Heterostructured material systems devoid of ferroic components are presumed not to display ordering associated with ferroelectricity. In heterostructures composed of transition metal oxides, however, the disruption introduced by an interface can affect the balance of the competing interactions among electronic spins, charges and orbitals. This has led to the emergence of properties absent in the original building blocks of a heterostructure, including metallicity, magnetism and superconductivity. Here we report the discovery of ferroelectricity in artificial tri-layer superlattices consisting solely of non-ferroelectric NdMnO3/SrMnO3/LaMnO3 layers. Ferroelectricity was observed below 40 K exhibiting strong tunability by superlattice periodicity. Furthermore, magnetoelectric coupling resulted in 150% magnetic modulation of the polarization. Density functional calculations indicate that broken space inversion symmetry and mixed valency, because of cationic asymmetry and interfacial polar discontinuity, respectively, give rise to the observed behaviour. Our results demonstrate the engineering of asymmetric layered structures with emergent ferroelectric and magnetic field tunable functions distinct from that of normal devices, for which the components are typically ferroelectrics.
The shortage of naturally occurring materials possessing both ferroelectricity1,2 and magnetoelectric (ME) coupling3,4,5 has propelled the search for artificial structures where individual ferroelectric (FE) and magnetic layers cause indirect enhancement of ME coupling based on interfacial exchange interactions6,7. Such structures may include superlattices (SLs) of FE oxide components, which have been found to possess improved physical properties over homogeneous thin films8,9, for example, the shift of the FE transition temperature (Tc) to higher values compared with the corresponding Tc for bulk materials10,11. It has also been proposed that the broken space inversion symmetry at a macroscopic scale in asymmetric SLs of tri-layers in an A-B-C-A-B-C arrangement12 could result in a permanent built-in electric field13,14, enhanced polarization15 and dielectric constant14, and large nonlinear optical responses16. Furthermore, epitaxial strain is another useful parameter that could enhance FE properties in thin films8,17, but may also lead to an increased polarization in tri-layer structures comprised of FE materials15. Most notable in the search for new materials with strong field dependence of ferroelectricity, however, is the possibility for the combination of asymmetric SL layering with epitaxial strain to encourage the formation of electrically and magnetically controllable polarization, even in the absence of FE components18. This strategy is of particular importance considering the lack of bulk materials comprising FE properties tunable by magnetic field3,4,5.
Here we report on high-quality artificial SLs with asymmetric structure composed of neither ferromagnetic nor FE perovskite manganites, yet showing distinct FE behaviour tunable by an applied magnetic field. Density functional theory (DFT) calculations indicate that the broken space inversion symmetry, because of cationic asymmetry and the presence of Mn3+/Mn4+ mixed valency originating in the interfacial polar discontinuity, give rise to the observed behaviour. This discovery allows for a wide range of new FE and ME materials and paves a long sought new path in the engineering19 of low-dimensional FE devices based on manganite antiferromagnets.
Materials growth and characterization
We used laser molecular-beam epitaxy to grow asymmetric tri-layer SLs composed of antiferromagnetic and non-FE manganite insulators [(NdMnO3)n/(SrMnO3)n/(LaMnO3)n]m on single-crystalline SrTiO3 (ref. 20). Parent compounds LaMnO3 and NdMnO3 have Mn3+ ions and are A-type antiferromagnets, whereas SrMnO3 is a G-type antiferromagnet with Mn4+. Structural and topographic characterizations confirmed the presence of sharp interfaces with roughness less than one unit cell and a surface roughness of ~2 Å (ref. 21). The high quality of the samples was clarified further using detailed bulk magnetization and neutron reflectometry studies21. SL capacitors were prepared with fixed total thickness of 50 nm and varying (n, m)=(22, 2), (5, 8) and (2, 21); this was done in order to investigate the effect of periodicity on the polarization and the ME coupling. A schematic view of a typical capacitor fabricated for our study is shown in Fig. 1a. Bare SrTiO3 capacitors were treated under conditions identical to the SrTiO3 substrates on which the SLs were grown and were used to check for possible contributions of the substrate to the measured emergent properties.
