Hydrogen, the simplest element in the universe, has a surprisingly complex phase diagram. Because of applications to planetary science, inertial confinement fusion and fundamental physics, its high-pressure properties have been the subject of intense study over the past two decades. While sophisticated static experiments have probed hydrogen’s structure at ever higher pressures, studies examining the higher-temperature regime using dynamic compression have mostly been limited to optical measurement techniques. Here we present spectrally resolved x-ray scattering measurements from plasmons in dynamically compressed deuterium. Combined with Compton scattering, and velocity interferometry to determine shock pressure and mass density, this allows us to extract ionization state as a function of compression. The onset of ionization occurs close in pressure to where density functional theory-molecular dynamics (DFT-MD) simulations show molecular dissociation, suggesting hydrogen transitions from a molecular and insulating fluid to a conducting state without passing through an intermediate atomic phase.
The insulator-metal transition in hydrogen has been a central problem in physics since Wigner and Huntington’s 1935 prediction of a transformation of insulating molecular hydrogen to a monatomic conducting state at high pressure1. In recent decades, owing to fundamental questions about the structure of gas giants2,3,4,5,6, hydrogen’s high-pressure properties have been the subject of intense study. Diamond anvil cell experiments have explored the low-temperature, high-pressure structure of hydrogen. It has been shown to remain in an insulating, molecular state at pressures in excess of 300 GPa (ref. 7) and recent work has focused on its phases near room temperature8,9,10,11,12,13. Sophisticated ab initio simulation techniques have advanced in tandem, resulting in a wide computational exploration of the hydrogen phase diagram, see McMahon and coauthors14.
High-pressures produced by dynamic compression techniques generally result in higher-temperature conditions. Experiments using reverberating shock waves to produce conductive liquid hydrogen at 140 GPa and temperatures near 3,000 K (refs 15, 16), reached densities very close to those predicted by Wigner and Huntington17. Recent experiments using the Sandia Z machine reached 300 GPa and 1,800 K, finding evidence for a liquid–liquid insulator-metal transition from optical reflectivity measurements18. In single-shock experiments, the temperatures reached are still higher, and the transition to metallic behaviour is driven by the combined pressure and temperature reached in the shock front. These experiments produce thermodynamic states lying on the primary shock Hugoniot. Optical reflectivity measurements have been used to observe a transition to metallic behaviour in laser-driven samples near 50 GPa and 8,000 K (ref. 19). X-ray scattering makes it possible to directly observe electron properties in such an experimental configuration, but until now it has not progressed beyond proof-of-principle in shock-compressed cryogenic samples20. In this work, we use a single-shock laser compression scheme, employing x-ray scattering to directly measure the ionization of laser-shocked deuterium as a function of compression.
Dynamic experiments along the principal Hugoniot result in target conditions far from the region where a first-order liquid–liquid phase transition from molecular to conducting fluids has been predicted21,22. We illustrate this in the hydrogen phase diagram shown in Fig. 1, which shows that most parts of the interiors of brown dwarfs (Gliese-229b, shown in brown) and giant planets (Jupiter, shown in black) are also at off-Hugoniot states. However, the P - T range of our experiments covers one of the most interesting parts of the Jovian interior. The flattening of the isentrope at ∼25 GPa is due to the dissociation of the hydrogen molecules. As shown by French et al.23, this is accompanied by a drastic increase in the dc electrical conductivity which represents a continuous nonmetal-to-metal transition. This result is validated with the x-ray scattering measurements presented in this study, where we find that the average ionization becomes significant just at this point on the Hugoniot curve, and coincident with dissociation. This is of great importance for planetary physics when validating equation of state (EOS) data that are used for interior2,23 and dynamo models24.
Inelastic x-ray scattering has a long history as a powerful probe of material properties in static samples. Recently, x-ray scattering has been employed in high-energy density physics experiments25 using laser-produced x-ray sources to measure density and temperature in targets dynamically shocked to warm, dense conditions26,27,28,29. Experiments at the Omega laser have demonstrated the viability of backscattering techniques for density measurements in cryogenic deuterium20. Here we combine forward and backward x-ray scattering observations with a simultaneous measurement of shock velocity using the velocity interferometry system for any reflector (VISAR) technique to infer pressure and mass density from the velocity of the shock and EOS tables. With a delocalized electron density measured using x-ray scattering, we can then directly determine the ionization state of shocked deuterium as a function of compression. We compare the onset of ionization with the molecular dissociation fraction calculated from density functional theory-molecular dynamics (DFT-MD) simulations and find that both quantities increase sharply between compressions of 2.5≤ρ/ρ0≤3.3.
