Introduction

Nucleic acid-based therapeutic technologies have gained significant interest for developing therapies targeting RNA molecules1. So far, four oligonucleotide drugs have been approved by the United States Food and Drug Administration for clinical use2,3,4,5. Vitravene, Kynamro and Eteplirsen are antisense oligonucleotides approved for the treatment of cytomegaloviral retinitis, familial hypercholestrolemia and Duchenne muscular dystrophy respectively, while a nucleic acid aptamer candidate Macugen was approved for age-related macular degeneration2,3,4,5. DNAzymes are another unique class of synthetic catalytic oligonucleotides that can play various roles including gene silencing and as biosensing molecules for diagnostic applications6. DNAzymes anneal to complementary RNA substrates through Watson-Crick base pairing rules and cleaves the phosphodiester bond mainly at purine-pyrimidine or less frequently at purine-purine junction in the presence of divalent metal ions (e.g. Mg2+, Ca2+, Pb2+)7,8,9. DNAzymes possess enzyme-like characteristic and the catalytic activity is dependent on divalent metal ions as cofactors7. The simple structure of DNAzyme includes two binding arms for specific target mRNA binding, and a catalytic core in between the binding arms to catalyse the cleavage of the target mRNA (Fig. 1A). One big advantage of DNAzymes over RNase-H dependent antisense oligonucleotides is that it can recognize and cleave the target mRNA without RNase-H recruitment and the process is reiterative (Fig. 1A).

Figure 1
figure 1

(A) Schematic illustration of DNAzyme-based mRNA cleavage, and (B) structural representations of LNA and inverted thymidine monomers.

Inflammation in the central nervous system is one of the major problems of chronic neurodegenerative disease such as multiple sclerosis (MS)10. ITGA4 is a validated therapeutic target for MS since a humanized monoclonal antibody, natalizumab, against ITGA4 is successful in delaying the disease progression11. The drug interferes with the interaction between ITGA4 and vascular cell adhesion molecule-1 and prevents immune cells from crossing the blood brain barrier and attacking the central nervous system11. Patients treated with natalizumab over several years have reduced or are free of annual relapses, however, there are significant limitations associated with natalizumab such as an increased risk of progressive multifocal leukoencephalopathy and development of side effects including serum sickness, generation of anti-drug antibodies and other adverse effects as discussed in recent reviews12, 13. Herein, we report the development of novel DNAzymes that can efficiently cleave ITGA4 mRNA transcript as potential therapeutics to reduce ITGA4 activity in MS.

Results

Design and screening of first-generation DNAzymes targeting ITGA4 mRNA

Two groups of DNAzymes, one with 10–23 catayltic motif (hammerhead) and the other with 8–17 catalytic motif (arm-loop) (Fig. 2A) were designed to target various exons of the ITGA4 transcript. The sequences of the catalytic regions were pre-fixed according to previous reports14, 15 and the arm regions were designed to be specific and complementary to the ITGA4 mRNA sequences (Fig. 2B). The catalytic activities of these DNAzymes against ITGA4 mRNA were screened in human primary fibroblasts by transfecting DNAzymes at different concentrations (600 nM, 400 nM, 200 nM, 100 nM and 50 nM) for 24 h. RNA was extracted from the cell lysate and the integrity of ITGA4 transcript was assessed by performing RT-PCR. Scrambled sequence (SCR) was used as a negative control to account for the non-specific effects.

Figure 2
figure 2

(A) Schematic illustration of the 10–23 and 8–17 catalytic motifs of DNAzymes. (B) Table for the activities of first-generation DNAzymes targeting ITGA4 mRNA that is directly correlated with the percentages of ITGA4 mRNA knockdown (See Materials and Methods for detailed procedures); The catalytic motifs are shown in red, the arm regions are in black, and the sequences are from 5′ → 3′. p-values were calculated for the activity in fibroblasts which was normalised to the UT using student t-test and *Indicates p-value < 0.05, **Indicates p-value < 0.005 and ***Indicates p-value < 0.0005. p-values have been rounded to 2 s.f. (C) Representative RT-PCR products of the ITGA4 and CycD transcripts from normal human primary fibroblasts after treatment with DNAzyme at different concentrations. The RT-PCR products after treatment with RNV143 are shown here. FL, full-length; UT, untreated; SCR, scrambled sequence; CYCD was used as a loading control. The gel images were cropped to highlight the ITGA4 specific products and the corresponding house-keeping gene control CYCD. The original images are shown in Figure S2 (Supplementary Information).