Magnetically controlled electrical polarization
Figure 1b depicts dc polarization measurements for a SL sample with a layer period (22, 2), indicating the onset of ferroelectricity below ~40 K and a temperature dependence characteristic of relaxors22. The polarization can be reversed by alternating the polarity of the applied electric field. The polarization versus electric field (P-Ea) hysteresis loop measured at a temperature T=5 K (Fig. 1c) indicates a remnant ac polarization Pr~0.7 μC cm−2 following the application of 2 kV cm−1. The butterfly loops15 in the capacitance–voltage (C-V) characteristics (Fig. 1d) measured at 5 K add credence to the FE switching in the SLs. Above Tc, both the C-V shift and the P-Ea hysteresis loop are suppressed, indicating the intrinsic nature of the observed hysteresis (Supplementary Fig. S1). Moreover, the weak frequency dependence of the P-Ea hysteresis (Fig. 1c) excludes contribution from extrinsic effects such as space charges, interface traps or charge leakage. Cooling the sample from room temperature and in the presence of an applied magnetic field of 6 T, hereby described as 'magnetic field cooling' (MFC), shifts the polarization plateau to lower temperatures (Fig. 1b). Concurrently, the absolute value of the measured polarization (more precisely at T=5 K) is enhanced by ~100%.
Notably, for the SLs studied here, we have recently demonstrated that the interfaces show magnetic relaxor and spin glass-like properties21. A modulated magnetization of antiferromagnetic and ferromagnetic layers as a function of depth was also demonstrated using polarized neutron reflectivity21. Combined with measurements of bulk magnetization, it was shown that the relaxor characteristics are due to the competitive interaction between ferromagnetism present mainly at the interfaces and antiferromagnetic regions in a magnetically modulated system. Therefore, further insight to the nature of the ferroelectricity and ME coupling may be obtained from measurements of polarization (Supplementary Fig. S2) and magnetization21 in zero field cooling conditions. The slim loop-like P-Ea hysteresis22, the extended tail of the polarization above Tc (ref. 22) and the thermal hysteresis between zero-field-cooled and field-cooled measurements of the polarization, and magnetization21 are indicative of a ME relaxor21,22,23,24,25.
Tunability by SL periodicity
To investigate the effect of periodicity, we performed measurements on a sample with a layer period (5, 8) in a manner similar to the measurements made on sample (22, 2). We find the magnitude of the polarization increases compared with the (22, 2)-SL while Tc shifts to lower temperatures, namely around 15 K (Fig. 2a). The ME effect is, however, weaker compared with SLs with a layer period (22, 2), resulting to a <20% increase in the measured polarization at 5 K during MFC at 6 T (Fig. 2b). Corresponding P-Ea hysteresis loops measured at 5 K (Supplementary Fig. S3) resulted in Pr~2.7 μC cm−2, following the application of 2 kV cm−1. The larger polarization compared with the (22, 2)-SLs is also apparent from the enhanced shift in the corresponding C-V characteristics (Supplementary Fig. S3).
Further reduction in periodicity, namely, SLs with (2, 21) shifts Tc to 25 K (Fig. 2a). Applying 6 T during MFC yields almost a 150% increase in the absolute value of the polarization (Fig. 2b). Corresponding P-Ea hysteresis loops for different frequencies are also depicted in Supplementary Fig. S1 (see Supplementary Methods for a discussion). Although the (2, 21)-SLs exhibit a lower polarization compared with the (5, 8)-SLs, the ME coupling is significantly enhanced, exceeding that of the (22, 2)-SLs. Figure 2a depicts a comparison between the temperature dependence of the polarization for the three sets of SLs studied here, as well as for the bare treated SrTiO3 substrates. Compared with the SLs, the polarization of the substrate is considerably lower, indicating the ferroelectricity and ME coupling studied here arise mostly from the SL structure grown on the SrTiO3 substrate.
