Abstract
Quasi-particle excitations in graphene exhibit a unique behavior concerning two key phenomena of mesoscopic physics: electron localization and the quantum Hall effect. A direct transition between these two states has been found in disordered two-dimensional electron gases at low magnetic field. It has been suggested that it is a quantum phase transition, but the nature of the transition is still debated. Despite the large number of works studying either the localization or the quantum Hall regime in graphene, such a transition has not been investigated for Dirac fermions. Here we discuss measurements on low-mobility graphene where the localized state at low magnetic fields and a quantum Hall state at higher fields are observed. We find that the system undergoes a direct transition from the insulating to the Hall conductor regime. Remarkably, the transverse magneto-conductance shows a temperature independent crossing point, pointing to the existence of a genuine quantum phase transition.
Similar content being viewed by others
Introduction
In two dimensional (2D) electron systems with an arbitrary weak elastic disorder, the scaling theory of localization predicts that at zero temperature all electron states are localized, resulting in an insulating system1,2. The transition from the high temperature regime characterized by a metallic behavior to the insulating one is still debated for 2DEGs3 and is even more controversial for graphene, where the relativistic nature of the excitations should hinder localization, at least for certain types of disorder4. Nevertheless, experiments show that in the presence of intervalley scattering, electrons in graphene are subject to localization, with a crossover from strong localization5 to weak localization6 behavior when the localization length ξ increases far beyond the phase coherence length Lϕ. The application of a perpendicular magnetic field can lead to the emergence of criticality in 2D disordered systems. At low field it increases the localization length by breaking the time reversal symmetry, it can therefore suppress localization. At high magnetic fields Landau levels are formed, with extended states near the band centers, which can account for electron transport in the quantum Hall (QH) regime. They also bring into play a new length scale, that is the magnetic length nm, here B is the magnetic field. Electron localization induced by disorder is also a key component of the QH effect, notably accounting for the finite width of the transverse magnetoresistance plateaus and its role has been recently addressed in literature for graphene7,8. Here we discuss its relevance for the insulator-to-quantum Hall conductor (Ins-QH) transition at low field, where graphene proves itself as an ideal tool due to the robustness of Landau levels with respect to both disorder and temperature, arising from the large cyclotron gap . The high field case has also been discussed in litterature9. The peculiarity of our samples is evident if we compare the Drude mobility of the graphene, where a fully developed QH effect was found, on the order of few hundred cm2V−1s−1, to that of the disordered 2DEGs where the Ins-QH transition has been generally observed, typically on the order of several to several tens of thousands cm2V−1s−1 10,11,12,13,14,15.
Results
Graphene characterization
The two epitaxial graphene films that are used in our magneto-transport experiments were grown by thermal decomposition of SiC16,17 and are mostly monolayer, with only a small fraction of bilayer, as evidenced by X-ray and angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy (XPS/ARPES) measurements, shown in Fig. 1a (see also Methods and Supplementary information). One of the graphene films was exposed to molecular oxygen prior to the nanofabrication18. Our graphene films have a typical carrier concentration on the order of several 1012 cm−2 and feature a linear band dispersion, indicating that despite disorder a crystalline graphene film is formed. These relatively low carrier concentrations (for epitaxial graphene) are required for observing the QH effect at accessible magnetic fields, on the order of several teslas. The presence of disorder is evidenced by contribution of the D band in the Raman spectra (Fig. 1b). The disorder in our samples is partially due to graphene edges and small fraction of bilayer. Since they both induce valley mixing, they favor localization at low temperatures. We used standard e-beam lithography, metal deposition and dry etching to produce Hall bars with a large central region of 50 × 50 μm2. A micrograph of one finished Hall bar is sketched in Fig. 1c, together with the principle of a Hall measurement.