Dose-dependent reduction of the full-length ITGA4 transcript was observed for all DNAzymes treated samples. The best ITGA4 transcript knockdown was observed at 600 nM and therefore, the efficiency of each DNAzyme was calculated as a percentage of ITGA4 transcript knockdown at 600 nM after normalising to the house keeping gene transcript cyclin D (CYCD) and described as the activity in fibroblasts (Fig. 2B). DNAzyme candidate RNV143 targeting the exon 9 of the ITGA4 mRNA showed highest efficacy with 84% knockdown of ITGA4 (gel shown in Fig. 2C) followed by RNV148 (71% although this was not statistically significant) and RNV145 (68%) (Fig. 2B).

Design and screening of second-generation DNAzymes targeting ITGA4 mRNA

Based on the initial screen, the best performing DNAzyme RNV143 was selected for further modifications. Many studies have shown that increasing the hybridisation arms on either side of the catalytic motif can increase the binding affinity and efficacy16,17,18. In our study, the first generation of DNAzymes initially had 8 nucleotides on one arm and 7 on the other. Several studies showed that the optimal arm lengths vary from 7 to 10 nucleotides long16,17,18,19,20,21. Therefore, the length of RNV143 was systematically increased at the end of both arms, and then the efficacy of the modified DNAzymes was verified. One, two and three nucleotides were added to both arms of RNV143 and named RNV182, RNV183 and RNV184 respectively (Fig. 3). The catalytic activities of these second generation DNAzyme candidates were analysed in human primary fibroblasts as described above. The transfections were repeated at least twice. Notably, a decrease in activities were observed for RNV182 (57%) and RNV183 (74%) at 600 nM compared to the parent DNAzyme RNV143 (84%) (Fig. 3). RNV184 with additional six nucleotides (three on each ends) was the only candidate that showed similar activity to the parent RNV143, with 89% knockdown of ITGA4 mRNA. These results showed that increasing the arm length did not dramatically improve the efficacy of DNAzyme RNV143 in fibroblasts.

Figure 3
figure 3

Second-generation DNAzymes derived from RNV143, targeting the ITGA4 mRNA. The activity of DNAzymes directly correlated with the percentage of ITGA4 mRNA knockdown. Activities of DNAzymes were calculated as described in Materials and Methods. The catalytic motifs are shown in red, the arm regions are in black and the residues modified with LNA are in blue. The sequences are from 5′ → 3′.

Next, we explored the improvement of nuclease stability of the DNAzymes since the natural nucleotide monomers are rapidly degraded in vivo. First, we introduced phosphorothioate (PS) linkages to the arm regions of RNV143 to improve nuclease resistance and named RNV143PS. However, RNV143PS failed to cleave ITGA4 RNA when transfected into the human fibroblasts. Only 10% of the ITGA4 transcript was degraded when treated with RNV143PS while nearly 29% of the ITGA4 transcript was non-specifically knocked down by the scrambled control (Fig. 3). Then we introduced another chemical modification, an ‘inverted dT’ (Fig. 1B) at the 3′ end of RNV143, RNV183 and RNV184, the DNAzymes with high activities, and the new generation DNAzymes were named RNV143A, RNV183A and RNV184A respectively. RNV143A, RNV183A and RNV184A slightly improved the activities of DNAzymes (89%, 76% and 92% respectively; Fig. 3).

We also investigated the potential use of locked nucleic acid (LNA) nucleotides in DNAzymes. Two LNA nucleotides were incorporated to both arms of RNV183 at positions 2, 5 and 31, 35. However, RNV183 with 4 LNA modifications was not effective (did not cleave ITGA4) when tested in cells (data not shown). We believe that this may be due to the formation of secondary structures caused by LNAs within the arms of the DNAzymes that could potentially affect the catalytic motif (sequence of the LNA modified RNV183 and the mfold22 predicted structures are shown in Supplementary Material, Figure S1). To limit this secondary structure formation, we truncated the LNA modified RNV183 by four nucleotides from the 5′ end to generate RNVLNA-3 (Fig. 3) with one LNA nucleotide on the truncated arm and two LNA nucleotides on the other non-truncated arm. This truncation is predicted to limit the secondary structure formation, and promote its ability to bind to the ITGA4 mRNA. Transfection with RNVLNA-3 showed 58% knockdown of ITGA4 transcript indicating that the truncation helped to improve the activity, although the efficacy of ITGA4 knockdown was not efficient (Fig. 3).