An overall comparison of the samples depicted in Fig. 2 reveals a strong dependence23,26 of the electric and magnetic properties of the SLs on layer thickness and/or on the total number of tri-layers integrated within the capacitor dielectric stack. It is therefore, apparent that the interfaces have a central role in the emergent FE properties. In particular, the periodicity of the SL affects both the magnitude of the polarization and Tc, as well as the strength of the ME coupling—as depicted by the effect of the magnetic field on the measured polarization (Fig. 2a,b). Notably, an enhanced polarization and weaker magnetic field dependence are observed with decreasing the thickness of the layers comprising a SL, for as long as the layer thickness is kept greater or equal to five unit cells. Bulk magnetization measurements revealed a similar thickness dependence21, with the (5, 8)-SLs exhibiting concurrently the highest magnetization (Fig. 2c). The abovementioned monotonic thickness dependence is reversed for both the polarization and the magnetization when the thickness of the layers is lower than five. An anti-correlation23 between the thickness dependence of the ME coupling and the magnetization (and polarization) is depicted in Fig. 2b,c.
To explore the microscopic mechanism of the reported tunable ferroelectricity, ab-initio DFT calculations were performed for a periodic [(LaMnO3)2/(SrMnO3)2/(NdMnO3)2] SL, as represented in Fig. 3a, with in-plane strain appropriate for epitaxial growth on an SrTiO3 (001) substrate (see Methods for details). Because of computational constraints, we restricted our study only to short period n=2 SLs. The formal charge layering of the LaMnO3 and NdMnO3 components gives rise to a polar discontinuity at the interface of these with SrMnO3, leading to charge transfer and off-centering of both the Mn and the A-site cations with respect to the interconnected lattice of O octahedral in response to macroscopic internal electric fields. This off-centering is characterized by the average out-of-plane component of the displacement between metal cations and oxygen anions in each atomic layer, as plotted in Fig. 3b (left axis). The inherent A-site cationic asymmetry of this tri-layer SL leads to a pattern of such displacements that does not possess space inversion symmetry, and therefore to a macroscopic polarization as can be clearly seen in the red points in Fig. 3b, which we refer to as the +P state. For such a structure to be considered as FE, however, there must be a complementary state with opposite polarization orientation. Such a state can be constructed by inverting the pattern of atomic displacements, but keeping the chemical identity of each site the same as in the +P state. After relaxation, we find a pattern of metal–oxygen displacements approximately inverted with respect to the +P state. We label this inverted state as −P and plot the displacements in blue in Fig. 3b. Given these two stable polarization states with opposite orientation, we can estimate the energy profile associated with polarization reversal by linearly scaling the atomic structure between the two stable minima, keeping track of the total energy of each tested structure. This scaling is parameterized by the dimensionless parameter λ, where λ=±1 corresponds to the ±P state. The −P state has energy 50 meV per cell above the +P state. The resulting double-well energy profile, plotted in Fig. 3c, is entirely consistent with what is expected for ferroelectricity in compositionally ordered structures with broken inversion symmetry13.
The bi-stability of the structure is intimately coupled to the charge transferred in response to the interfacial polar discontinuity. Figure 3d shows the Mn-3d projected local density of states (LDOS) near the Fermi level (EF) on each of the MnO2 atomic layers in the +P state (corresponding plots for the −P state are shown in Fig. 3e). Although all three components of the SL are insulating in the bulk (see the filled plots in the background of the second, fourth and sixth panels), there is non-zero LDOS at EF for the 'up'-spin electrons on the MnO2 layers above and below the central G-type ordered layer. All other MnO2 layers are essentially gapped, except the layer sandwiched on both sides by LaO layers, where there is non-zero LDOS at EF for the 'down'-spin states. The reverse polarization state (Fig. 3e), −P, exhibits similar charge transfer profile, except in this case the 'down'-spin charge is trapped in the NdMnO3 layer (compare bottom layers in Fig. 3d,e), whereas the LaMnO3 layer, which held the down-spin charge in the +P state, is now essentially bulk-like (compare the second layer from the top in Fig. 3d,e). The difference in the 'down'-spin charged states at the LaMnO3 and NdMnO3 layers between +P and −P states, respectively, is essential to produce the polarization bi-stability. This bi-stability in the position of the interface charge clearly gives rise to the switchable behaviour of the structure similar to that known for FE thin films sandwiched between two metal electrodes, and the interface charge may be interpreted as the 'screening' charge for polar displacements in the heterostructure27.
