx of immune effector cells into tumour parenchyma and markedly prolong survival of tumour-bearing mice. This is the first demonstration, to our knowledge, of reduced tumour angiogenesis and improved immune therapeutic outcome on loss of a vascular gene function and establishes a previously unrecognized role of G-protein signalling in tumour angiogenesis.
During tumour-induced angiogenesis, the two important vascular cell types, endothelial cells and surrounding pericytes, develop multiple morphological and architectural abnormalities7, 8 as well as altered expression of marker proteins9, 10, 11, 12. Using the RIP-Tag mouse model of pancreatic islet carcinogenesis (SV40 large T antigen expressed under the control of the rat insulin gene (Ins2) promoter), we have recently observed that Rgs5 is overexpressed in the aberrant tumour vasculature10.
Rgs5 is expressed by pericytes in the vascular bed and is the first marker for a subgroup of platelet-derived growth factor receptor
(PDGFR
)+ progenitor perivascular cells that regulate vascular survival in tumours8. RGS molecules are a family of biochemically well-characterized molecules that inhibit signalling from G-protein-coupled receptors by stimulating the intrinsic GTPase activity of activated G
proteins13. However, their function in vivo is largely unknown. Rgs5 is constitutively expressed in a variety of organs, especially brain, heart, aorta, skeletal muscle, liver and kidney, and is also upregulated in RIP1-Tag5 tumour vessels10, 14.
To study the role of RGS5 in tumour angiogenesis and vascular normalization, we generated Rgs5-deficient mice by crossing recombinant mice harbouring a loxP-flanked Rgs5 exon 1 with Cre-deleter mice. On exon 1 deletion, Rgs5 expression is absent in heart, kidney, brain, lung and liver (Fig. 1a, b). Rgs5-deficient mice develop normally and present with no gross histological abnormalities. Rgs5-/- mice were intercrossed with transgenic RIP1-Tag5 mice to assess survival and intratumoral characteristics (Supplementary Fig. 1). RIP1-Tag5 mice develop tumours in a well-characterized sequence of events from normal Tag+ islets to hyperplastic and angiogenic islets, and eventually form insulinomas, which cause premature death due to hypoglycaemia. Early tumorigenesis is unchanged in the Rgs5-/- background, as documented by a comparable number of angiogenic islets per mouse (Fig. 1c). At later tumour stages, the Rgs5-deficient background enhances tumour growth, as shown by an increase in overall tumour burden over age and premature death caused by hypoglycaemia (Fig. 1d). This is in agreement with the reduced survival of Rgs5-deficient RIP1-Tag5 mice compared to RIP1-Tag5 wild-type mice (P < 0.0001; range, 27
3 weeks for RIP1-Tag5
Rgs5-/-, 30
3 weeks for RIP1-Tag5; Fig. 1e).
Figure 1: Establishment of Rgs5-/- mice.

a, Rgs5 exon 1 was flanked with loxP sites, and a neomycin (neo) cassette was introduced into intron 1 and flanked by flip sites for removal after the selection process. SpeI restriction sites are shown. b, Left: Southern blot analysis of SpeI-digested tail DNA derived from F1 offspring after crossbreeding with Cre-deleter (CreDel) mice and wild-type controls. Right: PCR with reverse transcription (RT–PCR) analysis of organs from a Rgs5+/+ and a Rgs5-/- mouse. Hprt1, hypoxanthine phosphoribosyltransferase. c, The number of angiogenic islets in 18-week-old wild-type (grey bar) and Rgs5-deficient (white bar) RIP1-Tag5 mice (n = 10). Error bars represent s.e.m. d, Tumour burden in wild-type (open squares) and Rgs5-deficient (open circles) mice at the age of 22, 25 and 28 weeks (n = 10; range: Rgs5+/+, 41–87 mm3, 53–108 mm3, 57–132 mm3, respectively; Rgs5-/-, 35–128 mm3, 63–135 mm3 and 82–166 mm3, respectively). e, Kaplan–Meier survival analysis of RIP1-Tag5 wild-type (+/+, open squares, n = 82) and RIP1-Tag5
Rgs5-/- mice (open circles, n = 82, P < 0.0001).
To assess tumour vascular morphology, insulinomas in RIP1-Tag5 wild-type or Rgs5-deficient RIP1-Tag5 mice at 27 weeks of age were visualized after lectin perfusion using confocal microscopy (Fig. 2a–c). Notably, the vascular network in Rgs5-/- insulinomas resembles normal vessels with regard to vessel diameters and distribution (for overview, see Supplementary Fig. 2). This is in contrast with insulinomas in wild-type mice, which display a chaotic vascular architecture with large vessels adjacent to small vessels and a heterogeneous vessel density. This finding demonstrates that loss of Rgs5 expression results in vessel normalization.