In vitro cleavage of ITGA4 RNA template

To further verify the catalytic activity of DNAzyme towards the target region of ITGA4 transcript, we performed the cleavage efficacy in vitro using a synthetic fluorescein dye (FAM)-labelled RNA target composed of exon 9 region of the ITGA4 transcript. The experiments were performed by incubating DNAzymes with FAM-labelled RNA template in the presence of divalent metal ions and the products were separated and analysed on polyacrylamide gels. Briefly, 1.76 µM DNAzymes were incubated with 1.76 µM FAM-conjugated ITGA4 RNA in the presence of Mg2+ divalent cations for 30 min, 60 min and 120 min at 37 °C. The reactions were stopped by adding 10 µL of formamide solution. The products were then separated on a 15% denaturing polyacrylamide gel and visualised using Fusion FX Vilber Lourmat imager. The cleaved products of the 34mer full length FAM-conjugated RNA was expected to be 18 nucleotides. A scrambled (SCR) sequence and RNV143 mutants with different mutations within the catalytic region of RNV143 were used as negative controls in parallel and an untreated (UT) sample with no DNAzyme was also included.

Although variable efficiencies were observed for these DNAzymes in fibroblasts, RNV143, RNV182, RNV183 and RNV184 showed similar cleavage efficiency in vitro (around 0.7%/min) (Fig. 4). In general, the in vitro cleavage rates of the modified DNAzymes were slower than that of their parent oligonucleotides. Notably, RNV143PS showed very low cleavage efficiency with small percentage of cleaved FAM-conjugated RNA appearing after 120 minutes of incubation. Similar results were observed for RNV143-Mut3 while the other mutant DNAzymes and the SCR sequence showed no cleavage (Fig. 4).

Figure 4
figure 4

In vitro cleavage of the FAM-conjugated ITGA4 RNA template composed of exon 9 region (34 nucleotides) by RNV143 and its derivatives. FL RNA, full length; FAM-conjugated RNA; cleaved RNA; the cleaved FAM-conjugated ITGA4 RNA (18 nucleotides long). The FAM- conjugated template RNA is a small region of the ITGA4 transcript complementary to the hybridisation arms of the DNAzymes of interest. The gel images were cropped for better overview. The original images are shown in Figure S3 (Supplementary Information). The table shows the cleavage rate in %/min which was calculated as described in Materials and Methods section.

Nuclease stability analysis of DNAzymes

High nuclease stability is paramount towards the clinical development of oligonucleotides. Towards this goal, we tested the stability of DNAzymes RNV143, RNV183, RNV184, RNVLNA-3, RNV143A, RNV183A, and RNV184A using snake venom phosphodiesterase, a harsh enzyme with very high 3′ → 5′ exonuclease activity. DNAzyme candidates were incubated with the enzyme at 37 °C and samples were collected at different time points (0, 30, 60 and 120 minutes) followed by the products analysis on 15% denaturing polyacrylamide gels. As expected the stability was increased by increasing the arm lengths of the DNAzymes and RNV184 (36 nt long) was found to be the most stable compared to RNV183 and RNV143 (Fig. 5). RNVLNA-3 with LNA modifications (known for high nuclease stability23, 24) was more stable than RNV143, RNV183 and RNV184. A weak product band was visible even after 60 minutes of incubation. Remarkably, the DNAzymes with inverted dT nucleotide at 3′-end (RNV143A, RNV183A and RNV184A) showed highest stability with no significant degradation even after 1 hour incubation with phosphodiesterase (Fig. 5).

Figure 5
figure 5

Phosphodiesterase degradation analysis of DNAzymes that showed high efficacy in the cleavage of ITGA4 RNA in vitro and knockdown of ITGA4 RNA in fibroblasts. The gel images were cropped for better overview. The original images are shown in Figure S4 (Supplementary Information).

