Nature Publishing Group, publisher of Nature, and other science journals and reference works
my account e-alerts subscribe register
Sunday 22 October 2017
Journal Home
Current Issue
Download PDF
Export citation
Export references
Send to a friend
More articles like this

Review Article
Nature 283, 817 - 823 (28 February 1980); doi:10.1038/283817a0

Nuclear weapons and power-reactor plutonium

Amory B. Lovins

Consultant Physicist, c/o Friends of the Earth Ltd, 9 Poland Street, London W1V 3DG, UK

With modest design sophistication, high-burn-up plutonium from power reactors can produce powerful and predictable nuclear explosions. There is no way to ‘denature’ plutonium. Power reactors are not implausible but rather attractive as military production reactors. Current promotion of quasi-civilian nuclear facilities rests, dangerously, on contrary assumptions.



1. Wohlhstetter, A. Foreign Policy, 88−96, 145−179 (Winter, 1976/7).
2. Hill, J. in Nuclear or Not? (eds Foley, G. & van Buren, E. A.) 174 (Heinemann, London, 1978).
3. Avery, D. Testimony to 1977 Windscale Inquiry (26 July 1977).
4. Beckurts, K. H. Die Zeit (Hamburg) 30, 9 December 1977.
5. Union des Centrales Suisse d'Électricité, Journal de Genève, 24 July 1979.
6. AKA Committee, Spent Nuclear Fuel and Radioactive Waste, 43 (Rep.SOU: 1976:32, Libervorlag, Stockholm, 1976).
7. Cohen, K. The Science and Science Fiction of Reprocessing and Proliferation, AIF Fuel Cycle Conf. Kansas City (1977).
8. Walske, C. Nuclear Energy Environment in the United States, Madrid (Atomic Industrial Forum, 1976),
9. Westinghouse Energy Information Sheet, Plutonium (Westinghouse Energy Action Office, Pittsburgh, 1978).
10. McCormack, M. Congr. Rec. H6528, 12 July 1978.
11. Wohlstetter, A. et al. Moving Toward Life in a Nuclear Armed Crowd? (Rep. ACDA/PAB-263 to US Arms Control & Disarmament Agency, Pan Heuristics, Los Angeles, 1976).
12. Barnard, G. I. et al. A Report on the International Control of Atomic Energy, Rep. 2498 (US Dept. of State, 16 March 1946), reprinted at 127−198, US Senate Committee on Government Operations, Peaceful Nuclear Exports and Weapons Proliferation: A Compendium (USGPO, 1975).
13. Lovins, A. B. Soft Energy Paths: Toward a Durable Peace, Ch. 11 (Pelican, London, 1977).
14. Gilinsky, V. Plutonium, Proliferation, and Policy (USNRC S-14-76, 1976).
15. Taylor, T. B. in International Safeguards and Nuclear Industry (ed. Willrich, M.) 181 (Johns Hopkins, Baltimore, 1973).
16. Goldschmidt, B. The Atomic Adventure, 50 (Macmillan, New York, 1964).
17. Mark, J. C. in Impact of New Technologies on the Arms Race (eds Feld, B. T. et al.) 137−138 (Pugwash/MIT, Cambridge, 1971).
18. Hall, D. B. in Preventing Nuclear Theft: Guidelines for Industry and Government (eds Leachman, R. B. & Althoff, P.) 275−283 (Praeger, New York, 1972).
19. Willrich, M. & Taylor, T. B. Nuclear Theft: Risks and Safeguards (Ballinger, Cambridge, 1974).
20. McPhee, J. The Curve of Binding Energy (Ballantine, New York, 1975).
21. Commission on Environmental Pollution, 6th Rep. (HMSO, London, 1976).
22. Ranger Uranium Environmental Inquiry, 1st Rep. (Australian Government Publishing Service, Canberra, 1976).
23. Shea, J. R. (Director, Office of International Programs, USNRC) ERDA Unclassified Briefing on Reactor Plutonium and Nuclear Explosives, memorandum to Commissioners, 3 December 1976.
24. US Congress, Office of Technology Assessment, Nuclear Proliferation and Safeguards (Praeger, New York, 1977).
25. American Physical Society Study Group on Nuclear Fuel Cycles and Waste Management, Rev. Mod. Phys. 50, Part II, S1−S185 (1978). | ISI |
26. Griffin, J. (US Energy Research & Development Administration), Press Statement, 4 August 1977.
27. Wohlstetter, A. et al. Nuclear Physics: Fuel Without the Bomb, 21−56 (Ballinger,Cambridge, 1978).
28. Gilinsky, V. Plutonium, Proliferation and the Price of Money (USNRC S-78-8, 1978).