Magneto-transport measurements: weakly disordered sample
In Fig. 2 we present the longitudinal and the transverse magnetoresistivity of the Hall bar S1, measured during the first cooldown of the sample. The data are recorded as a function of the applied perpendicular magnetic field for different temperatures, covering almost two orders of magnitude, from 1.6 K up to 100 K. The peak in the longitudinal resistivity ρxx at zero field is a manifestation of weak localization attesting the presence of significant valley mixing5,19,20 and its large width of about 1 T is an indication of a short localization length. In such disordered samples, it turns out to be difficult to separate the Drude, weak localization and the electron-electron contributions21,22. While an accurate fit of the weak localization has proven to be challenging, the estimated phase coherence length Lϕ ≈ 70 nm at T = 1.6 K is close to typical values reported for graphene with short range disorder5. We also notice that the standard weak localization formula for graphene19 may not be fully justified because the inter-valley short-range scattering seems to dominate over the intra-valley scattering. At high magnetic fields, ρxx decreases when the temperature is lowered because of the onset of Landau quantization. This is confirmed by the behavior of the Hall resistivity ρxy, which becomes highly nonlinear for large B, following the drop of ρxx, as expected before the appearance of a quantum Hall plateau. At low magnetic fields, the transverse resistivity ρxy varies about linearly. The kink in ρxy around zero field, which develops when the temperature is decreased, is due to a geometrical contribution of ρxx on ρxy (see Supplementary). It also leads to an apparent shift from zero of the ρxy curves crossing point. The sample gradually evolves from a more localized state towards the relativistic quantum Hall regime23,24,25. However, we do not find indications of a direct Ins-QH transition such as a temperature independent fixed point in the magnetoconductivity. This may result from the suppression of localization before the onset of the QH effect.
Direct Insulating to QH transition: strongly disordered sample
Consistent with this scenario, we find that the behavior is different for more disordered samples with lower carrier concentration. Here localization effects are more robust and Landau quantization develops at lower fields. In Fig. 3 we plot both the longitudinal and the Hall resistivity recorded at different temperatures, for two graphene Hall bars. The two data sets in Fig. 3 refer to sample S1 (Fig. 3 a–b), but when measured on a second cooldown and to sample S2 (Fig. 3 a–b). The graphene film used for the latter was exposed to molecular oxygen prior to the Hall bar fabrication18. This treatment favors the observation of a direct Ins-QH transition. It decreases the carrier concentration of graphene and could enhance the number of short-range defects responsible for intervalley scattering26. Both samples exhibit the same qualitative behavior, the ρxx curves, which shows negative magnetoresistance as observed in disordered graphene in Ref. 27 are strongly affected by temperature and, remarkably, they all cross at a well-defined and T-independent magnetic field Bc1. Such a critical point suggests the existence of a zero-temperature quantum phase transition. Actually, at this field the sign of the temperature coefficient of the resistivity changes, identifying two regimes, a low-field insulating regime where the resistivity increases rapidly with decreasing temperature and a quantum Hall regime at high fields, where the resistivity diminishes when T is decreased. The formation of a quantum Hall state at high fields is evidenced by the vanishing longitudinal resistivity and by the plateau on the Hall resistivity at a value h/2e2.
We now focus on the data measured on device S2, since it displays a higher resistivity at zero field, suggesting a more localized state and a better quantization of the Hall plateau. We start by estimating the carrier concentration n = 1.2 × 1012 cm−2 from the low-field Hall resistivity at 22 K, where localization and electron-electron interaction effects are less important. From the value of ρxx, still at 22 K, almost constant, equal to 10 kΩ, over 3 T-field range below Bc1 where localization effects are further reduced, we also estimate the Drude resistivity ρD ≈ 8 kΩ, by subtracting a small ≈2 kΩ-contribution ρee from the electron-electron interaction28. The value of this contribution can be calculated with the number of multiplet channels participating in the interaction reduced to c = 3 by the strong intervalley scattering, the Fermi-liquid constant , which is the interaction parameter, equal to −0.1, as usually reported in literature for graphene21,29,30 and τtr = ltr/vF the transport time deduced from ρD. The consistency of the values calculated for ρee and ρD was checked a posteriori. The transport scattering length calculated from the Drude resistivity, which does not include localization effects, is short, as we find . The Drude mobility is μ = 1/ρDne = 860 cm2/Vs.