Furthermore, there is a strong coupling between structural, electronic and magnetic degrees of freedom in the heterostructure. This can be seen in Fig. 3b (right axis), which shows the difference in the layer-by-layer total magnetic moment (per Mn atom) between the +P and −P states, ΔM. The change in the magnetic moment is entirely consistent with the hopping of 'down'-spin electrons from the LaMnO3 layer to the NdMnO3 layer. The ME origin of the switchable polarization in the SLs suggests that changing magnetic moment alignment, for example, by applying an external magnetic field will strongly influence the charge transfer and thus leads to the magnetic modulation of the polarization as it is observed experimentally. In particular, the application of a magnetic field will break the inversion symmetry of the magnetic ordering and will therefore favour further charge transfer to one layer over the other, and therefore lead to a larger polarization.
Our calculations suggest that the ferromagnetism originates from the interfaces, consistent with ref. 21. On the other hand, the relaxor behaviour21 could not be seen from the theoretical results, which describe a static and zero-temperature behaviour revealing thus only the ground state of the system. Nevertheless, our DFT results indicate that the magnetic order and the origin of ferroelectricity are coupled (through the 'trapping' and 'hopping' of 'down'-spin charge), therefore, ferroelectricity should have relaxor character too (as depicted in Fig. 1). Finally, we note that as the polar displacements and the largest changes in the magnetization profile are localized at the interfaces (Fig. 3b), the net polarization and magnetization should scale with the density of interfaces, that is, a 1/n dependence on the lattice periodicity, n, which is consistent with the experimental thickness dependence depicted in Fig. 2c for n≥5.
The SLs studied here are comprised of three manganite perovskites each having a different A-site ion size thus introducing modulated strain and effective chemical doping19,26. Reciprocal mapping using synchrotron X-ray diffraction showed that although the in-plane lattice constants of all films match the lattice constant of the substrate, our SLs exhibit a tetragonal lattice distortion. Even though our experiments do not allow an estimate of atomic displacement, structural distortions and chemical engineering including Mn off-centering have been suggested to encourage FE instabilities in various perovskite systems28,29. Besides, electronic reconstruction arising from the interfacial Mn3+/Mn4+ mixed valency30,31,32 would favour the formation of local electric dipolar moments accommodated with a magnetic degree of freedom. Remarkably, our ab-initio calculations revealed that a synergy between asymmetric lattice distortion and atomic displacement, mixed valency and tunability of charge itinerancy by an applied magnetic field finally leads to a magnetically controlled FE polarization. Our discovery is a long sought19 demonstration for emergent ferroelectricity and magnetoelectricity in an artificial system originating purely in the broken space inversion symmetry as well as in the strong carriers' complexity and correlations at the nanoscale. A plethora of artificial FE and ME low-dimensional devices may now be designed and fabricated following the recipe for a tri-layer SL comprised of transition metal oxides incorporating mixed valency, compatible magnetic ordering and asymmetric cation displacement.
In conclusion, we demonstrated the emergence of ferroelectricity in artificial SLs composed of materials that are non-FE in their bulk form. We also observed up to 150% increase in the measured P by the application of a magnetic field. Engineering systems with tunable ferroelectricity and ME coupling in asymmetrically layered devices comprised of materials abundant in synthetic chemistry such as those used in the present study would widen the versatility of electric polarization functionality.
Capacitor fabrication and general measurement details
Circular metallic (Pt/Au) pads of various diameters (100–300 μm) were patterned on the SLs using electron-beam evaporation. The thickness of the SrTiO3 substrate was ∼500 μm. A metallic layer was deposited on the underside of the substrate using the same evaporation technique as for the top electrodes and served as a common bottom capacitor plate. Silver paint contacts were placed on the top and bottom metallic pads of the samples for both polarization and capacitance measurements. A systematic error of <5% was obtained when repeating measurements several times under identical experimental conditions. The results were accurately reproducible using many different capacitors of the same sample type. No aging effect was observed.
The capacitance–voltage (C-V) measurements were performed at various temperatures using an LCR metre with an AC signal frequency and magnitude of 20 kHz and 200 mV, respectively. Measurements using different voltage scanning directions (defined by arrows in the corresponding plots) revealed the FE switching of the SLs. The virgin curves of voltage scanning from 0 V to maximum value are not shown.