29. Lovins, A. B. Bull. atom. Sci. 35(2), 16−22 (1978). | ISI |
30. Pigford, T. H. & Ang, K. P. Hlth Phys. 29, 451−68 (1975). | ChemPort |
31. Seiden, R. W. ANS/AIF Meet. Washington, DC (Lawrence Livermore Laboratory, 1976).
32. Gyldén, N. & Holm, L. W. Risker für kärnladdningsframställning i det fördolda (FOA 4 rapport C 4567-T3, Forsvarets Forskningsanstalt [Swedish Defense Research Institute], Stockholm, 1974); or Risks of nuclear explosives production in secret, Rep. ERDA-tr-45 (Natn. Tech. Inf. Service, Springfield, 1974).
33. US Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Final GESMO, Rep.NUREG-0002 (1976).
34. Selden, R. W. Reactor Plutonium and Nuclear Explosives (Lawrence Livermore Laboratory, l November 1976).
35. Harding, J. Nuclear Fuel Burn-up and Fuel Cycle Costs, response to LILCO interrogatories (California Energy Commission, Sacramento, 1976).
36. International Atomic Energy Agency, Reps. GOV/1842 and GOV/1897 (incl. Annexes) (IAEA, Vienna, 1977 and 1978 respectively).
37. De Volpi, A. Proliferation, Plutonium and Policy (Pergamon, New York, 1979).
38. Clayton, E. D. Nucl. Sci. Engng 52, 417−20 (1973). | ChemPort |
39. 10 Code of Federal Regulations §73.1(b).
40. Foster, J. Jr Encyc. Am. 20, 251 (1970).
41. Taylor, T. B. A. Rev. nucl. Sci. 25, 407−21 (1975).
42. Seiden, R. W. Preprint (December 1976 updating ref. 34).
43. Meyer, W., Loyalka, S. K., Nelson, W. E. & Williams, R. W. Nucl. Safety 18, 427−38 (1977). | ChemPort |
44. Campbell, D. O. & Gift, E. H. Proliferation-Resistant Nuclear Fuel Cycles (Preliminary Rep. ORNL/TM-6392, Oak Ridge National Laboratory, 1978).
45. Olds, F. C. Power Engng. 38−46 (August 1977). | ChemPort |
46. De Volpi, A. Trans. Am. nucl. Soc. 30, 298 (1978). | ChemPort |
47. American Physical Society Study Group on Nuclear Fuel Cycles and Waste Management, Rev. Mod. Phys. 50, Part II S104n2 (1978).
48. Ott, H. C. Power Engng 24, 26 (November 1977).
49. Nonproliferation Alternative Systems Assessment Program, Nuclear Proliferation and Civilian Nuclear Power, Vol. 2, 2−40 draft Rep. DOE/NE-0001 (US Dept. of Energy, Dec. 1979).
50. Jauho, P. & Virtamo, J. The Effect of Peaceful Use of Atomic Energy upon Nuclear Proliferation (Finnish Academy of Science and Letters, Helsinki, 1973).
51. Kjernekraftutvalget, Nuclear Power and Safety, 237 Rep. NOU 1978:35C (Universitets-forlaget, Oslo, 1978).
52. Wohlstetter, A. et al. Nuclear Physics: Fuel Without the Bomb, 35 (Ballinger, Cambridge, 1978).
53. Glasstone, S. The Effects of Nuclear Weapons (USAEC/USGPO, Washington DC, 1962/64).
54. Taylor, T. B. et al. Modification of Strategic Special Nuclear Materials to Deter Their Theft or Unauthorized Use, Rep. IRT-378-R (International Research & Technology Corp., Arlington VA, 1975) (part of USNRC Special Safeguards Study).
55. American Physical Society Study Group on Nuclear Fuel Cycles and Waste Management, Rev. Mod. Phys. 50, Part II S98 (1978).
56. American Physical Society Study Group on Nuclear Fuel Cycles and Waste Management, Rev. Mod. Phys. 50, Part II S97 (1978).
57. Nye, J. S. Jr Time to Plan : The International Search for Safeguardable Nuclear Power (US State Dept. Houston, 30 June 1977).
58. Snyder, B. J. Non-Proliferation Characteristics of Radioactive Fuel (Office of Policy Evaluation, USNRC, Washington DC, 1978).
59. Gorleben International Review, Report to the Prime Minister of Lower Saxony on the proposed Entsorgungszentrum (Ch. 4), and transcript of the Hannover Hearings (Niedersächsisches Sozialministerium, Hannover, 1979); summarised at 99-125 in Hatzfeldt, H. et al. (eds) Der Gorleben-Report (Fischer Taschenbuch Verlag, Frankfurt/M, 1979).
60. Gilinsky, V. in Nuclear Policies: Fuel Without the Bomb (eds Wohlstetter, A. et al.) 83−91 (Ballinger, Cambridge, 1978).
61. Feiveson, H. A. A. Rev. Energy 3, 357−394 (1978). | Article | ISI | ChemPort |

© 1980 Nature Publishing Group
Privacy Policy