Experiment design and layout
X-ray scattering is sensitive to both the electron and ion structure in the target. The scattering cross section depends on the total dynamic structure factor of the material that, in the case of dense plasma conditions, is often expressed using a chemical picture approach due to Chihara30,31 as . Here k is the wave-vector probed, f(k) is the ionic form factor, q(k) represents the electron screening cloud around the ion and Zf (Zb) is the number of free (bound) electrons per atom. Sii and See0 represent the dynamic structure contributions of ions and free electrons; transitions of bound electrons into the continuum, Sce, are modulated by the motion of the ions, represented by SS.
In the non-relativistic limit, the probe energy and experimental geometry define the k-vectors probed according to . Our experiments probe density fluctuations at scale lengths of k=7.78 × 109 m−1 in the forward direction and 1.88 × 1010 m−1 in the backward direction. The scattering process can be defined with the parameter α=1/kλS, where λS represents the screening length in the plasma. For the strongly degenerate systems studied in this work, the screening length can be approximated with the Thomas–Fermi length, and where ne is the free-electron density. Thus, for our conditions, the forward scattering vector extends beyond the screening length and provides collective scattering even at small ionization fractions32, while the backward scattering vector is sufficiently long to probe at a scale length smaller than the screening length of the plasma, observing the electron momentum distribution in the Compton limit33.
A series of cryogenic experiments was performed at the Janus Laser Facility at the Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, a schematic of which is shown in Fig. 2. A drive laser was focused onto a cryogenic target, launching a shock wave into liquid deuterium at an initial density ρ0=0.17±0.004 g cm−3. A second laser, incident on a Si3N4 foil fixed to the target at an intensity of 1 × 1014 W cm−2 and wavelength of 527 nm, created an intense x-ray source by pumping the 2 keV Ly-α line in Si (ref. 34; Supplementary Fig. 1 and Supplementary Methods). These photons were collimated through a 400-μm-diameter aperture in the target, timed to probe the shock as it reached the x-ray collection ports. The x-rays were scattered from the shock front and collected through 400 μm ports at 45° and 135° from the incident photons. The probe pulse was delayed 10–20 ns after the rise of the drive beam, allowing the shock to traverse a distance of 350 μm to reach the volume accessed by the x-ray diagnostic port. The fields of view of the spectrometers were shielded with Ni-coated cones (40° opening angle) from ambient x-ray emission and stray light from both laser beams. The radiation was collected and spectrally dispersed with highly ordered pyrolytic graphite crystal spectrometers35 curved at a 107-mm radius.
The drive laser beam used a phase plate to produce a round 600-μm-diameter spot on target. The forward scattering measurements were made on deuterium shock-driven by a frequency-doubled 2-ns-long laser pulse producing a wavelength of 527 nm at the target. The backscattering measurements were made operating the same laser at the 1,054 nm fundamental. These shots used 4 ns drive pulses at moderate compression and 6 ns at higher compression, all at nominal intensities of 4 × 1013 W cm−2.
The drive laser was incident on a CH-coated aluminium layer ranging from 12 to 40 μm in thickness, depending on intended shock pressure. The CH layer was ablated in the laser-target interaction, driving a shock wave into the Al pusher that released into the D2 layer. The aluminium shielded the bulk D2 from hot electrons and x-rays produced in the laser-solid interaction that could preheat the target before the shock arrived.
Shock velocity and inferred compression
Since deuterium becomes optically reflective under shock compression, the shock velocity can be directly measured using the VISAR technique36,37. For this purpose, we propagated a 532-nm VISAR probe beam anti-parallel to the drive beam along the axis of the shock through the rear window. The reflected signal from the D2 shock front was collected and sent to two interferometers, coupled to optical streak cameras. These provided two 20-ns-long channels showing the evolution of shock velocity on each shot. Using two interferometers of differing sensitivities allowed the absolute velocity to be determined in spite of the discontinuity in phase caused by the shock.
To determine the mass density—and hence compression ρ/ρ0—of the target using measured shock velocity, one of two approaches is necessary. Impedance matching techniques can be used to determine particle velocity in addition to shock velocity, closing the Rankine–Hugoniot relations38,39,40 and directly constraining state variables in the target. Alternatively, existing theoretical models or measured EOS values can be used to calculate compression from the shock velocity measured with VISAR; that is the approach used in this study. While one of several modern EOS models could be effectively used, we have chosen the quotidian EOS (ref. 41) because of its computational efficiency and the fact that it represents a middle ground between popular EOS models in the pressure regime of interest. Because we rely on an EOS that is not perfectly known, this approach requires careful accounting for that uncertainty in our inferred compression. Hicks et al.42 gave a comparison of both calculated and measured EOS values and their associated experimental uncertainties. For our experimental conditions, variations in EOS models are relatively small; near 15 GPa, where we observe the onset of ionization, models vary by about 10% in compression at a given pressure (Supplementary Fig. 2 and Supplementary Methods). This uncertainty is included in the error bar of quoted values of mass density.
