Shapeshifting enables a wide range of engineering and biomedical applications, but until now transformations have required external triggers. This prerequisite limits viability in closed or inert systems and puts forward the challenge of developing materials with intrinsically encoded shape evolution. Herein we demonstrate programmable shape-memory materials that perform a sequence of encoded actuations under constant environment conditions without using an external trigger. We employ dual network hydrogels: in the first network, covalent crosslinks are introduced for elastic energy storage, and in the second one, temporary hydrogen-bonds regulate the energy release rate. Through strain-induced and time-dependent reorganization of the reversible hydrogen-bonds, this dual network allows for encoding both the rate and pathway of shape transformations on timescales from seconds to hours. This generic mechanism for programming trigger-free shapeshifting opens new ways to design autonomous actuators, drug-release systems and active implants.
Shape is integral to matter, impacting colour, motility, strength and packing1,2,3,4,5,6,7. In recent years, various shape-memory and shape-changing materials have been developed, enabling programmable actuations in response to external triggers such as a distinct alteration of temperature, pH, light, chemicals and sound8,9,10,11,12,13,14,15,16,17. These materials exhibit both one-way shifting between multiple shapes and two-way reversible transformations18,19,20,21,22, but these changes happen only in response to external trigger events. This requirement prompts a challenging question: Can we design a material that, like a mechanical watch (Fig. 1a), possesses a built-in energy-storage device (spring) and gear-analogues to regulate the rate of energy release? If so, we can envision biomedical implants that undergo an autonomous sequence of shape changes with pre-determined rates.
Here, to realize the watch analogy, in line with the recent studies of temporal control of snapping transformations in bistable structures23, we consider a dynamic polymer network comprising two types of crosslinks (Fig. 1a): (i) a low concentration of covalent crosslinks to form a network, which when deformed, stores the elastic energy that drives shape recovery; (ii) a high concentration of reversible physical crosslinks, which temporarily lock-in new shapes caused by deformations. Due to the time-dependent reorganization of the reversible physical crosslinks, the temporal programming of this dual network enables both sequential and reversible shape transformations, which occur with pre-determined rate and without applying an external trigger.
Theoretical analysis of reversible network
To delineate contributions from the chemical and physical networks to shape control, Fig. 1b presents a theoretical analysis of stress evolution versus time in a dual network undergoing deformation at constant strain rate (Supplementary Discussion, Supplementary Equations 1–28, Supplementary Figs 1 and 2). During deformation (shape programming), the physical network breaks and reforms in a new stress-free configuration25, which results in two plateaus at the Young’s moduli of the physical (EP) and chemical (Ec) networks, respectively. During shape recovery, the rearranged physical network counteracts the restoring force from the chemical network (Ep versus Ec) and secures the temporary shape. The lifetime of the physical crosslinks should be longer than the relaxation time of the chemical network strands to ensure shape recovery over relevant timescales (seconds to hours). The reversibility of physical crosslinks ensures steady shapeshifting and full restoration of the sample’s original shape and mechanical properties.
Design of dual network hydrogel
To prove the concept, we have synthesized hydrogels by copolymerization of N,N-dimethylacrylamide (DMAA) and methacrylic acid (MAAc), which yields a dense H-bonded network integrated with a loose chemical network (Fig. 1c). Due to the hydrophobic methyl substituents, the MAAc and DMAA groups undergo strong association26,27, which leads to the formation of H-bonded clusters yielding particularly tough hydrogels with mechanical properties on par with living cartilage28. For example, a 50:50 MAAc-co-DMAA sample (70 wt% water, pH=3, T=22 °C) gives a E∼30 MPa, fracture energy of ∼9,300 J m−2, and extensibility of ∼600%. These polymer gels undergo full recovery of both shape and all mechanical properties at controlled rates with no external trigger, even after ∼600% pre-rupture deformation (Supplementary Fig. 6).
