Willett and Jain reply:

The objective of our study was to examine the biological and clinical effects on rectal cancer of an initial bevacizumab infusion, before the initiation of radiation therapy and 5-fluorouracil. Six patients with clinical stage T3 or T4 rectal cancer completed the neoadjuvant therapy consisting of the first bevacizumab infusion followed by three 2-week cycles of bevacizumab administered concurrently with external beam radiation therapy (50.4 Gy in 28 1.8-Gy fractions over 5.5 weeks) and 5-fluorouracil (225 mg/m2/24 h by continuous peripheral venous infusion). Effects of the combined treatment on tumors were evaluated before surgery endoscopically and by PET scan and perfusion CT scan. Details of the protocol may be found in a corrigendum to our article, printed in this issue1. The 18-fluorodeoxyglucose uptake in the neck seen on one representative sagittal image of the presurgery PET scan (patient 1 in the original figure) was, in fact, seen on all three PET scans (pretreatment, day 12 and presurgery) and was interpreted as upper-limit normal activity in the thyroid gland. This PET finding was not judged to represent a metastasis, and similarly, PET findings showed no detectable evidence of metastasis in any of the other five patients (see Fig. 1 below). Although the goal of this study was to examine the biological and clinical response to a single dose of bevacizumab, the longer-term results of combined therapy in six consecutive patients have been promising.

Figure 1: Effect of treatment on tumors in patients who completed the entire combined treatment regimen.
figure 1

Tumor FDG uptake before treatment (pre-Tx), 12 d after BV treatment and 6–7 weeks after completion of all neoadjuvant therapy (presurgery). Sagittal projections of FDG-PET scans for patient 2–5 are shown. Tumor is outlined in box, posterior to bladder. On day 12 after BV infusion, the follow-up PET scans showed no change in tumor FDG uptake in five patients and a 40% decrease in patient 3. Six weeks after completion of the BV, radiation therapy and chemotherapy regimen (presurgery), follow-up PET scans showed decreased tumor FDG uptake as compared with pretreatment values in patients 1, 2, 3, 4 and 6. Tumor FDG uptake in patient 5 was low, and was similar before and at the end of therapy.

See “PET concerns in bevacizumab treatment” by Goessl and Grozdanovic.