High-efficiency thermoelectric materials require a high conductivity. It is known that a large number of degenerate band valleys offers many conducting channels for improving the conductivity without detrimental effects on the other properties explicitly, and therefore, increases thermoelectric performance. In addition to the strategy of converging different bands, many semiconductors provide an inherent band nestification, equally enabling a large number of effective band valley degeneracy. Here we show as an example that a simple elemental semiconductor, tellurium, exhibits a high thermoelectric figure of merit of unity, not only demonstrating the concept but also filling up the high performance gap from 300 to 700 K for elemental thermoelectrics. The concept used here should be applicable in general for thermoelectrics with similar band features.
Thermoelectric devices, which enable a direct conversion between heat and electricity based on either Seebeck or Peltier effects, have attracted increasing interest as a sustainable and emission free solution to the imminent global energy crisis and environment pollution for a few decades1. The performance of a thermoelectric material is determined by the dimensionless figure of merit, zT=S2σT/(κE+κL), where S, σ, κE, κL, and T are the Seebeck coefficient, electrical conductivity, electronic thermal conductivity, lattice thermal conductivity and absolute temperature, respectively.
Because the electrical properties including S, σ and κE couple with each other strongly, a simple improvement in one of these three parameters usually leads to a compensation in the other two, resulting in the difficulty for enhancing zT. Minimizing the lattice thermal conductivity (κL), the only one independent material property, has been proven to be effective through nanostructuring2,3,4,5,6, liquid phonons7,8 and lattice unharmonicity9,10 in the recent 15 years.
Alternatively, recent band engineering efforts aiming to obtain a high number of degenerated valleys (Nv) (refs 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18), a low carrier inertial mass19 and a weak scattering20,21 has also led to great success in increasing the figure of merit zT (ref. 22). Taking the strategy of increasing Nv by converging two different valence (or conduction) bands in the k-space as an example, which has been well-demonstrated in p-type PbTe (ref. 15) and other IV–VI (ref. 23) semiconductors, zT has found to be increased significantly.
A straightforward understanding on how band convergence leading to high thermoelectric performance, is the increased conducting channels for high electrical conductivity, without affecting the Seebeck coefficient that is determined by the position of Fermi level and scattering mechanism11. Being slightly different from the band convergence where two or more band branches having similar energy but unnecessarily the same k-space location, nested bands have not only similar energy but also the same k-space location. In spite of the difference in k-space location between band convergence and nestification, the aligned bands in both cases should equally contribute to the transport of charge carriers, leading to a superior electrical performance for high thermoelectric efficiency.
Band nestification often occurs in well-known simple semiconductors such as group IV elements and III–V compounds, particularly in p-type conduction, this is mainly due to the splitting of degenerate bands by spin-orbit interaction24. This interesting band feature has led these materials to be playing important roles in the electronic industry for many decades, and many of these semiconductors have actually been considered as thermoelectrics since they are known25, although the relative low atomic mass for the constitute elements and the simple crystal structure may lead to a high lattice thermal conductivity25,26,27.
As an important member among the elemental semiconductors, trigonal Te with the P3121 space group undergoes a transition to a topological insulator phase28. However, it has been much less considered as a thermoelectric material.29,30,31 Available experimental results are limited to the electrical properties29,30,31,32 and low temperature thermal conductivity only33,34. Providing its intrinsically nested valence bands30,32,35,36, which are very similar to those of group IV and III–V semiconductors, as superior electronic performance can then be reasonably expected in tellurium. In addition, the relatively heavy atomic mass and the complexity in crystal structure in tellurium, as compared with the well-studied group IV and III–V semiconductors, should lead to a much lower lattice thermal conductivity27.