The graphene zero-field resistivity of the order of h/e2 at low T, much larger than its Drude value of 8 kΩ, indicates that quantum interferences are a dominant feature in electron transport, leading to a strong localization at low T. This is confirmed by the small value of the localization length ξ ~ 50 nm estimated using the relation 5,31. Interestingly, Xsi appears very close to the transport length ltr. All these features indicate a stronger localization of electrons at low magnetic field than in the first cooldown of sample S1, with the insulating behavior of localized states in 2D graphene being manifested by the high value of the resistivity at zero magnetic field and its strong temperature dependence. The appearance of the plateau at Landau level filling factor near ν = nh/eB = 2 in the high field Hall magnetoresistance is also important. It confirms that despite the low mobility, the Landau levels are sufficiently quantized to still manifest the chiral Dirac fermions character in the magnetotransport measurements. While not exactly identical to the ratio of the cyclotron energy separating the Landau band centers to the disorder broadening of the bands themselves, the classical quantity ωcτtr, with ωc the cyclotron pulsation, is commonly used to estimate the magnetic field where Landau level quantization becomes sensitive considering that at this point ωcτtr = 1. To some extent, this criterion should also apply to determine the critical magnetic filed of the Ins-QH transition. However, for samples S1 (second cooldown) and S2, the transition occurs at and respectively, for ωcτtr = 0.2 and 0.34 respectively, with . Even if the transition is frequently observed for ωcτtr < 1 in disordered 2DEGS11,13,14,15,32, the very low ωcτtr value found in those graphene samples at the transition is remarkable. This could be attributed to the anticipated onset of the robust graphene quantum Hall effect at which requires an in-depth study, notably because it is also an asset for certain applications, such as the quantum Hall metrology33. More generally, the occurrence of the Ins-QH transition at magnetic field lower than expected also questions the relevance of the criterion ωcτtr = 1 to determine the position of this transition. It is worth noting that, near the magnetic field Bc1, the magnetic length lB, for example equal to 11.5 nm in S2, is close to our estimation of the localization and the transport scattering length. This confirms lB, Xsi, ltr are a meaningful T-independent criterion to estimate the position of the Ins-QH transition.
Discussion
The crossing point in the longitudinal magnetoresistance has already been interpreted as the signature of a QPT in 2DEGs. Such interpretation has been questioned by Huckestein34, who proposed a scenario with a smooth crossover due to the suppression of weak localization. Electron-electron interaction and weak localization corrections to the longitudinal conductivity in cleaner samples can also originate a fixed crossing point in the longitudinal resistivity due to the conductivity/resistivity tensor conversion. However, in our experiments the strong nonlinear character of ρxy which anticipates the fully developed ν = 2 plateau at high fields proves that Landau quantization is already important at fields as low as 3 T, much smaller than the crossing point field , suggesting that the QHE is a key ingredient of the transition observed. It has been suggested that a stronger indication of the QPT could be obtained by the analysis the magnetoconductivity data35, which are linked to the resistivity by the relations and . The main advantage here is that the transverse conductivity σxy is not affected by electron-electron interaction corrections. In addition, in the scaling theory of the QHE, these are some values of σxy which behave as fixed points under renormalization36. Magnetoconductivity curves for sample S2 are plotted in Figure 4. The shift in the longitudinal conductivity (Fig. 4a) reveals the presence of electron-electron interactions. The presence of a T-independent crossing point in the transverse magnetoconductivity (Fig. 4b) which is observed at a field BC2 = 4.5 T close to , strongly hints to a quantum phase transition. In addition, such a fixed point on σxy(B) has been observed on sample S1 (second cooldown) which is claimed to undergo a direct Ins-QH transition and not in the first cooldown when a gradual crossover occurs.