Figure 3 shows a VISAR streak record along with the extracted shock velocities for high-power laser drive conditions. Also shown are simulation results from HYDRA, a radiation-hydrodynamics code widely used for modelling inertial confinement fusion and laser-plasma experiments43. HYDRA accurately reproduces the measured late-time shock velocities when scattering is performed. Stray light from the drive beam is visible for 2 ns early in the streak. Shock breakout from the Al pusher into D2 occurs near the end of the drive beam where a discontinuous fringe shift is visible. As the shock decays, a drop in signal amplitude is visible in the raw data, since reflectivity falls as shock pressure and ionization decrease. The peak velocity immediately following shock breakout from the pusher is 22 km s−1 with pressures near 50 GPa, which decays to 14±1 km s−1 and 15+3.5/−4.5 GPa at 21 ns, the centre of the 2-ns-long x-ray probe.
X-ray scattering spectra
Figure 4 shows collective scattering data measured with the forward spectrometer for two shock conditions. The upper spectrum is taken from the same shot as Fig. 3, with a compression of ρ/ρ0=3.2+0.2/−0.3 at the time of x-ray probing, while the lower spectrum used a lower laser intensity drive to reach ρ/ρ0=2.8+0.3/−0.4. At this lower drive condition, no inelastic feature is visible above the noise and spectral resolution of the detector, placing an upper bound on ionization state of Z≤0.04.
At the higher drive condition, a downshifted plasmon feature is visible centred at 1,998 eV below the probe energy of E0=2,005 eV. The plasmon resonance in this low-temperature regime experiences very little damping and is therefore quite narrow. The presented fit curves include broadening due to collisional effects calculated in the local-field-corrected Born-Mermin approximation, which goes beyond the random phase approximation to the dynamical structure factor by including electron–electron interactions and electron–ion collisions in the Born approximation27,44. The spectrum is convolved with the instrument function introduced by the highly ordered pyrolytic graphite crystal and detector. The broad low-energy tail may be explained by bound-free transitions, whose fit includes density- and temperature-dependent continuum lowering. A best fit to the data indicates a delocalized electron density of ne=2.5±0.4 × 1022 cm−3 due to the free-electron density-sensitive plasmon shift at 7 eV. Combined with the mass density inferred from the VISAR trace, this corresponds to an average ionization state of Z=0.15±0.04. The measured electron density corresponds to a Fermi temperature of TF=3.1 eV. For typical temperatures of a fraction of an electron volt, the electrons are therefore strongly degenerate, with , and a scattering parameter of α=1.5.
Figure 5 shows the 135° backscattered spectrum from another shot using a 4-ns laser drive, and a probe beam delay of 15 ns. HYDRA calculations using an intensity profile matched to the velocity measurements shown above predict pressures of 16 GPa and compressions of 3.2+0.2/−0.4, producing target conditions very close to those achieved in the plasmon scattering case. The ratio of elastic to inelastic scattering is strongly dependent on the ionization of the target; with increasing average ionization, the inelastic scattering contribution from free electrons grows relative to the remaining elastic signal. Fits are shown in Fig. 5a for ionizations Z=0.1–0.5 and a best fit is achieved for ne=2.4 × 1022 cm−3. This corresponds Z=0.15±0.08, in good agreement with the plasmon data. At these conditions, the scattering parameter is α=0.63.
For non-collective scattering, the theoretical models used to describe the bound-free contribution can have a significant effect on the inelastic spectrum. In the present case where weakly bound electrons in the compressed deuterium occupy states near the continuum, continuum depression plays a particularly important role. To minimize any ambiguity introduced by this model dependence, we have compared our results, which use a Stewart-Pyatt (SP) model45 for ionization potential depression, with a set of calculations using the Eckert-Kröll (EK)46 model. The resulting curves are shown in Fig. 5b, with the SP model in red and the EK model in blue. The contribution to the spectrum from bound-free scattering are shown separately as dashed curves, illustrating that the primary difference comes through the shift of the EK feature towards E0. We attribute this to a much higher value of continuum depression calculated by the EK model, ΔEEK=10.2 eV compared with ΔESP=2.1 eV for SP. We note that in both cases a best fit is found for an ionization state of Z=0.15 (Supplementary Figs 3 and 4 and Supplementary Methods). We conclude that, for very similar experimental drive conditions, plasmon and Compton scattering provide nearly identical ionization states; this is significant because the sensitivity of plasmon spectra and Compton scattering spectra to bound-free models and structure factors is very different. This finding indicates that contributions from bound-free scattering and interband transitions are accounted for by our data analysis and that interband transitions play a minor role in the interpretation of the data.