In agreement with the theoretical predictions (Fig. 1b), mechanical properties of these gels depend on the crosslinking density of the physical network. In Fig. 1d, 50:50 MAAc:DMAA (densest physical network) displays two relaxation transitions separated by a plateau: (i) Rouse relaxation of the network strands () at t∼ms (τ0<t<(m/p)2τ0) and (ii) yielding of the physical network due to dissociation of the H-bonds at t∼min. From the measured moduli of the physical and chemical networks (Supplementary Fig. 7), we have extracted N≅120 and p/m=Ep/NEc≈1, respectively. Within limits of scaling approximation, these molecular parameters predict characteristic timescales t=τ1≈10 s and (Fig. 1b), which are of the same order of magnitude as observed in Fig. 1d. Upon decreasing fraction of the associating groups, the plateau modulus decreases (samples 45:55 and 40:60) and eventually merges with Ec≅105 Pa of the permanent network (30:70). Unlike the theoretical prediction in Fig. 1b, the temporary network plateau is not distinct due to the crossover of the Rouse and Associating Liquid regimes. We could potentially extend the onset of the liquid regime by strengthening the lifetime of H-bonds, but this would shift the shape recovery process to prohibitively long times. In a separate set of experiments, we have shown that Ec increases with chemical crosslink density (Supplementary Fig. 8) and Ep decreases with temperature (Supplementary Fig. 7) due to the dissociation of H-bonds monitored by IR absorption (Supplementary Fig. 9). Temperature affects both concentration and strength of H-bonds due to the entropic contribution to the bond free energy.
Controlling the rate and pathway of shapeshifting
Unlike conventional stimulation methods of shape recovery, for example, by increasing temperature above a specific trigger point, below we demonstrated a new capability to vary the shapeshifting rate by changing programming protocols without a specific alteration of the environmental conditions. Reversible networks provide a range of different protocols for encoding both rate and pathway of shapeshifting (Fig. 2a). Protocol 1 (deformation at controlled strain rates) and Protocol 2 (stress relaxation at controlled times) yield identically stressed samples (see horizontal dashed lines) for the same total programming time (tp), including the durations of the deformation and stress relaxation processes. Protocol 3 (deformation at higher temperature) is a short cut with respect to Protocols 1 and 2, as it allows for faster re-arrangement of the strained physical network, while yielding a shape with the same ‘shape-memory clock’. Although the molecular arrangement of differently programmed networks may be different, the identical true stress at the same strain values suggests the same average crosslink density and leads to similar kinetics of shape recovery (Supplementary Fig. 11a). The restoring stress σ(t, ɛ) is a sum of σc(ɛ)—strain-controlled stress from the permanent chemical network and σp(t)—time-dependent stress of the temporary physical network (Fig. 2a). Samples that are allowed to relax for a longer time have lower internal stress due to re-arrangement of the H-bonded network, and therefore, display slower shape recovery. This effect is demonstrated in Fig. 2b, where a triple hairpin unfolds along two different pathways depending on programming time applied to each individual angle. Note that the observed shape transformations are not triggered by heating samples above a certain threshold temperature, as no thermal transitions are observed in this temperature range (Supplementary Fig. 12). The shape recovery occurs spontaneously at temperatures, which can be equal to, higher, and even lower than the programming temperature. However, the recovery temperature has an effect on the rate of shape recovery (Supplementary Fig. 11b). Unlike the conventional shape-memory polymers which can display partial shape recovery below their programming temperature, our systems restore 100% of the original shape after large deformation (up to 600%) even at T<Tprogramming. Furthermore, due to the temporary stress storage in the transient network, these polymeric gels can be programmed for sequential shapeshifting in reverse directions (Fig. 2c; Supplementary Movie 1). Effectively, the applied programming process results in a system with two transient sub-networks strained in opposite directions. This triple shape-memory (one-way reversible shapeshifting) behaviour occurs at constant temperature, that is, without using a sequence of external triggers as is used in conventional triple shape transitions21. Since the programming and recovery process occurred under the same environmental conditions, we observe a virtually trigger-free shape-memory behaviour. The presented findings suggest that both shape and viscoelasticity of our gels are determined by reversible reorganization of the relaxation of transient H-bonded networks.
To examine a universal relationship between object properties (shape) and molecular properties (network relaxation), we measured the kinetics of shape recovery (Fig. 3a) and examined its correlations with the modulus variations in Fig. 1d. After a quick initial drop in strain, shape recovery follows a single exponential decay with a characteristic time τr, which increases with programming time (Fig. 3a). Upon plotting strain versus t/τr, all curves collapse onto a single curve (inset in Fig. 3a), which points to universality of the molecular mechanisms responsible for the shapeshifting. A shape-recovery process corresponds to a creep test at zero external force, which can be described with a two-network model (Supplementary Discussion; Supplementary Equations 30–40; Supplementary Fig. 13). By using Eyring’s notion of stress-induced shift in bonds lifetime29, the model describes the shape-recovery rate using two fitting parameters: β=vEc/(3kT) and τr (Supplementary Equation 37). All curves in Fig. 3b show the same slope (β=0.9±0.1), whereas the zero-strain intercept (ln(3τr)) depends on the programming time. Note that for long programming times, the recovery time levels off at τr≈1,200 s (Supplementary Fig. 14). From the obtained fitting parameters and independently measured Ec=250 kPa and Ep/Ec≅130 (Supplementary Fig. 8f), we find an activation volume of v=34±4 nm3 and lifetime of the physical crosslinks τ1≅τrEc/Ep=10±2 s. These times agree with the boundaries of the associating liquid regime (Fig. 1b) ranging from t=τ1∼10 s to obtained from the modulus evolution during programming (Fig. 1b,d), and the large activation volume is consistent with the clustering of H-bonds28.