It is therefore tempting to analyze our data near the critical point using the scaling theory of the quantum Hall effect37, which is known to capture the physics of the delocalization-localization transitions in both 2DEGs and graphene. The divergence of the localization length is described by a power law ξ ∝ (E − Ec)−γ, where Ec is the energy of the delocalized state at the center of the Landau level. The exponent γ is not easily accessible, but is linked to the parameter κ = p/2γ, where p, usually taken to be 2 for graphene2, describes the temperature dependence of the phase coherence length Lϕ ∝ T−p/2. The critical exponent for the Ins-QH transition κ can be extracted from magnetoconductivity data which are expected to scale with temperature according to ∝ T−κ at the critical magnetic field11,14. In the case of sample S2, κ was simply extracted from the linear fit of the ln(dσxy/dB) versus ln(T) plot at BC2, as shown in the inset of Fig. 4 b. The data follow the expected linear relation and κ, equal to the slope of the fit was found to be 0.26 ± 0.03. This experimental value of κ is in good agreement with what is reported for more conventional 2DEGs, in the case of spin-degenerate Landau levels and dominant short-range disorder, for the Ins-QH transition11,14, as well as for QH plateau to QH plateau transitions2,36,38. This seems to suggest that the low-field insulator to QH transitions, QH to QH transitions and QH to high-field insulator transitions belong to the same QPT universality class.
Thus, we have shown that for low-mobility graphene with resistivity on the order of h/e2 a direct transition between a localized and the quantum Hall regime is induced by the magnetic field. Analysis of the magnetoconductivty hints to a genuine quantum phase transition, rather than a simple crossover. The transition can be described by a scaling law with a critical exponent of 0.26. Thanks to its large cyclotron gap, robust to strong disorder graphene is the material of choice for the study of the Ins-QH transition. Such a study could unveil new aspects of the metal-insulator transition in two-dimensional systems due to the relativistic nature of graphene carriers.
Methods
The graphene was grown by thermal decomposition of an undoped 4H-SiC(0001). The substrate was first etched in a hydrogen flux at 1500°C at 200 mbar for 15 min in order to remove any damage caused by surface polishing and to form a step-ordered structure on the surface. After the etching, the substrate was transferred into an ultrahigh vacuum (UHV) chamber with a base pressure of 10−9 mbar. The surface of the substrate was annealed at 600°C during 60 min. The substrates were heated under a Si flux (1 ML/min) at 800°C to remove the native oxide in UHV (P = 2 109 mbar). Graphene was synthesized by exposing the substrate an argon flux at 1350°C under semi-UHV (P = 2105 mbar) during 15 minutes. This induces a growth of a R30° and R30° reconstructions as an intermediate step towards few layer growth of graphene due to Si depletion. The temperature of the substrate was calibrated with an infrared pyrometer in the high temperature range and with a thermocouple in the low temperature range. XPS and ARPES experiments were performed in ultra high vacuum conditions at TEMPO beamline at the SOLEIL Synchrotron facility (Saint-Aubin, France). The Hall bars were structured using standard e-beam lithography and PMMA was used as resist. The etching was performed by a 15 seconds exposure to oxygen plasma in our reactive-ion etching setup. For the electrodes we deposited a palladium-gold bilayer 20/80 nm, followed by lift-off in thrichloroethylene.
References
Abrahams, E., Anderson, P., Licciardello, D. C. & Ramakrishnan, T. Scaling Theory of Localization: Absence of Quantum Diffusion in Two Dimensions. Physical Review Letters 42, 673–676 (1979).
Evers, F. & Mirlin, A. Anderson transitions. Reviews of Modern Physics 80, 1355–1417 (2008).
Smet, J. H. Metalinsulator transition: A plane mystery. Nature Physics 3, 370–372 (2007).
Ponomarenko, L. A. et al. Tunable metal-insulator transition in double-layer graphene heterostructures. Nature Physics 7, 958–961 (2011).