Guided by the concept of nested bands for high thermoelectric performance, this work focuses on the thermoelectric performance of polycrystalline tellurium, a constitute element commonly used for producing conventional thermoelectrics including PbTe and Bi2Te3. The thermoelectric figure of merit, zT, as high as 1.0, achieved in a material as simple as elemental tellurium, demonstrating the validity of the concept. The achieved zT of ∼1.0 here is actually the highest among the reported element-based thermoelectrics37 including those are heavily alloyed, such as SiGe (refs 38, 39) and BiSb (refs 40, 41, 42). Furthermore, the obtained high zT fills the gap of elemental thermoelectrics showing high zT in the temperature range of 300–700 K as shown in Fig. 1, revealing the importance of tellurium as a thermoelectric material when the application circumstance strictly disallows precipitation, segregation or volatilization.
Band structure of tellurium
It was reported35 as early as in 1950s, followed by a few other researchers in 1970s (refs 30, 32, 36, 43, 44, 45). Very recently, the detailed band structure has been given by theoretical calculations28,46. Regardless the different sources, the most important similarity, among the majority of the literatures, is that the nested valence bands at the H point in the Brillouin zone30,32,36,43,44,45,46 due to the spin-orbit coupling in tellurium. The four-orbital degenerated valence band at point H was split into two upper valence bands H4 and H5 and the lower doubly degenerate band H6 (refs 28, 46). Because the energy separation, either calculated36,43,46 (https://www.materialsproject.org/materials/mp-19/) or measured47, between the two upper valence bands (H4 and H5) is as small as 0.1 eV or less, they both contribute to the hole transport concurrently. On the other hand, the third valence band (H6) has a much lower energy36,43,46 and therefore is not influential to the electrical properties in the temperature and doping ranges studied here. Further due to the spin-orbital coupling, the first valence band, H4, may exhibit a weak camel’s back in shape along the H→K direction36,46. However, this work focuses on the transport properties at temperatures >300 K, the resulting Fermi distribution broadening is significantly larger in energy than the difference between the extremums of the camel’s back H4 band, leading to an unobservable effect on the electrical properties. Therefore, the band structure of Te can be approximated as the inset of Fig. 1 schematically, without including either the low energy H6 band or the camel’s back feature for band H4.
It is then clear that the bands H4 and H5 are effectively nested in tellurium, giving a rise to the conducting channels for holes. This inherent band feature, and its effect on the thermoelectric performance is essentially similar with those caused by band convergence11,22,48, in which the converged bands unnecessarily have band extremum at the same k-space location. In this way, the two upper valence bands, with a valley degeneracy of 2 each, accumulate the hole pockets to a total number of 4 approximately, being comparable with 4∼6 that obtained in n-SiGe, Bi2Te3 and n-PbTe thermoelectrics.
Carrier concentration-dependent transport properties
The transport properties were measured on single phased polycrystalline tellurium samples, where the trigonal structure and an average grain size of ∼100 μm are determined by X-ray diffraction and transmission electron microscope analyses (Supplementary Fig. 1). The transport properties in the directions along and perpendicular to the applied pressure of the hot press, are found to be nearly isotropic (Supplementary Fig. 2). Indeed, the experimental thermoelectric figure of merit, zT, of elemental tellurium is found to be as high as unity, being the highest among the reported element-based thermoelectrics including those are heavily alloyed such as SiGe (refs 38, 39) and BiSb (refs 40, 41, 42). This further leads to a fill-up to the gap of elemental thermoelectrics showing high zT in the temperature range from 300 to 700 K as shown in Fig. 1. The measured zT shows a good reproducibility (Supplementary Fig. 3) and comparability (Supplementary Fig. 4) to that measured by a different technique. The observed discrepancy on zT between the experimental results and the ab initio calculations46 is largely due to the difference on estimating the electronic thermal conductivity.