Delayed shape transformation
As shown in Fig. 2b,c, control of the recovery rate allows for programming of different shapeshifting pathways. However, for all protocols discussed above, onset of shape recovery occurs instantly after the release of the external force. The lack of an induction period limits applications that require a controllable lag-time for the deployment of a shape-programmed object. Theoretically, this can be resolved by introducing a network with infinite lifetime during programming and then gradually breaking the network during shape recovery. We resolved this issue by simply introducing a thin skin of dehydrated gel on the surface of a programmed sample through partial drying in ambient air (Fig. 4a). The recovery process is halted until the physical network returns to its dynamic state via re-immersion into an aqueous environment. Controlling the skin thickness allows for encoding a well-defined dormant period enabling shape transformation in a distinct step-wise fashion inside stable closed environments (Fig. 4b; Supplementary Movies 2 and 3; Supplementary Fig. 15). Adding temporal control over the onset time of shapeshifting is a vital advancement, which enables creation of cascading actuator assemblies displaying control of both the initiation and rate of multiple actuations. Figure 4c shows sequential ‘blooming’ of an artificial flower, which has been assembled from individually programed petals (Supplementary Movie 4).
In conclusion, a dual network hydrogel system has been designed to integrate energy storage and controlled energy release, which enables sequential shape transformations without applying an external trigger. Such systems rely on developing a dual network with dynamic bonds, which satisfy the following requirements: (i) a high concentration to provide rigidity to offset the restoring force of the chemical network and secure a temporary shape, (ii) a suitable lifetime, which should be relatively short-lived to allow for spontaneous reconfiguration of the dual network upon release of an external force, and longer than the Rouse relaxation time of the chemical networks strands to ensure shape recovery over practically relevant timescales (seconds to hours). The outlined molecular mechanism of temporal shapeshifting is generic and can be applied to other types of dynamical networks, once the dynamic bonds meet the above requirements30,31,32. Combined with the recent developments in 3D printing of complex shapes33, these time- and route-programmable materials have great potential in biomedical engineering enabling autonomous actuation and minimally invasive surgical procedures34,35,36,37,38.
Dual network hydrogels were synthesized by a one-step copolymerization of DMAA and MAAc with different molar ratios, while the total monomer concentration was 33 wt%. A mixture of above monomer aqueous solution with 0.5 mol% ammonium persulfate and N,N,N’N’-tetramethylethylenediamine (in a concentration relative to the total monomer concentration) was poured into a glass mold with a PDMS spacer and then polymerized at room temperature for 48 h. To achieve a high crosslink density of the physical network for controlling shape-fixation and -recovery rate, we targeted m=1–2.5 through variation of MAAc:DMAAm ratio during polymerization and p≅1 by using low pH=3 of the solvent.
The mechanical tests were carried out on a Dynamic Mechanical Analysis (RSA-G2, TA Instrument) with an Immersion Clamps. Samples with a thickness of 1.6 mm were cut into dogbone shape (DIN 53504-S3, 2 mm in width with an initial length of 12 mm). To enhance reproducibility, all of the mechanical tests were performed in silicone oil with temperature control. Samples were stretched at a certain strain rate at a defined temperature. For shape programming, sample was stretched to a strain of 50% at a certain strain rate and then held at 50% strain for a defined time. Next, the sample was set to isoforce mode where the external force was set to be constantly at zero and then the strain change over time during the recovery process was recorded.
Further details on the methods are available in the Supplementary Methods.
The data that support the findings of this study are available from the corresponding author on request.
How to cite this article: Hu, X. et al. Programming temporal shapeshifting. Nat. Commun. 7, 12919 doi: 10.1038/ncomms12919 (2016).
The authors gratefully acknowledge funding from the National Science Foundation (DMR 1122483, DMR 1407645, DMR 1436201, and DMR 1409710). The FTIR-ATR test was performed in the Instrumentation Facility of UNC-EFRC for Solar Fuels, funded by the U.S. Department of Energy, DE-SC0001011. We also thank Drs Edward Samulski and Stephen Craig for illuminating discussions and reviewing the manuscript.