Moser, J. et al. Magnetotransport in disordered graphene exposed to ozone: From weak to strong localization. Physical Review B 81, 205445 (2010).
Morpurgo, A. & Guinea, F. Intervalley Scattering, Long-Range Disorder and Effective Time-Reversal Symmetry Breaking in Graphene. Physical Review Letters 97, 196804 (2006).
Martin, J. et al. The nature of localization in graphene under quantum Hall conditions. Nature Physics 5, 669–674 (2009).
Jung, S. et al. Evolution of microscopic localization in graphene in a magnetic field from scattering resonances to quantum dots. Nature Physics 7, 245–251 (2011).
Chekelesky, J. C. et al. Zero-Energy state in graphene in a High Magnetic Field. Physical Reviez Letters 100, 206801 (2008).
Jiang, H., Johnson, C., Wang, K. & Hannahs, S. Observation of magnetic-field-induced delocalization: Transition from Anderson insulator to quantum Hall conductor. Physical Review Letters 71, 1439–1442 (1993).
Wang, T., Clark, K., Spencer, G., Mack, A. & Kirk, W. Magnetic-field-induced metal-insulator transition in two dimensions. Physical Review Letters 72, 709–712 (1994).
Gusev, G. et al. Absence of delocalised states in a 2D electron gas in a magnetic field below ωcτ = 1. Solid State Communications 100, 269 (1996).
Song, S., Shahar, D., Tsui, D., Xie, Y. & Monroe, D. New Universality at the Magnetic Field Driven Insulator to Integer Quantum Hall Effect Transitions. Physical Review Letters 78, 2200–2203 (1997).
Huang, C. et al. Insulator-quantum Hall conductor transitions at low magnetic field. Physical Review B 65, 3–6 (2001).
Liang, C.-T. et al. On the direct insulator-quantum Hall transition in two-dimensional electron systems in the vicinity of nanoscaled scatterers. Nanoscale research letters 6, 131 (2011).
Berger, C. et al. Electronic confinement and coherence in patterned epitaxial graphene. Science 312, 1191–6 (2006).
Ouerghi, A. et al. Epitaxial graphene on 3C-SiC(111) pseudosubstrate: Structural and electronic properties. Physical Review B 82, 125445 (2010).
Mathieu, C. et al. Effect of oxygen adsorption on the local properties of epitaxial graphene on SiC (0001). Physical Review B 86, 1–5 (2012).
McCann, E. et al. Weak-Localization Magnetoresistance and Valley Symmetry in Graphene. Physical Review Letters 97, 14–17 (2006).
Aleiner, I. L. & Efetov, K. B. Effect of Disorder on Transport in Graphene. Physical Review Letters 97, 236801 (2006).
Lara-Avila, S. et al. Disordered Fermi Liquid in Epitaxial Graphene from Quantum Transport Measurements. Physical Review Letters 107, 166602 (2011).
Eroms, J. Comment on Evidence for Spin-Flip Scattering and Local Moments in Dilute Fluorinated Graphene. Physical Review Letters 109, 179701 (2012).
Zhang, Y., Tan, Y.-W., Stormer, H. L. & Kim, P. Experimental observation of the quantum Hall effect and Berry's phase in graphene. Nature 438, 201–4 (2005).
Novoselov, K. S. et al. Two-dimensional gas of massless Dirac fermions in graphene. Nature 438, 197–200 (2005).
Goerbig, M. Electronic properties of graphene in a strong magnetic field. Reviews of Modern Physics 83, 1193–1243 (2011).
Pallecchi, E. et al. Observation of the quantum Hall effect in epitaxial graphene on SiC(0001) with oxygen adsorption. Applied Physics Letters 100, 253109 (2012).
Hong, X. et al. Colossal negative magnetoresistance in dilute fluorinated graphene. Physical Reviez B 83, 085410 (2011).
Kozikov, A. A., Savchenko, A. K., Narozhny, B. N. & Shytov, A. V. Electron-electron interactions in the conductivity of graphene. Physical Review B 82, 075424 (2010).