Figure 2: Vascular normalization in Rgs5-deficient tumours.

a, Confocal images of lectin-perfused vessels in RIP1-Tag5 wild-type (+/+, n = 12) and Rgs5-deficient (-/-, n = 15) size-matched tumours (40–65 mm3), and C3H controls (pancreas; n = 10). Arrowheads point at a vessel with small caliber next to a vessel with large caliber (arrows). For these images, a
20 objective was used; scale bar, 50
m. b, Mean vessel diameters were quantified from wild-type (+/+) or Rgs5-deficient (-/-), size-matched tumours and C3H pancreatic tissue (C3H; 5 fields per tumour, 15 tumours, *P = 0.0009). c, Vessel density within randomly selected fields excluding the tumour periphery (5 fields per tumour, 15 tumours, *P < 0.0001). d, Confocal images from wild-type (+/+) and Rgs5-deficient (-/-) mice, labelled with anti-
SMA (green, upper panels) and anti-PDGFR
(green, lower panels). Endothelial cells (EC) were stained with anti-CD31 (red). For these images, a
60 objective was used; scale bar, 20
m. e, Quantitative increase of the number of
SMA-, desmin-, NG2- and PDGFR
-positive pericytes in wild-type (+/+, grey bars) and Rgs5-deficient (-/-, white bars) mice. The ratio of total area of green staining (pericyte markers) to red staining (EC) is provided (5 fields per tumour, 15 tumours, *P = 0.0001, **P = 0.002, ***P = 0.0001). All error bars represent s.e.m.
Because vascular Rgs5 expression is restricted to pericytes, we hypothesized that pericyte maturation, abundance and/or attachment along the vessel wall is intimately associated with the observed vascular normalization. Pericyte coverage and association with endothelial cells were unchanged in Rgs5-deficient tumours (Supplementary Fig. 3). However, pericyte phenotypes differed between wild-type and Rgs5-deficient tumours. In RIP-Tag wild-type tumours, most pericytes are positive for both PDGFR
and Rgs5, representing immature progenitor cells with the potential to differentiate into mature pericytes in vitro. A smaller subpopulation of mature pericytes that are immunoreactive for NG2 (also known as Cspg4), desmin and
SMA (also known as Acta2) is also found in these tumours8. By contrast, Rgs5-deficient tumour pericytes in age- and size-matched tumour samples predominantly express
SMA and also NG2—recognized markers of maturity8 (Fig. 2d, e). These data indicate that in the absence of Rgs5, tumour pericytes are of a more mature phenotype.
Diverse functions have been described for pericytes, ranging from haemodynamic regulation to vessel stability and permeability15. Because Rgs5-deficient mice display notably improved vascular integrity and maturity, we reasoned that concomitant changes in the tumour microenvironment were also likely. Interestingly, Rgs5 expression has been shown to be increased under hydrostatic pressure in vitro, underscoring a direct correlation between angiogenesis, intratumoral hydrostatic pressure and Rgs5 expression16. We found oxygen supply to be improved in Rgs5-deficient tumours compared to wild-type tumours, as demonstrated by a reduced tumour hypoxia; this was visualized by the formation of pimonidazole adducts (Fig. 3a). This finding may contribute to a growth advantage for Rgs5-deficient tumours, resulting in poorer survival (Fig. 1e).
Figure 3: Improved oxygenation and reduced vessel leakiness in Rgs5-/- tumours.

a, Hypoxia in 27-week-old RIP1-Tag5 (+/+) and RIP1-Tag5
Rgs5-/- (-/-) mice (n = 20 tumours, size matched, range of 40–65 mm3, P < 0.0001). For these images, a
20 objective was used; scale bar, 50
m. Error bars represent s.e.m. b, Photographs represent T1-weighted (T1w; post CM, post contrast media) MRI images and the corresponding colour-coated parameter maps of the exchange rate constant kep (indicating vessel permeability), and T2-weighted MRI images of RIP1-Tag5 wild-type (+/+, upper panel) and RIP1-Tag5
Rgs5-/- (-/-, lower panel) mice recorded with a 1.5 tesla (T) whole-body MR scanner in combination with a small animal coil. Arrows indicate location of tumours. BO, bowel; K, kidney; M, dorsal muscle; SP, spine. Graphs represent quantitative analyses of MRI studies (one-sided t-test): kep, exchange rate constant; A, amplitude indicating relative blood volume (n = 10, *P = 0.008). Error bars represent s.d.