Figure 6 summarizes measurements of ionization across several shock-drive and probe delay conditions producing compressions between ρ/ρ0=2.8 and ρ/ρ0=4.05. Measured ionization states for both forward and backscattered configurations are shown as a function of compression, along with predicted ionizations from several models. The compression values for the backscattering data points and the lowest compression case, where velocity measurements are not possible below the onset of optical reflectivity, were determined using hydrodynamic calculations benchmarked to VISAR measurements. The error bars in compression for these points include a 20% uncertainty in drive intensity and uncertainty between EOS models at the relevant pressures. The data indicate a sharp onset of ionization between 3 and 3.5 times compression.
This onset is reproduced by average-atom simulations of a D ion system embedded in a plasma background47, but with lower absolute ionization values. The Thomas–Fermi model exhibits very little of the density dependence in the data at low compression. Similar results have been reported in x-ray scattering experiments on shock-compressed CH (ref. 48). We also show the deuterium dissociation curve calculated with the code FVT, a chemical picture model based on fluid variational theory49 that predicts the onset of molecular dissociation at higher compressions than measured here.
Theoretical models for dense matter can be divided into chemical and physical-picture models. In the chemical picture, ions, atoms and molecules are treated as elementary members of the ensemble, while in the physical picture, nuclei and electrons are treated as elementary particles and bound states are long-lived correlations between them. While ab initio physical picture theories represent the state-of-the-art in simulating hydrogen under extreme conditions, an explicit definition of ionization within a physical-picture model is difficult in pressure and temperature regimes where electron delocalization and finite temperatures blur the characteristics of free and bound electrons. To provide a comparison to our measurements we have calculated the dissociation of deuterium molecules along the Hugoniot using DFT-MD (ref. 50). DFT-MD couples a finite-temperature treatment of electrons using density functional theory with a molecular dynamics treatment of ion motion. The dissociated fraction, shown in red in Fig. 6, is estimated by tracking neighbouring ions in the system as the simulation evolves in time (Supplementary Figs 5 and 6 and Supplementary Methods). The fraction of dissociated molecules in the calculations matches the fraction of measured ions closely, suggesting that the processes of dissociation and ionization occur nearly simultaneously along the Hugoniot, see also refs 21, 22, 23.
To facilitate further comparison between our simulations and experimental results, optical reflectivity and dynamic conductivity were calculated from the DFT-MD results. Figure 7a shows reflectivity calculated along the principal Hugoniot (Supplementary Fig. 7 and Supplementary Note 1). Comparisons are made at 808 nm with the results of Celliers et al.19 and at 532 nm with the recent measurements by Loubeyre et al.51. Good agreement is found between experiment and theory. Between 20 and 50 GPa, DFT-MD is seen to produce somewhat higher reflectivities than the Loubeyre results, attributable to the fact that DFT-MD underestimates the bandgap systematically using exchange-correlation functionals like that of Perdew, Burke, and Ernzerhof (ref. 52), leading to early bandgap closure and an earlier onset of dissociation and, thereby, conduction. In Fig. 7b, the dynamic conductivity along the Hugoniot is plotted at a pressure range corresponding to our experimental conditions. The DC limit is plotted in the inset, showing that conductivity starts at very small values near 0.1 S m−1 at 2.8 × compression (black curve), rising orders of magnitude to a metallic conductivity of 105 S m−1 near fourfold compression (yellow curve). This confirms the continuous transition from an insulating molecular fluid to a metallic degenerate electron liquid observed in the experiments.
More broadly, this work demonstrates the viability of combining x-ray spectroscopic and optical velocity measurements to make detailed inferences into the electronic states of a variety of materials compressed to pressures relevant to planetary science. As fourth-generation light sources come online, we expect these results to lead to an unprecedented exploration of the high-pressure structure of hydrogen and other light elements and allow experimental determination of such properties as interior temperature profiles and core erosion in giant planets.
How to cite this article: Davis, P. et al. X-ray scattering measurements of dissociation-induced metallization of dynamically compressed deuterium. Nat. Commun. 7:11189 doi: 10.1038/ncomms11189 (2016).
The authors thank the Jupiter Laser Facility staff for facility support and W. Unites for target development and experimental support. This work performed under the auspices of the (US) Department of Energy (DOE) by Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory (LLNL) under Contract No. DE-AC52- 07NA27344 and supported by Laboratory Directed Research and Development (LDRD) Grant 11-ER- 050. P.D. was supported by the NNSA SSGF programme. A.B., B.H., P.S. and R.R. acknowledge support from the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG) within the SFB 652 and the BMBF via the FSP-301. A.B. performed calculations within the grant mvp00008 at the North-German Supercomputing Alliance (HLRN). This work was supported by DOE Office of Science, Fusion Energy Science under FWP 100182.
Supplementary Figures 1-7, Supplementary Note 1, Supplementary Methods and Supplementary References.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 4.0 International License. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons license, unless indicated otherwise in the credit line; if the material is not included under the Creative Commons license, users will need to obtain permission from the license holder to reproduce the material. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/