In nested bands on the transport properties, the Hall carrier concentration dependence is given in Fig. 2. According to the above discussion on the band structure, a two-band (H4 and H5) model is used to understand the transport properties. Furthermore, due to the small band gap in tellurium, the band may be slightly nonparabolic and therefore needs to take into the first order of nonparabolicity (Kane band) into account49. The two Kane band model enables a reasonable prediction (dashed curves) on the hall carrier concentration-dependent Seebeck coefficient (Fig. 2a), Hall mobility (Fig. 2b) and power factor (Fig. 2c). The ab initio calculated46 Seebeck coefficient is slighter higher, which is presumably due to the fact that this method does not take into account the reduction of the band gap with increasing temperature30. As a result, the ab initio calculated46 power factor is also higher than the measurement (Supplementary Fig. 5). Similarly, this discrepancy can also be seen from the temperature-dependent transport properties as discussed below.
The Kane band model has shown similar success on understanding the transport properties of n-type PbTe (refs 19, 50, 51). It should be noted that the two-band model takes the band nonparabolicity, temperature-dependent effective mass and band gap30 into account. This model assumes a dominant charge carrier scattering by acoustic phonons, as evidenced in Fig. 2d by the observed temperature dependence of T−1.5 on the Hall mobility (μH), because any other scattering mechanisms such as by grain boundaries, polar-optical phonons, and ionized impurities predict a dependence of μH∼Tp with p≥−0.5. The even faster decrease in the Hall mobility than the μH∼T−1.5 relationship at temperatures higher than 500 K, can be understood by the increased effective mass according to the two-band model.
This model further tells the optimal carrier concentration (nopt) that allows a maximum power factor to be achieved (Fig. 3c), and the resulting nopt is found to be in the range of 1–3 × 1019 cm−3, depending the temperature and density of state effective mass51. The obtained nopt is consistent with the ab initio calculation46, and is comparable with that of narrow band gap (Eg<0.5 eV) thermoelectric semiconductors such as n-PbTe (ref. 51) and Bi2Te3 (ref. 52).
Temperature-dependent transport properties
The temperature-dependent Seebeck coefficient (S) and resistivity (ρ) are shown in Fig. 3a and Fig. 3b, respectively. The doping effectiveness of arsenic can be seen from the significant decrease in both resistivity and Seebeck coefficient when the doping concentration increases. The positive sign of the Seebeck coefficient indicates the p-type conduction, which is consistent with our Hall coefficient measurements. Majority of the samples studied here show degenerated semiconducting behaviour, meaning a continuous increase in both resistivity and Seebeck coefficient with increasing temperature. The decrease in ρ and S at high temperatures can be ascribed to the existence of minority carriers, which is normally seen in narrow band gap semiconductors. The existence of minority carriers also lead to an increase in the high-temperature thermal conductivity, particularly in lightly doped samples.
The temperature-dependent total thermal conductivity and (κ) its lattice contribution (κL) are shown in Fig. 3c and Fig. 3d, respectively. It can be seen from Fig. 3c that due to the effective doping by arsenic, the resulting reduced resistivity (Fig. 3b) leads to an increased electronic thermal conductivity (κE) and therefore the total thermal conductivity. The electronic thermal conductivity can be determined by the Wiedeman–Franz law (κE=LT/ρ), where the temperature-dependent Lorenz factor (L) is estimated by the two-Kane-band model. The lattice thermal conductivity is determined by subtracting the electronic contribution from the total thermal conductivity via (κL=κ−κE). The room temperature lattice thermal conductivity for unintentionally doped tellurium is ∼1.6 Wm−1 K−1, which is comparable with conventional thermoelectric lead chalcogenides21,50,53,54 and bismuth/antimony tellurides52,55, but significantly lower than those of group IV or group III–V semiconudctors38,56. The low lattice thermal conductivity is presumably due to the heavy atomic mass and relatively complex crystal structure27. Importantly, all the heavily doped samples show a nearly identical temperature dependence, and follow a nice T−1 decrease with increasing temperature, indicating a dominant phonon scattering by Umklapp process. According to the Cahill model57, the measured sound velocities (2,287 ms−1 for longitudinal and 1,410 ms−1 for transverse ones, respectively), enable a determination of minimal lattice thermal conductivity (κLmin), which is also shown in Fig. 3d. It can be seen that there should be a reasonably big room for a reduction on κL for an even higher zT through well-demonstrated strategies in thermoelectrics such as solid solution38,58 and nanostructuring2,3,4,5.