DC polarization data processing
Polarization (P) was measured using a pyroelectric current technique with a bias electric field (Ea) applied perpendicular to the plane of the SL (using a Keithley electrometer 6517B). During an electric field cooling process, the samples were first polarized by applying the desired Ea at high temperature and then cooled to 5 K while Ea was maintained at the same bias. During the zero electric field cooling process, the samples were cooled to 5 K in zero Ea. The pyroelectric current and the sample temperature were then recorded as a function of time, while the sample was warmed at a constant Ea and a heating rate of 5 K min−1. A typical value of Ea=+100 V cm−1 was used (All measurements of P were performed during an electric field heating process, unless otherwise stated.). For the zero magnetic field cooling (ZMFC) process, the sample was cooled to base temperature in the absence of an applied magnetic field, whereas in the case of MFC a constant magnetic field was applied during cooling. In both cases, the heating cycle was performed in the presence of a magnetic field—applied parallel to the plane of the film, unless otherwise stated. Similar tests have been reported for the magnetization of our SLs21.
AC polarization measurements
Polarization versus electric field (P-Ea) hysteresis loops were measured at various temperatures using a TF 2000 analyser with Ea ranging from −2 to 2 kV cm−1 (the thickness of the SrTiO3 substrate limited the maximum applied electric field). The AC signal frequency ranged from 10 Hz to 1 kHz. An initial triangular excitation pulse was applied to establish a polarization state. Three consecutive excitation pulses followed, separated by a relaxation time of 1 s. During each pulse, the current was measured and the polarization extracted by integrating the current with respect to time.
Electronic and atomic structure calculations were performed within DFT applied to (LaMnO3)2/(SrMnO3)2/(NdMnO3)2 SLs. The calculations used the projector augmented wave method as implemented in the Vienna Ab Initio Simulation Package code33. The exchange–correlation effects were treated within generalized gradient approximation (GGA). The calculations were carried out using a plane-wave basis set with a cutoff energy of 520 eV and an 8×8×4 mesh of k points in the irreducible Brillouin zone with energy converged to 0.01 meV per cell. Atomic relaxations were performed until the Hellmann–Feynman forces on atoms have become <30 meV Å−1. The in-plane lattice constant is constrained to the experimental bulk lattice constant of SrTiO3, a=3.905 Å. On-site electron-electron Coulomb interactions of the Mn-3d states were treated within the GGA+U approach34. We impose U=8.0 and J=1 eV on Mn-3d states35,36 giving reasonable band gaps for all three components: Eg=0.99, 1.2 and 0.23 eV for LaMnO3, NdMnO3 and SrMnO3, respectively, which are consistent with experimental values 1.0 eV (ref. 37), 1.7 eV (ref. 38) and 0.3 eV (ref. 39). As the La-4f bands lie at higher energy than that predicted by GGA, the value of U for the La-4f states was taken to be 11.0 eV to avoid spurious mixing with the conduction bands. The structural model was initially constructed from the bulk structures of each manganite component, all of which are found to have the tilts and rotations of oxygen octahedrons consistent with the Pnma space group. The Mn magnetic moments are arranged in a collinear manner, according to the known antiferromagnetic ordering in the bulk compounds: G-type in SrMnO3 and A-type in both LaMnO3 and NdMnO3, as indicated in Fig. 3a. Those MnO2 layers sandwiched between SrO and LaO or NdO layers continue the neighbouring A-type order, whereas the MnO2 layer sandwiched between two SrO takes on a G-type checkerboard pattern. Several other collinear magnetic order configurations were tested and were found to have higher energy.
How to cite this article: Rogdakis, K. et al. Tunable ferroelectricity in artificial tri-layer superlattices comprised of non-ferroic components. Nat. Commun. 3:1064 doi: 10.1038/ncomms2061 (2012).
We thank C. Batista and I. Martin for insightful discussions. This work was supported by the National Research Foundation, Singapore, through a Competitive Research Program grant, the European Union through EURYI and MEXT-CT-2006-039047 grants. Research at the University of Nebraska-Lincoln (UNL) was supported by the National Science Foundation through Nebraska EPSCoR (Grant No. EPS-1010674) and Nebraska MRSEC (Grant No. DMR-0820521). Computations were performed at the UNL Holland Computing Center. The work at Sungkyunkwan University was supported by the National Research Foundation of Korea through Basic Science Research Program (2009-0092809).
Supplementary Figures S1-S3, Supplementary Methods and Supplementary References