To evaluate further the physiological impact of vascular maturation, we compared vascular permeability of wild-type and Rgs5-/- tumours using dynamic contrast-enhanced magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) on 27-week-old mice. Notably, normalized tumour vessels in Rgs5-/- mice showed a 50% reduction in permeability for the contrast agent compared to wild-type RIP1-Tag5 tumours (Fig. 3b, P = 0.008). These are the first functional data demonstrating reduced leakiness of angiogenic vessels on loss of gene function in vivo. Thus, absence of Rgs5 results in a reduced number of enlarged tumour vessels, increased oxygen supply to the tumour parenchyma and decreased tumour vascular permeability. These key findings were reproduced in a fibrosarcoma transplantation model (AG104A) that was subcutaneously grown in Rgs5-deficient mice (Supplementary Fig. 4). Rgs5 is also a marker for developing pericytes in the brain17, and its expression persists in adult brain vessels. We therefore investigated the role of RGS5 in the barrier function of brain capillaries during ischaemia. Interestingly, brain oedema after transient cerebral ischaemia was significantly reduced in Rgs5-deficient mice, demonstrating decreased permeability for plasma molecules in brain capillaries (Supplementary Table 1), and strongly supports our intratumoral findings (Fig. 3b).
Our previous work on RIP1-Tag5 tumour immunity showed a strong correlation between vascular remodelling induced by intratumoral inflammation and lymphocyte influx5, 18, 19. However, we did not know whether lymphocyte migration into tumour parenchyma was enhanced by vessel remodelling or by an ongoing local immune response. We sought to address this question by adoptively transferring ex vivo activated H–2k-restricted anti-Tag CD4+ and CD8+ T cells into 27-week-old tumour-bearing RIP1-Tag5
Rgs5-/- mice bred into the C3H background (H–2k). Seven days after transfer (the peak of pre-activated Tag-specific T cell proliferation in vivo19), tumours were harvested and analysed. Untreated tumours in wild-type RIP1-Tag5 mice did not show a spontaneous T-cell infiltrate; by contrast, Rgs5-deficient mice consistently displayed a higher degree of spontaneous T-cell infiltration, although this did not reach statistical significance (Fig. 4a and Supplementary Fig. 5). Vessel wall inflammation or upregulation of cytokines and chemokines in untreated Rgs5-/- tumours were not observed. However, after adoptive transfer (total of 5
106 CD4+ and CD8+ T cells), tumours in the Rgs5-deficient mice were massively infiltrated by CD8+ and CD4+ T cells, whereas wild-type RIP1-Tag5 tumours showed no significant increase in infiltrating lymphocytes (Fig. 4a and Supplementary Fig. 5). Thus, Rgs5 loss in angiogenic blood vessels 'opens' tumours for immune cell penetration—a very notable finding further substantiated by impressive survival in subsequent studies.
Figure 4: Immune-mediated tumour rejection after vascular normalization.

a, Spontaneous infiltration of CD8+ immune cells measured in tumours of 27-week-old RIP1-Tag5 wild-type (+/+) and Rgs5-deficient (-/-) mice (upper images). Infiltration of CD8+ T cells after adoptive transfer into 27-week-old RIP1-Tag5 wild-type and Rgs5-/- mice (middle images) and corresponding anti-Tag tumour staining (lower images). For these images, a
10 objective was used; scale bar, 100
m. The graph shows quantification of CD8+ lymphocytic infiltration in size-matched RIP1-Tag5 wild-type (grey bars) and Rgs5-deficient (white bars) tumours without treatment and after adoptive transfer (5 fields per tumour, n = 15 tumours, *P < 0.0001). Error bars represent s.e.m. b–d, Kaplan–Meier-survival studies on RIP1-Tag5 wild-type (Rgs5+/+, open squares, n = 10–16) and RIP1-Tag5
Rgs5-/- mice (Rgs5-/-, open circles, n = 12–16) treated with: b, pre-activated anti-Tag T cells (logrank test, P = 0.0004); c, non-specific ConA-activated T cells (P = 0.27); or d, naive T cells from C3H mice (P = 0.24). Treatment start, 23 weeks; untreated controls are shown in Fig. 1e. e, Survival of RIP1-Tag5 wild-type (open square, n = 16) and Rgs5-deficient (open circle, n = 16) mice after vaccination with Tag and CpG-ODN 1668, P < 0.0001. Treatment start: 23 weeks.