In summary, the inherently nested valence bands in tellurium enable an approximate hole pockets of 4, leading to a reasonably high power factor. In combination with its acceptably low thermal conductivity, elemental semiconducting tellurium surprisingly shows a high figure of merit, zT=1.0, and therefore nicely fills up the high performance gap from 300 to 700 K for elemental thermoelectrics. The guiding principle here introduces a pure electronic effect for discovering high thermoelectric performance materials, application of other well-demonstrated independent strategies such as alloying or nanostructruing for decreasing the lattice thermal conductivity, is expected to lead to an even higher zT.
Polycrystalline Te samples were prepared by melting high purity element (>99.99%) at 823 K for 8 h, followed by quenching in cold water and annealing at 673 K for 3 days. Dopants including phosphorus (P), arsenic (As), antimony (Sb) and bismuth (Bi) were used to tune the carrier concentration. It is found that As-doping is the most effective to achieve a high enough carrier concentration that is needed for realizing the high zT at high temperatures, and is therefore focused on in this study. The ingot materials were ground into fine powders and hot pressing59 at 673 K for 20 min under a uniaxial pressure of 90 MPa. The obtained dense pellet samples were a ∼12 mm in diameter and 1.5 mm in thickness.
The phase impurity was characterized by X-ray diffraction (Dandong Haoyuan Instrument Co. LTD). The samples for the transmission electron microscope observation were prepared by mechanical polishing, dimpling and ion milling with liquid nitrogen. STEM images were taken with a JEOL ARM 200 equipped with a probe corrector. The obtained pellet samples showed a density higher than 98% of the theoretical one, where microvoids with a size of microns can be occasionally observed.
Transport property measurements
To be less involved in measurement uncertainties due to the possible hysteresis and the sample dimension determinations, the electrical transport properties including resistivity, Seebeck coefficient and Hall coefficient were simultaneously measured on the same pellet sample during both heating and cooling. The Seebeck coefficient was obtained from the slope of the thermopower versus temperature gradients of 0–5 K (ref. 60). The resistivity and Hall coefficient (RH) were measured using the van der Pauw technique under a reversible magnetic field of 1.5 T. For a comparison, the Seebeck coefficient and resistivity for two high performance samples were also measured using a ULVAC ZEM-3 system. The thermal diffusivity (D) was measured through laser flash method with the Netzsch LFA457 system. The heat capacity (Cp) was assumed to be the Dulong–Petit limit and to be temperature independent, which is consistent with the literature result at room temperature61. The thermal conductivity was calculated via к=dCpD, where d is the density measured using the mass and geometric volume of the pellet. All the transport property measurements were performed under vacuum in the temperature range of 300–650 K. The sound velocity was measured using an ultrasonic pulse-receiver (Olympus-NDT) equipped with an oscilloscope (Keysight). The uncertainty for each measurement of transport property (including S, σ and к) is ∼5%.
How to cite this article: Lin, S. et al. Tellurium as a high performance elemental thermoelectric. Nat. Commun. 7:10287 doi: 10.1038/ncomms10287 (2016).
This work is supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Grant No. 51422208, 11474219 and 51401147), the national Recruitment Program of Global Youth Experts (1000 Plan), the programme for professor of special appointment (Eastern Scholar) at Shanghai Institutions of Higher Learning, the Pujiang Project of Shanghai Science and Technology Commission (13PJ1408400), the fundamental research funds for the central universities and the Bayer-Tongji Eco-Construction and Material Academy (TB20140001). The authors thank Professors Xun Shi and Lidong Chen from the Shanghai Institute of Ceramics, CAS for their support on Seebeck coefficient and resistivity measurements for comparison.
Supplementary Figures 1-5 and Supplementary Reference
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons license, unless indicated otherwise in the credit line; if the material is not included under the Creative Commons license, users will need to obtain permission from the license holder to reproduce the material. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/