Discussion

We have successfully identified a DNAzyme that cleaves the ITGA4 transcript both in vitro and in human primary fibroblasts by screening different DNAzyme constructs with 10–23 catalytic motif and 8–17 catalytic motif targeting different sites of ITGA4 mRNA. The DNAzyme was not only capable of downregulating the ITGA4 transcript in vitro and in human primary fibroblasts but also showed high resistance to exonuclease degradation. Our study thus provides a novel approach for downregulating ITGA4 transcript that may have therapeutic potential towards the treatment of MS where ITGA4 is a validated target for tackling inflammation.

Cleavage by first generation DNAzymes with either 10–23 or 8–17 catalytic motif targeting five different cleavage sites of the ITGA4 transcript showed variable cleavage efficiencies (Fig. 2B). The best cleavage efficiency was achieved with the 10–23 catalytic motif DNAzymes designed to cleave a site located in exon 9 of the ITGA4 transcript. The variable target-cleaving efficiencies observed for different first generation DNAzymes targeting different regions of the ITGA4 transcript could be due to the structure variations that might affect the accessibility of target sequences. This is consistent with previous observations by Vester et al.17, 21, 25. The cleavage efficiency of DNAzyme has been proposed to be dependent on the structural complexity of the RNA that is targeted17, 26. In a comparison between different substrate structures, Vester et al., targeted three different cleavage sites of either a short (17 nucleotides) unstructured RNAs; or longer (58 nucleotides) RNAs with stable secondary structures; or longer (2904 nucleotides) RNAs with both stable secondary and tertiary structures17, 26. The results indicated that only one cleavage site out of three could be efficiently cleaved by the DNAzymes and the cleavage of the short unstructured RNAs were more efficient than the longer structured RNA17, 26. This implies that the accessibility of the purine-pyrimidine sites differs in different regions of the ITGA4 (1032 bp long) transcript due to the formation of different secondary and tertiary structures in the transcript inside the cells, leading to differences in the ability of DNAzymes to cleave them.

The optimal arm length may vary for different DNAzymes and there is no evidence on whether the arms should be asymmetrical or symmetrical for optimal catalytic activity. In addition, the GC content may also have an effect on the catalytic efficiency16, 18, 21, 27, but how it is affected is unclear16, 18, 19. In parallel, increasing the DNAzyme binding arm length would increase DNAzyme- target affinity as it enhances the heteroduplex stability28, but it could also result in slower product release that would inhibit or decrease the rate of multiple turnovers. Therefore, longer binding arms may not always produce higher catalytic efficiency14, 29. Using the best candidate RNV143 from the first screen, we further tested the impact of DNAzyme arm lengths aiming for increased efficiency. However, the catalytic efficiency was decreased in most DNAzymes with longer arms. We speculate that increasing the arm length of the DNAzyme RNV143 could increase the binding affinity of DNAzymes to the target RNA but result in slower product release and turnover26. For DNAzymes to have therapeutic potential, it is desirable to have high turnover.

Although we have identified a DNAzyme with high cleavage efficiency, one of the disadvantages of unmodified DNAzymes, similar to antisense oligonucleotides, is their vulnerability to nucleases in vivo and therefore, nuclease resistance is a critical characteristic of their physical property30. The suitable solution to increase nuclease resistance is to introduce chemical modifications30. Several modifications have been successfully introduced into the oligonucleotides including sugar modifications such as LNA21, 22, and inverted thymidine and backbone modification such as PS30. In line with this, we modified several of our efficient DNAzyme candidates, RNV143 and its two derivatives RNV183 and RNV184 with PS, LNA and inverted-dT. When modified with PS modification (RNV143PS), RNV143 resulted in decreased cleavage efficiency both in vitro (Fig. 4) and in human fibroblasts (Fig. 3). PS modification typically enhances the stability of the oligonucleotide against nucleases, however, they compromise the affinity to their target in some cases, which could result in decreased cleavage efficiency30. Similar results were also observed in another study that further support our observation that PS modification may not be ideal for developing efficient DNAzymes19. Although truncation and incorporation of LNA to the DNAzymes increased resistance to nuclease (Fig. 5), the activity was decreased (Fig. 3). The reduction in the activity may be due to a combination of reduced size and slower DNAzyme dissociation from the mRNA target based on the high affinity of LNA nucleotides19. Among all modifications tested, incorporation of inverted dT (RNV143A, RNV183A and RNV184A) was found to be the best chemistry in this case, since it not only conferred nuclease resistance (Fig. 5) but also achieved high activity (89%, 76% and 92% respectively) (Fig. 3). The result is also consistent with a previous study performed by Schubert et al.19. Additionally, we have also performed a human serum degradation experiment to observe the stability of the DNAzymes in human serum (Figure S4 in Supplementary Material). RNV143, RNV182, RNV183 and RNV184 showed similar stability (degradation observed after 2 hours incubation) in human serum and as expected their modified counterparts RNV143A, RNV183A and RNV184A showed better stability (~26–50% DNAzymes remained after 6 h incubation). Interestingly, RNVLNA-3 conferred the best stability in human serum, however as discussed above, its activity in cells was decreased (Fig. 3).