Cohorts of wild-type and Rgs5-deficient RIP1-Tag5 mice (23 weeks old with significant tumour burdens; average range, 50–120 mm3) were adoptively transferred with in vitro activated CD4+ and CD8+ anti-Tag T cells in two-week intervals. In parallel, equal numbers of non-specifically (concanavalin A, ConA) activated or naive T cells from C3H control mice were transferred. As previously reported, adoptive transfer of activated, Tag-specific, naive or ConA-activated lymphocytes alone does not confer a survival advantage to RIP1-Tag5 mice19, 20, with the mice succumbing to insulinomas at 32
2, 29
2 and 29
3 weeks of age, respectively (Fig. 4b–d). However, RIP1-Tag5
Rgs5-/- recipients showed substantially prolonged survival after the transfer of pre-activated, Tag-specific T cells (age 41
7 weeks, P = 0.0004; the experiment was terminated when surviving mice reached 48 weeks), correlating with the marked parenchymal influx of anti-Tag immune cells (Fig. 4a), although repeated T-cell infusions were required owing to their limited lifespan in a non-inflammatory tumour environment. This survival advantage is tumour-antigen-specific and requires activated anti-Tag T cells because no such effect was seen with transfer of ConA-activated or naive lymphocytes (survival: 28
3 and 27
3 weeks, respectively, Fig. 4c, d). Similarly, Rgs5-deficient mice are highly responsive to therapeutic anti-Tag vaccination (survival: 47
7 weeks, P < 0.0001, started at 23 weeks); in contrast, vaccination strategies in wild-type RIP1-Tag5 mice are only successful in an early prophylactic setting before tumour development (starting at week 6, ref. 20), and fail later, when highly vascularized tumours are established (Fig. 4e and Supplementary Fig. 6).
The present study identifies RGS5 as a key regulator controlling the aberrant morphology of the tumour vasculature. Moreover, our results demonstrate the highly dynamic and reversible nature of tumour angiogenesis. Loss of Rgs5 gene function induces notable morphological and physiological changes in the tumour vasculature and microenvironment. Importantly, deficiency of Rgs5 reduces angiogenic activity and notably improves the outcome of specific therapeutic interventions.
This study has some overlapping features with anti-angiogenesis therapy in relation to vessel diameters and alleviation of hypoxia. Blocking vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) signalling in tumours has been shown to create a 'vascular normalization window' that decreases interstitial pressure and enhances tumour oxygenation and the therapeutic response to cytotoxic drugs and/or radiation in mouse and human cancers21, 22. Rgs5 deficiency is, however, clearly distinct with regard to vessel density and results in changes to intratumoral pericyte phenotype rather than pericyte coverage23. Furthermore, we show for the first time, to our knowledge, an association between vessel normalization in the absence of Rgs5 and an increased anti-tumour immune response. Whereas VEGF-blocking therapies clearly enhance drug efficacy, correlating with changes in vascular morphology, pericyte maturation shown in this study may also contribute to the anti-tumour effects by directly influencing leukocyte attachment and transmigration into tumour parenchyma. There is emerging evidence that resistance develops to anti-VEGF/VEGF receptor therapies, and that re-growth of treated tumours may occur due to compensation by other pro-angiogenic factors24. Here we provide novel mechanistic insights into reversing tumour angiogenesis independently of anti-angiogenic drugs by targeting G-protein signalling. Studies are under way to elucidate pathways regulated by RGS5 in tumour pericytes for pharmacotherapeutic intervention in combination with immune therapy. Recognition that RGS5 is a broadly expressed tumour antigen25 and is also vessel-associated in numerous tumours (for example, astrocytomas and insulinomas10, renal cell carcinoma26 and hepatocellular carcinoma27) confirms its general importance in tumorigenesis and expands potential therapeutic opportunities.
Methods Summary
Rgs5-deficient mice were established by removing exon 1. Rgs5-/- mice were crossbred with RIP1-Tag5, SV40 large T antigen transgenic mice on a C3H background. Angiogenic islets and tumours were isolated from pancreatic tissue. Confocal microscopy was performed on lectin-perfused, albumin/gelatine-embedded, vibrotome-dissected tissue to assess vascular density and vessel diameters. Anti-
SMA, anti-PDGFR
, anti-NG2 and anti-desmin histology was used to assess pericyte maturation. Hypoxia in islet tumours was detected by the formation of pimonidazole adducts after the injection of pimonidazole hydrochloride compound into tumour-bearing mice. MRI was performed using a 1.5 tesla whole-body MR-scanner (Siemens Symphony) in combination with a custom-made radio-frequency coil for excitation and signal reception to assay vascular leakiness. Anti-Tag, CD4+ and CD8+ transgenic T cells were used for adoptive transfers to evaluate lymphocyte access into tumours. Vaccination studies were performed using 50
g of Tag protein mixed with 50
g of CpG-oligodeoxynucleotide (ODN) 1668.