Jobst, J., Waldmann, D., Gornyi, I. V., Mirlin, A. D. & Weber, H. B. Electron-Electron Interaction in the Magnetoresistance of Graphene. Physical Review Letters 108, 106601 (2012).
Jouault, B. et al. Interplay between interferences and electron-electron interactions in epitaxial graphene. Physical Review B 83, 195417 (2011).
Kivelson, S., Lee, D.-H. & Zhang, S.-C. Global phase diagram in the quantum Hall effect. Physical Review B 46, 2223–2238 (1992).
Shahar, D., Tsui, D. & Cunningham, J. Observation of the υ = 1 quantum Hall effect in a strongly localized two-dimensional system. Physical Review B 52, R14372–R14375 (1995).
Schopfer, F. & Poirier, W. Graphene-based quantum Hall effect metrology. MRS Bulletin 37, 1255–1264 (2012).
Huckestein, B. Quantum Hall effect at low magnetic fields. Physical Review Letters 84, 3141–3144 (2000).
Hughes, R. J. F. et al. Magnetic-field-induced insulator-quantum Hall-insulator transition in a disordered two-dimensional electron gas. Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter 6, 4763–4770 (1994).
Huckestein, B. Scaling theory of the integer quantum Hall effect. Reviews of Modern Physics 67, 357–396 (1995).
Pruisken, A. Universal singularities in the integral quantum Hall effect. Physical Review Letters 61, 1297–1300 (1988).
Koch, S., Haug, R., Klitzing, K. & Ploog, K. Size-dependent analysis of the metal-insulator transition in the integral quantum Hall effect. Physical Review Letters 67, 883–886 (1991).
Acknowledgements
We acknowledge B. Etienne for fruitful discussions. We thank F. Sirotti, M.G. Silly for the XPS and ARPES experiments. We are grateful to U. Gennser for stimulating discussions and for proofreading our manuscript. D. Kazazis acknowledge LNE financial support within the action incentive contract LNE/10-3-002. This work was supported by the the French Contract No. ANR-2010-BLAN-0304-01-MIGRAQUEL, the French-Tunisian CMCU project 10/G1306 and the RTRA Triangle de la Physique.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Contributions
E.P. and A.O. planned the experiments. A.O. fabricated the graphene layer and characterized it by XPS and ARPES. D.K. and E.P. produced the Hall bars, E.P., D.K., M.R. conducted the measurements, F.L., F.S., W.P. carried out complementary experiments. E.P., M.R., M.O.G., F.S., W.P. and A.O. analyzed the data, D.M. supported the experiment. E.P. wrote the paper with all authors contributing to the final version. A.O. supervised the project.
Ethics declarations
Competing interests
The authors declare no competing financial interests.
Electronic supplementary material
Supplementary Information
Supplementary Material
Rights and permissions
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/3.0/
About this article
Cite this article
Pallecchi, E., Ridene, M., Kazazis, D. et al. Insulating to relativistic quantum Hall transition in disordered graphene. Sci Rep 3, 1791 (2013). https://doi.org/10.1038/srep01791
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/srep01791
This article is cited by
-
High Electron Mobility in Epitaxial Trilayer Graphene on Off-axis SiC(0001)
Scientific Reports (2016)
-
Nonequilibrium fluctuations as a distinctive feature of weak localization
Scientific Reports (2015)
-
High Electron Mobility in Epitaxial Graphene on 4H-SiC(0001) via post-growth annealing under hydrogen
Scientific Reports (2014)
-
Flower-Shaped Domains and Wrinkles in Trilayer Epitaxial Graphene on Silicon Carbide
Scientific Reports (2014)
-
Single step fabrication of N-doped graphene/Si3N4/SiC heterostructures
Nano Research (2014)
Comments
By submitting a comment you agree to abide by our Terms and Community Guidelines. If you find something abusive or that does not comply with our terms or guidelines please flag it as inappropriate.