We observed a discrepancy between the ITGA4 knock down observed in fibroblasts and the in vitro cleavage for the same DNAzymes. Although variable efficiencies are observed for second generation DNAzymes in human primary fibroblasts (Fig. 3), the in vitro data does not reflect this (Fig. 4). It is expected that cell-free conditions are incomparable to the crowded cell-culture environment and the mRNA folding and accessibility of the template may significantly influence the success of experiments within the cells. It is also expected that the ITGA4 RNA expressed in fibroblasts (1032 base pairs long) is much longer and can adopt complex secondary and tertiary structures while the synthetic short single stranded RNA (34 nucleotides long) used for the in vitro cleavage assay may not form any secondary or tertiary structures and therefore it is much easier for the DNAzyme to access and cleave. However, the DNAzymes that knocked down ITGA4 transcript in fibroblasts also showed the ability to cleave the synthetic ITGA4 transcript template in vitro and from this we may suggest that the ITGA4 knock down observed in the fibroblast could be due to the DNAzymes-mediated cleavage of ITGA4 transcript. Furthermore, we designed three RNV 143 mutants RNV143-Mut1, RNV143-Mut2 and RNV143-Mut3 to investigate the possibility of antisense effect rather than DNAzyme cleavage. RNV143-Mut1 and RNV 143-Mut2 are double mutants designed based on the paper by Wang et al. that suggested that these double mutants were critical for activity in the hammerhead and the stem loop respectively31. Both double mutants may be important for catalytic activity as they abolished the in vitro cleavage activity (Fig. 4). However, RNV143-Mut3 showed very small cleavage activity indicating that the nucleotide mutated may not be crucial for catalytic activity, supporting the previous study by Wang et al.31. These controls also suggest that the gene silencing effects seen in cells by RNV143 may be due to DNAzyme cleavage rather than the antisense effect. The cleavage rates of the DNAzymes observed here is about half of that reported by Schubert et al.19. However, we performed the in vitro cleavage reactions with equal molar ratio of the DNAzyme to substrate in the presence of 0.5 mM MgCl2 while Schubert et al., performed the reactions with 10-fold excess of DNAzyme to substrate in 10 mM MgCl2 19.

In conclusion, we identified DNAzymes that are capable of cleaving the ITGA4 transcript in human primary fibroblasts. The DNAzyme candidate RNV143 targeting exon 9 of the ITGA4 transcript showed 92% knock down of the ITGA4 transcript and the catalytic ability of the DNAzyme was verified by in vitro cleavage assay. Furthermore, introducing a chemical modification such as an inverted dT at the 3′ end (RNV143A) significantly improved the stability while maintaining efficient catalytic activity. Although RNV143A needs further validations, based our current results, we firmly believe that the candidate could provide therapeutic benefits.

Methods

DNAzyme design and synthesis

DNAzymes with either stem loop or hammer head conformation were designed for the selected exons (Fig. 2B) and the oligonucleotides were ordered from IDT. The LNA modified DNAzyme was made in-house by ABI Expedite 8909 nucleic acid synthesis system in 1 µM scale, deprotected by NH4OH at 55 °C overnight and purified by NAP column (GE Health care).

Cell propagation and transfection

Cell cultures media and supplements were purchased from (Life technologies, Australia) unless specified. Normal human fibroblasts were propagated in Dulbecco’s modified Eagle’s medium supplemented with GlutaMAX™ and 10% fetal bovine serum. Transfections were performed in 24 well-plate format with approximately 15,000 cells/well. The cells were seeded one day before transfecting with the DNAzymes complexed with Lipofectamine 3000® transfection reagent (Life Technologies, Australia) per the manufacturer’s protocol. Transfection was carried out for 24 hours before harvesting RNA for transcript analysis. RNA was extracted using Direct-zol RNA MiniPrep Kit (Zymo Research, USA) following manufacturer’s protocol.

