Access

Correspondence

Nature 416, 785 (25 April 2002) | doi:10.1038/416785a

'Practical autonomy' entitles some animals to rights

Steve Wise1

  1. Center for the Expansion of Fundamental Rights, Inc., 896 Beacon Street, Boston, Massachusetts 02215, USA
Top

Basic rights stem from the ability to desire, to act intentionally and to have a sense of self.

In your Opinion article "Rights, wrongs and ignorance" (Nature 416, 351; 2002), you urge scientists and lawyers to challenge the arguments for the basic rights of great apes and other non-human animals that I made in my books Rattling the Cage (Profile Books/Perseus; 2000) and the forthcoming Drawing the Line (Perseus; 2002). You say that some cognitive scientists will challenge my interpretation of the scientific evidence.