RT-PCR assays

50 ng of total RNA was analysed using a Superscript III One-Step RT-PCR System (Life technologies, Australia) and reaction conditions are as follows: 55 °C for 30 min, 94 °C for 2 min, 28 rounds of 94 °C for 30 sec, 55 °C for 30 sec and 68 °C for 1 min 30 sec. Exon 1–10 was amplified using primer pair 1F (5′-gagagcgcgctgctttaccagg-3′) and 10R (5′-gccatcattgtcaatgtcgcca-3′); exon 9–20 using primer pair 9F (5′-ggatcgtactttggagcttctg-3′) and 20R (5′-gcatgcactgtgatactgaggt-3′). The products were analysed on 2% agarose gels.

Image analysis of the gel from gel electrophoresis

Densitometry (measuring the band intensity) of the bands was performed using Image J Software32. The band intensity of the ITGA4 bands in different DNAzymes treated samples were measured and normalised to the band intensity of the corresponding CYCD bands before comparing to the band intensity of the untreated samples. The percentage of ITGA4 transcript knockdown by DNAzymes in fibroblasts was expressed as activity of DNAzyme.

In vitro cleavage assay

4.4 µL of 20 µM DNAzyme was incubated with equal molar concentration of FAM-conjugated ITGA4 RNA (5′-FAM-CUGUGCUGUGGACCUCAAUGCAGAUGGCUUCUCA-3′) in 5 µL of buffer containing Mg2+ divalent cations (10 mM MgCl2) at 37 °C. The reaction was stopped by adding 10 µL of formamide to 10 µL of the reaction mixture at 0, 30 mins, 60 mins and 2 hours. Scrambled DNAzyme RNV174, RNV143-Mut1 (5′-CATCTGCAGGCTAAATACAACGATGAG-3′), RNV143-Mut2 (5′-CATCTGCAAACTAGCTACAACGATGAG-3′) and RNV143-Mut3 (5′-CATCTGCAGGCTAGCAACAACGATGAG-3′) were used as negative controls and the untreated samples did not have any DNAzyme. The mutated bases are in bold and the two double mutants RNV143-Mut1 and RNV 143-Mut2 were designed based on a previous paper31 The reaction mixtures were separated on a 15% polyacrylamide gel/7 M urea for 50 mins at 13 W. The gel was visualised using the Fusion FX Vilber Lourmat Imager (Fisher Biotech).

Image Analysis of the gel from in vitro cleavage assay

Densitometry (measuring the band intensity) of the bands was performed using Image J Software32. The band intensity of the full length RNA bands for different time points were measured and normalised to the combined band intensity of both cleaved and full length RNA bands for different time points and plotted on excel as the % of uncleaved RNA. The same analysis was repeated to calculate % of cleaved RNA. The slope of the curve was used to calculate the % cleaved per minute.

Phosphodiesterase assay

5 µM DNAzyme was incubated with 0.00001 U phosphodiesterase from Crotalus adamanteurs venom (Sigma Aldrich) at 37 °C. At different time points 0, 2 mins, 5 mins, 10 mins, 30 mins and 1 hour, 10 µL of formamide was added to equal volume of the reaction mixture to stop the reaction. The reaction mixture was separated on a 20% polyacrylamide/7 M urea gel. The gel was stained with ethidium bromide for 10 minutes and destained in water for 10 minutes before visualizing under UV light using Bio-Rad Molecular Imager ChemiDoc XRS Imaging System.

Human serum degradation assay

5 µM DNAzyme was incubated in human serum at 37 °C. At different time points 0, 30 mins, 60 mins, 2 hours, 4 hours and 6 hours, 10 µL of formamide was added to equal volume of the reaction mixture to stop the reaction. The reaction mixture was separated on a 15% polyacrylamide/7 M urea gel. The gel was stained with ethidium bromide for 10 minutes and destained in water for 10 minutes before visualizing under UV light using Bio-Rad Molecular Imager ChemiDoc XRS Imaging System. The images are shown in Figure S4 (Supplementary Information).